Review 2 Pty Ltd v Redberry Enterprise Pty Ltd (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 20 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Review 2 Pty Ltd v Redberry Enterprise Pty Ltd (No. 2) [2008] FCA 1805

COSTS – settlement offer and offer of compromise under O 23 of the Federal Court Rules (Cth) purportedly made by respondent/cross-claimant to the applicants/cross-respondents – applicants/cross-respondents rejected offers – O 23 r 11(6) not in operation when the purported offer of compromise was rejected – no presumptive entitlement to indemnity costs under O 23 of the Rules – whether rejection of offers imprudent or unreasonable – whether applicants/cross-respondents advanced groundless contentions – no award of indemnity costs

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 59(4)
Legislative Instruments Act 2003 (Cth) s 12(2)(b).
Federal Court Rules (Cth) O 5 r 11, O 23

Global Brand Marketing Inc v YD Pty Ltd (2008) 76 IPR 161 cited
Coshott v Learoyd [1999] FCA 276 cited
Dukemaster Pty Ltd v Bluehive Pty Ltd [2003] FCAFC 1 referred to
Seven Network Ltd v News Ltd (2007) 244 ALR 374 referred to
John S Hayes & Associates Pty Ltd v Kimberly-Clark Australia Pty Ltd (1994) 52 FCR 201 cited
Colgate-Palmolive Company v Cussons Pty Ltd (1993) 46 FCR 225 cited
Hamod v New South Wales (2002) 188 ALR 659 cited

University of Western Australia v Gray (No 21) [2008] FCA 1056 cited

REVIEW 2 PTY LTD (IN LIQUIDATION) (ACN 067 634 360) and REVIEW AUSTRALIA PTY LTD (ACN 122 295 836) v REDBERRY ENTERPRISE PTY LTD (ACN 093 946 260)

VID 286 OF 2007

KENNY J
28 NOVEMBER 2008
MELBOURNE


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

VID 286 of 2007

BETWEEN:

REVIEW 2 PTY LTD (IN LIQUIDATION) (ACN 067 634 360)
First Applicant/First Cross-respondent

REVIEW AUSTRALIA PTY LTD (ACN 122 295 836)
Second Applicant/Second Cross-respondent

AND:

REDBERRY ENTERPRISE PTY LTD (ACN 093 946 260)
Respondent/Cross-claimant

JUDGE:

KENNY J

DATE OF ORDER:

28 NOVEMBER 2008

WHERE MADE:

MELBOURNE

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The applicants pay the respondent’s costs of the application.

2.The cross-claimant pay the cross-respondents’ costs of the cross-claim.

Note:Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.


The text of entered orders can be located using eSearch on the Court’s website.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

VID 286 of 2007

BETWEEN:

REVIEW 2 PTY LTD (IN LIQUIDATION) (ACN 067 634 360)
First Applicant/First Cross-respondent

REVIEW AUSTRALIA PTY LTD (ACN 122 295 836)
Second Applicant/Second Cross-respondent

AND:

REDBERRY ENTERPRISE PTY LTD (ACN 093 946 260)
Respondent/Cross-claimant

JUDGE:

KENNY J

DATE:

28 NOVEMBER 2008

PLACE:

MELBOURNE

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

INTRODUCTION

  1. On 24 October 2008, the Court dismissed the applicants’ claim against Redberry Enterprise Pty Ltd for infringement of a design registered under the Designs Act 2003 (Cth). I refer to this design as the Review Design. At the same time, the Court also dismissed Redberry’s cross-claim for design registration invalidity: see Review 2 Pty Ltd v Redberry Enterprise Pty Ltd [2008] FCA 1588.

  2. The question of costs now falls for determination.

    FURTHER BACKGROUND…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Review 2 Pty Ltd v Redberry Enterprise Pty Ltd (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] FCA 1805
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Review 2 Pty Ltd v Redberry Enterprise Pty Ltd (No 2), the court was tasked with determining the costs of the proceedings following the resolution of the substantive issues. The dispute involved intellectual property infringement, with Review 2 Pty Ltd as the applicant and Redberry Enterprise Pty Ltd as the respondent. The applicants sought costs associated with their successful application, while Redberry contested the extent of the costs it should bear, particularly regarding its unsuccessful cross-claim. The court had to navigate through the procedural history and settlement offers made by both parties to arrive at a fair costs determination.

The primary legal issue before the court was how to allocate costs between the parties given the procedural history and the settlement offers. The court had to consider the effect of the offers of compromise made by Redberry on the costs order, specifically whether Redberry was entitled to indemnity costs following the unsuccessful outcome of its cross-claim. Redberry argued that its offer of compromise, made in accordance with Order 23 of the Federal Court Rules, entitled it to indemnity costs as the unsuccessful party. The applicants, however, contended that the costs should be allocated based on the usual rule where the unsuccessful party pays the costs of the successful party, without regard to the offers of compromise.

The court analysed the relevant provisions of the Federal Court Rules and concluded that the offers of compromise did not entitle Redberry to indemnity costs. It determined that the provisions concerning indemnity costs after a respondent’s offer of compromise did not apply because the offers were made prior to their commencement. Furthermore, the court found that the applicants’ complete failure in their claim meant that the provision dealing with the applicant's rejection of a respondent's offer did not apply either. Consequently, the court held that the usual rule of costs allocation should be applied, where the unsuccessful party pays the costs of the successful party on both the application and the cross-claim.

In its final orders, the court ruled that Review 2 Pty Ltd and Review Australia Pty Ltd (the applicants) should pay the costs of Redberry Enterprise Pty Ltd in relation to the application. Additionally, Redberry Enterprise Pty Ltd was ordered to pay the costs of the cross-claim incurred by the applicants. This decision underscores the importance of considering the procedural context and the specific terms of any settlement offers when determining costs in litigation.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The applicants pay the respondent’s costs of the application.

2. The cross-claimant pay the cross-respondents’ costs of the cross-claim.

Note:

Background

Background to the litigation

The question of costs now falls for determination.FURTHER BACKGROUND AND SETTLEMENT OFFERS Before considering the question of costs, it is necessary to set out some aspects of the procedural history and settlement offers made by the parties prior to the trial. The details of the settlement offers were included in the parties’ written submissions in support of the costs orders they seek: see O 23 r 8 of the Federal Court Rules (Cth). The proceeding began on 10 April 2007 when the first applicant filed an application and a statement of claim. On 18 May 2007, Redberry filed its defence. Shortly thereafter, by a letter dated 1 June 2007, Redberry, through its then solicitors, Rose Chai Lawyers and Consultants, made an offer to settle the proceeding for the sum of $1,862 – said to be the amount of profit made by Redberry in selling the allegedly infringing garments – plus the first applicant’s reasonable legal costs. This was Redberry’s first settlement offer. The amount offered was said to be the profit made by Redberry on 133 imported garments sold at a price of $20 per garment less $6.00 as costs per garment. The letter also offered Redberry’s undertaking that Redberry would cease to import, distribute or sell the garments. This offer was made “without prejudice except as to costs” and was open until 3.00 pm on 8 June 2007. In the following week, Redberry filed and served an unverified list of documents. On 13 June 2007, Redberry swore its list of documents, which included reference to documents showing that Redberry had made the 133 garment sales as claimed. Redberry said that copies of these documents were sent to the applicants’ solicitors on 25 June 2007. By a letter dated 8 June 2007, the first applicant rejected Redberry’s offer. In that letter, the first applicant offered to settle the matter on the basis that Redberry: (1) provide a written undertaking that it would cease and forever refrain from importing, selling or distributing garments infringing the Review Design; (2) would immediately deliver up any remaining stock of the allegedly infringing garments; and (3) pay the first applicant the sum of $200,000 for damages and costs. On 4 July 2007, the parties attended Court-ordered mediation, which was unsuccessful. By notice of motion dated 11 July 2007, the first applicant sought: (1) leave to join Review Australia Pty Ltd as the second applicant in the proceeding; (2) leave to file an amended defence and amended statement of claim; and (3) summary judgment against Redberry. Also on 11 July 2007, Redberry gave notice that its solicitors on the record had become Clayton Utz. After the hearing of the motion on 10 August 2007, the Court made various orders, including dismissing the motion and granting the first applicant leave to join Review Australia as the second applicant. On 17 August 2007, Redberry filed its amended defence and a cross-claim. On 21 August 2007, Redberry, through Clayton Utz, made an offer of compromise, relying on Order 23 of the Rules. By this offer, Redberry offered to compromise the claim and cross-claim on the basis that: (1) Redberry would pay the sum of $20,000 to the applicants/cross-respondents, plus costs as taxed or agreed; (2) the payment would be made within 28 days after acceptance of the offer; and (3) the offer would be open for acceptance for 14 days beginning on the day after service of the notice. In its covering letter, Redberry stated that the offer was made “[w]ithout prejudice save as to costs”. The letter also stated that the offer was exclusive of costs and that, if accepted, Redberry would also pay the applicants’ costs in respect of the claim and cross-claim, as agreed or taxed on a party and party basis, incurred up to and including the day the offer was accepted.

Decision

Reasons for decision

KENNY J
Issues
1. What are the appropriate costs orders in light of the settlement offers made by the parties?
2. Can Redberry rely on its offer of compromise under Order 23 of the Federal Court Rules to claim indemnity costs?

Held
1. The applicants pay the respondent's costs of the application.
2. The cross-claimant pay the cross-respondents' costs of the cross-claim.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: KENNY J

In relation to the costs of the cross-claim, Redberry submitted that it was to be treated as an “applicant” for the purposes of O 23 of the Rules: see O 5 r 11 and O 23 r 1 (where an “applicant” is defined to include a “cross-claimant” and a “respondent” is defined to include a “cross-respondent”). Accordingly, in reliance on O 23 r 11(4) of the Rules, Redberry submitted that it was entitled to:1.its party/party costs on the cross-claim up to 21 August 2007; and2.its costs on the cross-claim from 22 August 2007 onwards on an indemnity basis.CONSIDERATION The parties agreed that, in proceedings such as this, the Court would ordinarily order that the unsuccessful party or parties pay the costs of successful party or parties on the claim and cross-claim respectively: see, e.g., Global Brand Marketing Inc v YD Pty Ltd (2008) 76 IPR 161. Thus, ordinarily, the applicants would pay Redberry’s costs of the application and Redberry would pay the cross-respondents’ costs of the cross-claim. In this case, however, the position is complicated by Redberry’s offers of settlement. I turn first to Redberry’s latest offer of compromise of 21 August 2007, which invoked O 23 of the Rules. The offer complied with the formal requirements of the order, which are set out in O 23 r 3. The offer also provided a time for acceptance in accordance with O 23 r 5(3). Currently, O 23 r 11(6) of the Rules applies “[i]f … an offer is made by a respondent and not accepted by the applicant; and … the respondent obtains an order or judgment on the claim to which the offer relates as favourable to the respondent, or more favourable to the respondent, than the terms of the offer”. If applicable, this provision creates a presumptive entitlement in the respondent to indemnity costs after 11 am on the day after the offer was made. This provision is, however, a comparatively new one, having commenced operation only on 2 August 2008. The provision cannot apply to Redberry’s offer of compromise, which was made in the preceding year, in August 2007: see Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth), s 59(4) and the Legislative Instruments Act 2003 (Cth), s 12(2)(b). As at August 2007, the only provision in connection with costs following an applicant’s rejection of a respondent’s offer of compromise was O 23 r 11(5), which deals with the position “[i]f … an offer is made by a respondent and not accepted by the applicant; and … the applicant obtains judgment on the claim to which the offer relates not more favourable than the terms of the offer”. If applicable, this provision also creates a presumptive entitlement in the respondent to indemnity costs. The provision cannot apply to Redberry’s offer of compromise, however, because the applicant not only rejected the respondent’s offer but was wholly unsuccessful in the claim. In this circumstance, O 23 r 11(5) of the Rules has no application: see Coshott v Learoyd [1999] FCA 276 at [37] per Wilcox J; Dukemaster [2003] FCAFC 1 at [6] per Sundberg and Emmett JJ; and Seven Network Ltd v News Ltd (2007) 244 ALR 374 at [32] per Sackville J.