JURISDICTION : DISTRICT COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA
IN CIVIL
LOCATION: PERTH
CITATION: RGB INTEGRATION PTY LTD -v- AUDIO VISUAL IMAGENATION PTY LTD [2009] WADC 165
CORAM: SCOTT DCJ
HEARD: 3, 4, 5 AUGUST 2009, 22 OCTOBER 2009
DELIVERED : 4 NOVEMBER 2009
FILE NO/S: CIV 1256 of 2004
BETWEEN: RGB INTEGRATION PTY LTD (ACN 089 691 261)
Plaintiff
AND
AUDIO VISUAL IMAGENATION PTY LTD (ACN 052 517 718)
Defendant
Catchwords:
Contract for supply of electrical components for courtroom - Extent to which representations were promissory and were terms of contract - Breach of contract - Turns on own facts
Legislation:
Nil
Result:
Judgment for plaintiff
Defendant's counterclaim dismissed
Representation:
Counsel:
Plaintiff: Mr M Holler
Defendant: Mr M L Segler
Solicitors:
Plaintiff: Formbys Lawyers
Defendant: Martin Lee Segler Barrister and Solicitor
Case(s) referred to in judgment(s):
Hospital Products Ltd v United States Surgical Corporation (1984) 156 CLR 41
SCOTT DCJ: In this case the plaintiff claims the sum of $46,836.90 being the price of various electronic components which were supplied by the plaintiff to the defendant between 2 May 2003 and 19 August 2003.
Although the defendant did not, in its substituted defence and counterclaim dated 19 December 2008 ("substituted defence and counterclaim"), specifically plead to each of the paragraphs in the statement of claim I was advised by counsel for the defendant at the commencement of this trial that save for the defendant's set‑off which was ultimately pleaded in an amended substituted defence and counterclaim dated 6 August 2009 ("substituted defence, set off and counterclaim"), the defendant admits the plaintiff's entitlement to the sum claimed by it in the statement of claim.
The principal electrical component supplied by the plaintiff to the defendant was an Extron 2424HV 425Mhz – 24 x 24 RGBHV switcher (the "24 x 24 Matrix switcher"). The other items comprising the electronic components supplied by the plaintiff to the defendant were ancillary to the 24 x 24 Matrix switcher.
In the substituted defence, set off and counterclaim the defendant alleges that:
"3.At all material times the defendant was contracted to the Department of Justice and the Government of Western Australia to provide a fully operational electronic courtroom with the ability to video link to remote witnesses, video conference to locations worldwide and electronic document display.
PARTICULARS
(a)On 18 December 2000, the defendant together with Spark & Cannon Pty Ltd and the Ministry of Housing and Works representing the State of Western Australia entered into a contract in writing numbered 75000 for the provision of court monitoring services transcription and support of audiovisual technologies for the Western Australian Ministry of Justice, Courts and Tribunals ('Contract 75000').
(b)Further to Contract 75000, the defendant by document RFT 1909 of 2003 tendered to the Department of Justice for the installation of an electronic courtroom at 111 St Georges Terrace Perth which tender was accepted.
4.On 10 April 2003 the Defendant was informed by the Plaintiff as to the availability of an RGBHV 24 x 24 Matrix switcher which had…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read RGB Integration Pty Ltd v Audio Visual Imagenation Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2009] WADC 165
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court held that the representations made by the plaintiff were not promissory and did not form part of the contract. The court found that the evidence given by the defendant's witnesses did not support the claims made in the defence. The court also held that the plaintiff was not liable for the costs claimed by the defendant, except for the cost of the replacement Matrix switcher, the airfare and accommodation for the software engineer, and the cost of the software developer. The court found that the other costs claimed by the defendant were not recoverable as there was insufficient evidence to support the claims. The court ordered that the plaintiff was not liable to pay the defendant any damages.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The representation was not a contractual promise such that it formed part of the agreement in that it was not promissory in nature (Hospital Products Ltd v United States Surgical Corporation (1984) 156 CLR 41 at 61 and the cases there cited). The evidence given by Mr Hammond was not to the effect pleaded in par 5 of the substituted defence set off and counterclaim. Mr Hammond gave evidence that his conversation with the (unnamed) representative of the plaintiff Mr Hammond requested pricing on a 24 x 24 Matrix switcher, he did not recall discussing the May Holman Centre, there was no discussion as to the input sync impedance and the extent to which reference was made to a courtroom installation was that he said that he told that representative that the Matrix switcher was for a courtroom installation and the defendant needed to have more inputs and more outputs, there being no reference to switchability. In any event, I am not satisfied on the evidence that the 128 HVA Matrix switchers installed in the District Court rooms in the May Holman Centre had switchability on each input. To that end:(a)There was no material in the form of a catalogue or the like in evidence which might relate to the switchable capacity of the 128 HVA Matrix switchers available in 1998/9. The 1998/1999 catalogue (Exhibit 9) does not refer to the input sync impedance being switchable and the 1999/2000 catalogue refers to the 128 HVA switchers being suitable only on inputs 1 – 4. (b)Mr Routledge gave evidence that in the May Holman Centre each input was identical. He said that each of the 12 inputs were able to develop a 75 ohms circuit by way of a switch that switches that feature on (T30). On the other hand Mr Booth gave evidence that to his knowledge no switcher which had been manufactured by Extron had an entirely switchable capacity.(c)Although Mr Routledge said that Mr Boyes had visited May Holman Centre in relation to the installation of the 128 HVA switchers in or about 1999, Mr Boyes was not questioned on that issue and in any event said that he had not previously heard of the May Holman Centre. Had the defendant established its claim for breach of the agreement pleaded by it, the damages, to which it would have been entitled are, in my view, as follows. The defendant filed a schedule of damages dated 14 May 2009 referable to the plea in par 14 of the substituted defence set off and counterclaim. 1.(a) Administration and site attendances (par 14(a) and (b)) in the sum of $20,700 – provision of technicians at Court 14.1 to facilitate manual patching of signals.The evidence from Mr Routledge (T 41) was that the defendant did not consider that item to be a chargeable item to its customer and so records were not kept by way of job sheet or otherwise. He said that there were a number of persons, including him, employed by the defendant who were required to be on site for this purpose.(b)Mr Alexander Wade gave evidence. He is the business development manager for the defendant having been employed by the defendant in 2005.(c)He said that he was first involved with the installation of electronic componentry in Supreme Court room 14.1 when he was State manager of Spark & Cannon and subsequently as business development manager for the defendant.(d)There was no evidence given by Mr Wade with respect to the claim under this head of $20,706.10 nor was there any evidence given by Mr Routledge with respect to this claim. This claim is not made out.2.Cost of Matrix switcher (May Holman Centre) withheld by the plaintiff from the defendant in the sum of $9,088.25. This claim is not pursued by the defendant.3.The cost to the defendant of a replacement Matrix switcher in the sum of $50,892.50 exclusive of GST (par 14(d)):(a)Mr Routledge gave evidence that the 24 x 24 Matrix switcher was returned to the plaintiff at the earliest opportunity once the Bell Resources trial was completed. The 24 x 24 Matrix switcher was removed and replaced with a unit manufactured by Kramer. Mr Routledge said that he sought quotes from competitors and selected the Kramer Matrix switcher having regard to the capability of the switcher and its ability to integrate into the existing system. (b)The sum claimed by the defendant is $50,892.50 exclusive of GST. Exhibit B is an invoice from Kramer for a 32 x 32 3 chan/2 sync switcher in the total sum of $44,715. Exhibit A is the defendant's job sheet in which this item is included and in respect to which it is marked up by the defendant by 20 per cent. There was no evidence before me as to why the sum was marked up by the defendant. There is no evidence that the loss to the defendant was any more than the price paid by it for the replacement switcher. That is the extent of the claim capable of being maintained by the defendant.(c)There was no evidence led by the plaintiff that a Matrix switcher has a particular lifespan or would be likely to be upgraded in any event – having regard to the fact that the 24 x 24 Matrix switcher had been utilised in Court 14.1 for six years or so. In my view the defendant would bear the evidentiary burden of adducing evidence if it wished to contend that the price for the replacement switcher was unreasonable. It has not done so. The sum of $44,715 is the appropriate amount under this head.4.In respect of par 14(e):(a)The cost to the defendant of airfares and accommodation to facilitate the attendance of the software engineer. To that end Mr Routledge said that Mr John White of White Noise was a programmer engaged to change the software to accommodate the replacement switcher. The cost of his airfare is Exhibit D and is the sum of $1,360.79 including GST. In Exhibit 1 the defendant has again marked up the airfare, this time by 25 per cent which I do not consider recoverable. The defendant would not be entitled to any sum greater than the cost to it viz $1,360.79.In addition, accommodation costs for Mr White totalled $690 which is a recoverable sum. The mark-up claimed by the defendant is not.(b)The cost to the defendant of a software developer to integrate the replacement for the 24 x 24 Matrix switcher being $7,500 exclusive of GST. Exhibit E is an invoice from White Noise Products for the sum of $6,600 inclusive of GST. The mark-up of 20 per cent in Exhibit 1 is not allowed. The sum of $6,600 is the extent of the loss to which the defendant is entitled.(c)The cost to the defendant of the removal of the 24 x 24 Matrix switcher and the installation of the replacement for the 24 x 24 Matrix switcher including but not limited to administration, labour, testing and the commissioning of the replacement Matrix switcher being $8,855 exclusive of GST.In this regard the defendant relies upon the evidence of Mr Wade who said that the company's employees recorded their activities on a daily basis and once that entry was recorded that database was used by the defendant to raise timesheets.The relevant timesheet is then transposed to a job sheet being Exhibit A.Mr Wade said that the installation of the replacement switcher commenced on 5 January 2009, system testing commenced on 7 January 2009 and concluded on that day. A further round of testing was conducted on 12 January 2009. The system was finished and operational on 12 January 2009.In the job sheet, namely Exhibit A, the work activities are recorded as commencing on 28 November 2008 and being completed on 2 July 2009.At best, on the evidence, the period 5 January 2009 – 12 January 2009 appears relevant.There is no breakdown of the work undertaken by the named workers. In addition their time has been charged out at a particular rate about which there is no evidence.I can only assume that these persons were employees. Prima facie the hourly rate ought to be commensurate with their salary, i.e. the actual cost to the defendant. In the event that the defendant wishes to allege that these employees were deployed for this task which resulted in them not being able to charge out at a particular rate on other work for which the defendant was then engaged over that period, evidence would need to have been adduced by the defendant in that regard. There is none. I cannot speculate as to the cost to the defendant and cannot therefore make any assessment with respect to this head and it is not allowed.(d)Cost to the defendant of components required for the installation for the replacement Matrix switcher being $667.67 exclusive of GST.There was no invoice raised nor any evidence relating to this item. There is a charge of $500 plus a 25 per cent mark-up in Exhibit A, however there was no evidence nor indication in the job sheet as to how that amount was calculated. There is no invoice which would indicate that the sum was charged by a contractor.In those circumstances this sum is not recoverable.