Retzlaff Carruthers and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (Migration)

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

Retzlaff Carruthers and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (Migration) [2025] ARTA 70 (6 February 2025)

Applicant/s:  Tautai Ozzy Jr Retzlaff Carruthers

Respondent:  Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs

Tribunal Number:                2024/9510

Tribunal:General Member A. Maryniak KC

Place:Melbourne

Date:6 February 2025  

Decision:The Tribunal sets aside the decision under review and in substitution decides that the decision cancelling the Applicant’s visa is revoked.        

........................[SGD]................................................

General Member A. Maryniak KC

Catchwords

Non-revocation under s 501CA(4) of the Migration Act 1958 of the mandatory cancellation of Applicant’s TY Subclass 444 Special Category (Temporary) visa – where the Applicant does not pass the character test – whether there is another reason to revoke the mandatory cancellation– Protection of the Australian Community – Strength Nature and Duration of Ties to Australia – Best Interests of Minor Children – Other considerations – Decision set aside and substituted

Legislation

Migration Act 1958 (Cth)

Cases

FYBR v Minister for Home Affairs [2019] FCAFC 185

Rogers and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [2025] ARTA 28

Secondary Materials

Direction No 110 – Visa refusal and cancellation under section 501 and revocation of a mandatory cancellation of a visa under section 501CA

Statement of Reasons

  1. The 32 year old Applicant, a Samoan and New Zealand citizen, born on 30 November 1992 in Moto’otua Samoa, migrated to Australia on 15 August 2014, aged 21. He seeks review of a decision, which cancelled his subclass 444 Special Category visa pursuant to section 501(3A) of Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (the Act).  He has been held in Immigration detention since 28 March 2024.[1]

    [1] Exhibit R1, ‘G’ Documents, G10, 88.  

    Consideration

  2. The Tribunal has considered the documentary material before it, comprising exhibits A1-2 and R1-3,[2] together with the testimony of the Applicant, the Applicant’s mother, the Applicant’s eldest sister Ms Brown and independent Forensic Clinical Psychologist Dr James Freeman.  The Tribunal has also considered the written and oral submissions of the parties.

    [2] A1 24/1/25 Email from Applicant’s solicitors;

    A2 30/1/25 Email from Applicant’s solicitors;

    R1 G-Documents;

    R2 Respondent’s Hearing Tender Bundle;

    R3 30/1/25 Email from Respondent’s solicitors.

  3. The Applicant concedes and the Tribunal finds that he does not pass the character test, pursuant to section 501(6)(a) of the Act due to him having been sentenced to 18 months imprisonment: see section 501(7)(c) of the Act.

  4. The Tribunal is to determine whether there is another reason why the visa cancellation decision should be revoked pursuant to section 501CA(4)(b)(ii) of the Act, by assessing and evaluating the factors for and against revoking the visa cancellation. Such a determination must be carried out in accordance with any written directions given pursuant to section 499(1) of the Act. The Tribunal must comply with Direction 110 (the Direction) made pursuant to s499 of the Act.

  5. Paragraph 5.2 of the Direction provides the following framework principles:

    1Australia has a sovereign right to determine whether non-citizens who are of character concern are allowed to enter and/or remain in Australia. Being…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Retzlaff Carruthers and Minister for Immigration and Multicu... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] ARTA 70
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case before the Tribunal involves the non-revocation of the mandatory cancellation of a Temporary Activity (Subclass 444) visa held by the Applicant, who has failed the character test. The Applicant's visa was subject to mandatory cancellation under section 501CA(4) of the Migration Act 1958, and the Tribunal was tasked with determining whether there were other reasons to revoke the mandatory cancellation. The central issue was whether the primary considerations and other relevant factors in favour of cancelling the revocation decision outweighed the primary considerations against such a cancellation.

The Tribunal considered several primary considerations and other factors in its decision. The primary consideration of the protection of the Australian community was heavily weighed against the Applicant, given his history of violent conduct, including a serious assault in 2023 and multiple police-related offences. However, the Tribunal also took into account the strength of the Applicant's ties to Australia, his best interests, and the best interests of his minor children. The Tribunal found that the Applicant had significant ties to Australia, including employment, family connections, and the upbringing of his children in the country. These ties, along with the other considerations, ultimately led the Tribunal to conclude that they outweighed the primary considerations against cancelling the revocation.

In light of the above considerations, the Tribunal set aside the decision to cancel the Applicant's visa and substituted it with a decision that the visa cancellation is revoked. The Tribunal found that the best interests of the minor children, the strength of the Applicant's ties to Australia, and other mitigating factors justified the revocation of the mandatory cancellation. The Tribunal's decision underscores the importance of balancing the primary considerations with other relevant factors in making a decision under the Migration Act.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Tribunal finds that Primary Considerations 3 and 4 and the other considerations discussed above in favour of cancelling the revocation decision ultimately outweigh Primary Considerations 1 and 5.Decision The Tribunal sets aside the decision under review and in substitution decides that the decision cancelling the Applicant’s visa is revoked.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Tribunal, informed by these principles, is to take into account the primary and other considerations, with Primary Consideration 1 generally to be given greater weight, per paragraph 7(2) of the Direction, and the primary considerations to be given greater weight that the other considerations.Primary consideration 1 – Protection of the Australian community Paragraph 8.1(2) of Direction 110 requires decision-makers to give consideration to:a)the nature and seriousness of the non-citizen’s conduct to date; andb)the risk to the Australian community, should the non-citizen commit further offences or engage in other serious conduct.Nature and Seriousness of Conduct The protection of the Australian community is paramount. The Applicant’s relevant criminal offending in Australia comprises a violent assault occasioning bodily harm on 27 February 2023, for which he was imprisoned for 18 months from 24 November 2023, then paroled on 30 March 2024 (the 2023 Assault). The Applicant was also ordered to pay $5000 compensation to the victim and there is no suggestion that compensation was not paid. Further, the Applicant was convicted on 17 September 2014 of a series of three related offences of assault officer in execution of duty ($1000 fine and 18 month bond), resist officer in execution of duty ($1000 fine) and resist or hinder police officer in the execution of duty ($1000 fine) (the Police Offending).[3] [3] Ibid G4, 45. The Applicant also has three earlier convictions in New Zealand from February 2013 and June 2011 for Unlicensed Driver Failed to Comply With Prohibition, Drink Driving and careless driving (the Driving offences).[4] Further, in light of the testimony of the Applicant before the Tribunal, the Tribunal considers that the discrepancies on the passenger cards were not intentional and hence of limited consequence.[5] In context, the earlier New Zealand Driving offences are also of limited consequence.[4] Ibid G5, 46.[5] Ibid G15-16, 345-346; G12, 333-334. Both the 2023 Assault and the Police Offending involved violence and are viewed very seriously by the Australian Government and the Australian community: Direction 8.1.1 (1)(a)(i) and (c). The victim of the 2023 Assault was punched in the face at about 3am by the Applicant, rendering him unconscious as he fell to the ground, striking his head on the ground resulting in significant bleeding. The Applicant, who had been out drinking for hours with his brother Richard, then left in a taxi, whilst the victim was convulsing on the ground until the paramedics arrived. The victim sustained a concussion, a large laceration at the back of his head (with 14 stitches) together with bruising and swelling to the left side of his face and eye.[6] It is only fortuitous that the victim did not sustain more serious injuries. It was not suggested that the victim has ongoing consequences from the assault.[7] However the injuries were significant. The evidence before the Tribunal going to the lead up to the assault suggests nothing to justify the Applicant’s conduct. It was cowardly and disproportionate to any perceived insult or misconceived threat. The Applicant seems genuinely and appropriately remorseful for the 2023 Assault.[6] Ibid G6, 64; R2, 4-6.[7] Paragraph 8.1.1(1)(d) of Direction 110