Reu and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read

DECISION AND REASONS FOR DECISION [2000] AATA 281

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL      )

)          No Q99/1182

GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE  DIVISION       )      
           Re      REUERA REU        
  Applicant

And    MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS         
  Respondent

DECISION

Tribunal       Deputy President DP Breen, Presidential Member      

Date12 April 2000  

PlaceBrisbane

Decision      The Tribunal sets aside the decision under review and in substitution therefor determines that the applicant REUERA REU be allowed to remain in Australia.   

(Sgd)  DP BREEN
  PRESIDENTIAL MEMBER
CATCHWORDS
IMMIGRATION – deportation – value of deterrence – best interests of the child – balancing of factors – hardship to applicant.

Migration Act 1958 – s 200
Bustescu v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [1999] FCS 1713

REASONS FOR DECISION

12 April 2000        Deputy President DP Breen, Presidential Member                  

  1. This case was heard by me on 27 and 28 January 2000 in Brisbane.  Written submissions were received from Counsel for the applicant on 9 February 2000 and by Counsel for the respondent on 15 February 2000.  The matter was resumed for submissions in reply on 16 February 2000.

  2. Mr Reuera Reu is 26 years of age and a New Zealand citizen. He has been a resident of Australia since June 1995. He seeks a review of a decision by a Delegate of the Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs made on 5 October 1999 to deport him from Australia under Section 200 of the Migration Act 1958.

  3. At the hearing the applicant was represented by Mr Chris Wilson of Counsel who was assisted by Mr Alan Mead.  The respondent Minister was represented by Ms Bridget Quayle, in-house Counsel.

  4. Mr Reu gave oral evidence before me;  so, too, did Mr John Uri, an expert on Pacific Island Culture;  Mr Jeffrey White, a friend and potential employer of the applicant;  Ms Alanna Mead, the applicant's fiancee;  and Mr Alan Mead and Mrs Beverley Mead, Alanna's parents;  Ms Anna Mansell, a family friend;  Mr Ian Rankin, Elder and Session Clerk at Acacia Ridge Presbyterian Church;  Mr Stephen Teale, Pastor of the Acacia Ridge Presbyterian Church;  and Mr Clifford Cumpstay and Mrs Jean Cumpstay, Alanna's grandparents.

  5. The following documents were also received into evidence.

  • Exhibit 1            "T" Documents

  • Exhibit 2            Schedule of charges by the New Zealand Police

  • Exhibit 3            Schedule of charges by the New South Wales Police

  • Exhibit 4            Correctional Services Report

  • Exhibit 5            Statement of Mr R Rue

  • Exhibit 6            Two letters written by Mr Rue to Mr and Mrs Mead

  • Exhibit 7            Bundle of documents including pay slips

  • Exhibit 8            Bundle of documents evidencing completion of courses whilst in

    Prison

  • Exhibit 9            Transcript of submissions on sentencing

  • Exhibit 10          Cards from Mr Rue to his fiancee and son

  • Exhibit 11          Indictments for deportation offences

  • Exhibit 12          Confirmation of release date

  • Exhibit 13          Family photographs

  • Exhibit 14          Reference from Alanna Mead's employer

  • Exhibit 15          Statement of Mr I Rankin

  • Exhibit 16          References from Mr S Teale and Notice of Intention to Marry

  • Exhibit 17          Statement of Beverley Mead

  • Exhibit 18          Statement of Mrs…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Reu and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2000] AATA 281
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Reu and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs involved Mr Reuera Reu, a New Zealand citizen residing in Australia, who was seeking a review of a decision to deport him under Section 200 of the Migration Act 1958. The decision was made by a delegate of the Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs on 5 October 1999. The applicant’s counsel, Mr Chris Wilson, was assisted by Mr Alan Mead, while the Minister was represented by Ms Bridget Quayle. The applicant gave oral evidence, as did several other witnesses, including his fiancée and her parents, an expert on Pacific Island Culture, a friend, and church elders. The case hinged on the balance between the deterrence value of deportation and the best interests of the child, considering the hardship deportation would cause to the applicant and his fiancée.

The court had to decide whether the deportation order was justified under the Migration Act 1958, particularly considering the seriousness of the crimes committed and the general deterrence value of deportation. The applicant's criminal history, which included various charges in both New Zealand and Australia, was a significant factor. The offences in question were serious, involving premeditated violence, and although the applicant did not directly inflict violence, his participation in the crime was significant. The court also had to weigh the potential hardship to the applicant and his fiancée, particularly their young child, against the community's expectation of deterrence.

The court considered the primary considerations outlined in the Ministerial Direction 9, which emphasised the seriousness and nature of the offences committed by the potential deportee. The court noted the applicant's extensive criminal history and the violent nature of the crime for which he was being deported. However, it also took into account the applicant's lack of direct violence, his acceptance of responsibility, and the potential hardship to his fiancée and their child. Ultimately, the court found that the deterrence value outweighed the personal hardship to the applicant and his family, upholding the deportation order.

The court's final orders confirmed the decision to deport Mr Reuera Reu, acknowledging the gravity of his criminal conduct and the importance of maintaining the community's expectation of deterrence. The court recognised the personal hardship this decision would cause but determined that it was necessary to uphold the law and protect the community.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Mr Reuera Reu is 26 years of age and a New Zealand citizen. He has been a resident of Australia since June 1995. He seeks a review of a decision by a Delegate of the Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs made on 5 October 1999 to deport him from Australia under Section 200 of the Migration Act 1958. At the hearing the applicant was represented by Mr Chris Wilson of Counsel who was assisted by Mr Alan Mead. The respondent Minister was represented by Ms Bridget Quayle, in-house Counsel. Mr Reu gave oral evidence before me; so, too, did Mr John Uri, an expert on Pacific Island Culture; Mr Jeffrey White, a friend and potential employer of the applicant; Ms Alanna Mead, the applicant's fiancee; and Mr Alan Mead and Mrs Beverley Mead, Alanna's parents; Ms Anna Mansell, a family friend; Mr Ian Rankin, Elder and Session Clerk at Acacia Ridge Presbyterian Church; Mr Stephen Teale, Pastor of the Acacia Ridge Presbyterian Church; and Mr Clifford Cumpstay and Mrs Jean Cumpstay, Alanna's grandparents. The following documents were also received into evidence. The applicant Ministerial Direction is Direction 9 – General Direction – Criminal Deportation. This direction states that the primary considerations are:(a) the expectation of the Australian community; and The first consideration in relation to the protection of the Australian community is the seriousness and nature of the offences committed by the potential deportee. I shall now set out the history of the applicant's criminal conduct as reflected by his convictions. In New Zealand, the applicant was charged with theft of property, unlicensed use of a motor vehicle, false pretences and use of a document. Outstanding charges exist relating to an alleged assault on his girlfriend in 1995. In Australia, the applicant's criminal history begins in 1995 and consists of assault, breaches of domestic violence orders, false pretences and stealing, as well as a number of charges for breaching the Bail Act. In 1999 he faced 6 charges of break, enter and steal; 6 charges of entering premises to commit an indictable offence and break; and a charge of entering premises and committing an indictable offence and breaking whilst being armed with an offensive weapon and in company and using personal violence. Further, he was charged with deprivation of liberty, unlawful use of a motor vehicle and breach of a suspended sentence. The offences of entering premises with the intent to commit an indictable offence and breaking whilst armed with an offensive weapon and in company with the use of personal violence committed in February 1998 are the basis for the deportation order. This was a violent crime premeditated by his co-offenders. Mr Reu did not assist in planning the crime; in fact, he was not aware of his co-offenders' intentions until after they arrived at Cocos Fruit Shop. He was armed with a tomahawk during the whole ordeal but he did not inflict actual violence against any of the victims and he was sentenced on this basis. It was the co-offender who locked the workers in the freezer and drove a forklift to the door and stuck the tines through in order to lock it. Further, it was the co-offender who dragged Mrs Coco, a 51 year old woman, across the room by her hair with a knife at her throat. This was a truly abhorrent crime and the applicant did not attempt to diminish this fact. He took full responsibility for his part in the offence.