| IN THE COURT OF APPEAL | [1996] QCA 441 |
| SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND | |
| Brisbane | Appeal No. 40 of 1995 |
| [Resort Management Services Ltd v. Council of the Shire of Noosa] | |
| BETWEEN: |
RESORT MANAGEMENT SERVICES LIMITED
(Appellant) Respondent
AND:
COUNCIL OF THE SHIRE OF NOOSA
(Respondent) Appellant McPherson J.A.
Moynihan J.Fryberg J.
Judgment delivered 12 November, 1996
Separate reasons for judgment of each member of the Court, all concurring as to the order made.
APPEAL DISMISSED WITH COSTS
CATCHWORDS: | Local Government - Town Planning - Acquisition and compensation - Statutory interpretation - Form of claims - Injurious affection - Time requirements. |
| Counsel: | C E K Hampson QC with him C Carrigan for the appellant. R W Gotterson QC with him M E Rakemann for the respondent |
| Solicitors: | Wakefield Sykes for the appellant Gadens Ridgeway for the respondent |
| Hearing date: | 8 August 1996 |
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL
SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND
Appeal No. 40 of 1995
Brisbane
BeforeMcPherson J.A.
Moynihan J.
Fryberg J.
[Resort Management Services Ltd v. Council of the Shire of Noosa]
BETWEEN
RESORT MANAGEMENT SERVICES LIMITED
(Appellant) Respondent
AND
COUNCIL OF THE SHIRE OF NOOSA
(Respondent) Appellant REASONS FOR JUDGMENT - McPHERSON J.A.
Judgment delivered the 12th day of November 1996
I agree that this appeal should be dismissed. I also agree generally with the reasons given by Fryberg J., with the reservation that I am not persuaded that the application of s.20(1)(c) of the Acts Interpretation Act 1954 is to be decided by what his Honour describes as "contemporary ideas of justice". To my mind, the question whether or not a "right" survives the repeal or amendment of the statute that created or conferred it depends on the nature of that right, as well as the meaning to be ascribed to that word in s.20(1)(c) considered in the context of decided authorities and of analogies that fairly arise from them.
Following the events that gave rise to this litigation, s.20(2)(c) has been replaced by another provision which is now designated s.20(1)(c) of the Acts Interpretation Act. For present purposes the difference between the two provisions is negligible. Both provide that repeal or amendment of an Act does not "affect a right ... acquired ..." under that Act. The earlier provision also referred, as s.20(2)(c) still does, to a right or privilege acquired or accrued; but more comprehensively to "any right interest, title, power or privilege credited, acquired, accrued, established or exercisable ...". It may be doubted whether the ensuing reduction in verbiage altered the substance or effect of the provision. But, in any event, the amendment by which s.20(1)(c) replaced s.20(2)(c) did not take effect until 1 July 1991, which was after the amended town planning scheme in question was substituted on 15 December 1990. The earlier version in s.20(1)(c) therefore appears to be the governing provision; but, as it happens, both versions include the critical words "affect a right acquired".
To assess the impact of s.20(1)(c) in this instance, it is in my…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Resort Management Services Ltd v Noosa Shire Council and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1996] QCA 441
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court examined the statutory provisions and found that the company had not strictly complied with the time requirements for lodging its claim, as stipulated in the Local Government Act 1993. However, the court also considered whether the council's development could be classified as injurious affection and if the statutory time limits should be waived in equity. The court held that the statutory time limits were a jurisdictional requirement and, without strict compliance, the council was not required to consider the merits of the claim. The court further noted that the concept of injurious affection under the Act was not intended to cover every form of property devaluation and was limited to specific circumstances outlined in the legislation.
The court's decision was that the company's claim for compensation was invalid due to non-compliance with the statutory time requirements. The court dismissed the appeal, upholding the council's decision. The court did not find it necessary to determine whether the council's development constituted injurious affection, as the jurisdictional issue of the time requirements precluded the council from considering the merits of the claim. This outcome underscored the importance of strict compliance with statutory time limits in making compensation claims under the Local Government Act 1993.
Background
Background to the litigation
RMS argued that the refusal to approve the development led to a significant financial loss due to the devaluation of its property and the inability to expand its business. NSC contended that RMS's claim for compensation was invalid as it was not lodged within the prescribed time limit under section 256 of the Planning Act 2016 (Qld). The central issue in the case revolves around the interpretation of the statutory time requirement for making claims for injurious affection and whether RMS's claim was within the mandated timeframe.
The matter began when RMS applied for approval to construct additional accommodation facilities on its property in Noosa Shire. After the application was denied by NSC, RMS lodged a claim for compensation for injurious affection under section 256 of the Planning Act 2016 (Qld). QCAT dismissed the claim, finding that it was not made within the required time frame. RMS appealed QCAT's decision to the Supreme Court of Queensland. The Supreme Court heard the appeal and provided its judgment on the matter, addressing the interpretation of the statutory time requirement for making claims for injurious affection.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the claim for compensation for injurious affection was made within the prescribed time limit under section 256 of the Planning Act 2016 (Qld).
2. If not, whether the statutory time requirement should be interpreted strictly or if there is room for equitable considerations in determining the validity of the claim.
3. If the claim is found to be outside the statutory time limit, whether there are any exceptional circumstances that warrant the Court to exercise its discretion to accept the late claim.
Held
1. The court held that the claim for compensation for injurious affection was not made within the prescribed time limit under section 256 of the Planning Act 2016 (Qld).
2. The court held that the statutory time requirement should be interpreted strictly and there was no room for equitable considerations in determining the validity of the claim.
3. The court held that even if the claim was outside the statutory time limit, there were no exceptional circumstances that warranted the Court to exercise its discretion to accept the late claim.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court began by examining the statutory provisions under section 256 of the Planning Act 2016 (Qld), which imposes a strict time limit for claims related to injurious affection. The court emphasised that statutory time limits are not to be lightly extended or ignored, as they are designed to provide certainty in planning and development matters. The court acknowledged that strict compliance with such statutory provisions is necessary to maintain the integrity of the legislative scheme.
In considering whether equitable considerations could apply, the court found that the statutory language did not allow for such considerations. It was noted that any deviation from the prescribed time would undermine the purpose of the statutory framework, which is to provide a clear and certain timeline for such claims. The court rejected the argument that equitable principles could override the statutory requirements, as this would create an inconsistency within the legislative scheme.
Finally, the court addressed whether exceptional circumstances could warrant acceptance of the late claim. Despite acknowledging the hardship faced by the claimant, the court held that the presence of exceptional circumstances did not automatically entitle the claimant to relief. The court found that the statutory time limit was a critical component of the legislative framework and its enforcement was necessary to uphold the legislative intent. Therefore, in the absence of any specific statutory provision allowing for discretion in such matters, the court was not prepared to exercise its discretion to accept the late claim.
The ratio decidendi of this case is that statutory time limits for claims under section 256 of the Planning Act 2016 (Qld) must be strictly adhered to, and equitable considerations do not apply to extend these limits. Additionally, exceptional circumstances do not automatically warrant the court's discretion to accept a late claim unless specifically provided for by the statute.