Residential Property Conveyancers v Vincent Bagnato

Link copied
Case Copied 50 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Applications Under Various Acts or Rules: Civil)

RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY CONVEYANCERS v VINCENT BAGNATO & ORS

[2009] SASC 71

Reasons for Decision of The Honourable Justice Layton

13 March 2009

MAGISTRATES - APPEALS AND REVIEW - SOUTH AUSTRALIA - APPEAL TO SUPREME COURT - COSTS

PROCEDURE - COSTS - APPEALS AS TO COSTS

PROCEDURE - COSTS - DEPARTING FROM THE GENERAL RULE - OTHER CASES - DISCONTINUANCE OR ABANDONMENT

Application for permission to appeal against a decision of a magistrate to refuse an application for costs by the second defendant upon discontinuance of the action – legal principles on costs upon discontinuance – whether the Magistrate impermissibly adjudicated the issues in the case by deciding that the plaintiffs acted reasonably in joining the second defendant – whether the Magistrate erred in finding that the plaintiffs acted reasonably in the course of litigation and that the second defendant’s conduct caused delay – whether the second defendant’s pursuit of discovery as to “best endeavours” was relevant prior to amendment of pleadings - whether Magistrate would have exercised discretion differently had evidence of Calderbank offers been before him – whether costs should have been awarded on the complex action scale.

Held: Magistrate correctly applied relevant principles in deciding that the plaintiffs had acted reasonably in joining the second defendant – no error was demonstrated in the finding by the Magistrate that the second defendant had caused delay – refusal of Calderbank offers by the plaintiffs as not so unreasonable that the Magistrate would have exercised discretion differently had they been before him – the notification alleged by the applicant as certifying the action as complex did not sufficiently alert the plaintiffs that Rule 106(7) of the Magistrates Court (Civil) Rules was being triggered –  issues were also narrow in compass and were made unnecessarily prolix by procedural issues – permission refused and proposed appeal rejected on its merits.

Civil Liability Act 1936 (SA) s 41; Magistrates Court (Civil) Rules 1992 (SA) r 106(7); Supreme Court Civil Rules 2006 r 281; Magistrates Court Act 1991 (SA) s 40(2), referred to.
Australian Securities Commission v Aust-Home Investments Ltd (1993) 116 ALR 523; Boscaini Investments Pty Ltd & Ors v The Corporation of the City of Kensington and Norwood [1999] SASC 327; Danielsen v Waldowski [2008] SASC 27; Gribbles Pathology Pty Ltd v Health Insurance Commission (1997) 80 FCR 284; Pentroth Pty Ltd v Kirschild Pty Ltd [2006] SASC 356; Re the Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs; ex parte Lai Qin (1997) 186 CLR 622, applied.

RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY CONVEYANCERS v VINCENT BAGNATO & ORS
[2009] SASC 71

LAYTON J:

  1. This is an application for permission to appeal against an order for costs made by a magistrate on 1 October 2008.  Permission to appeal against a costs order is required by Rule 281(b) of the Supreme Court Civil Rules 2006 (“2006 Rules”).

  2. The submissions made by counsel were in relation to both the application for permission…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Residential Property Conveyancers v Vincent Bagnato and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] SASC 71
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The matter before the court was an application by a small conveyancing corporation for permission to appeal a decision of a magistrate to refuse an application for costs by the second defendant upon discontinuance of the action. The application arose from a previous litigation concerning a contract for the purchase of land between the plaintiffs and the vendor, with the second defendant being the conveyancer retained by the plaintiffs. The conveyancing corporation sought costs on the complex action scale, but the application was refused by the magistrate, who directed each party to bear their own costs. The conveyancing corporation now seeks permission to appeal against that order.

The legal issues before the court were whether the magistrate correctly applied the relevant principles in deciding that the plaintiffs had acted reasonably in joining the second defendant, whether there was any error in the finding by the magistrate that the second defendant had caused delay, whether the conveyancer's pursuit of discovery as to "best endeavours" was relevant prior to amendment of pleadings, whether the magistrate would have exercised discretion differently had evidence of Calderbank offers been before him, and whether costs should have been awarded on the complex action scale. The court also had to consider whether the magistrate correctly applied the relevant principles in deciding that the plaintiffs had acted reasonably in joining the second defendant, whether there was any error in the finding by the magistrate that the second defendant had caused delay, whether the conveyancer's pursuit of discovery as to "best endeavours" was relevant prior to amendment of pleadings, whether the magistrate would have exercised discretion differently had evidence of Calderbank offers been before him, and whether costs should have been awarded on the complex action scale.

The court found that the magistrate correctly applied the relevant principles in deciding that the plaintiffs had acted reasonably in joining the second defendant, and that there was no error in the finding by the magistrate that the second defendant had caused delay. The court also found that the conveyancer's pursuit of discovery as to "best endeavours" was not relevant prior to amendment of pleadings, and that the magistrate would not have exercised discretion differently had evidence of Calderbank offers been before him. The court held that costs should not have been awarded on the complex action scale, as the notification alleged by the applicant as certifying the action as complex did not sufficiently alert the plaintiffs that Rule 106(7) of the Magistrates Court (Civil) Rules was being triggered, and the issues were also narrow in compass and were made unnecessarily prolix by procedural issues. The court refused permission for the proposed appeal and rejected it on its merits.

The court's decision was based on a detailed analysis of the evidence and submissions put before it, including affidavits of the conveyancer's solicitor and the plaintiffs' solicitor, and the submissions of the parties. The court found that the magistrate had correctly exercised his discretion in deciding the costs order, and that there was no error in his findings. The court also held that the conveyancer's conduct through its solicitors contributed to additional costs and the matter not being listed for trial at an earlier time. The court found that the cost involved in the obtaining of the expert reports was likely to have been considerable, and that there was no reason why a report from the "expert" conveyancer could not have been organised at an earlier point in time, as the obtaining of such a report was not dependant on any of the discovery issues.

Background

Background to the litigation

This matter has a substantial history. I will briefly outline the facts before turning to the issues. Background circumstances The applicant is a small conveyancing corporation run by a conveyancer who was the second defendant in an action in the Magistrates Court. The first three respondents were the plaintiffs in that action. The subject of the litigation was a contract for purchase of land between the plaintiffs and the first defendant (the fourth respondent in this application), being the owner of the land. The second defendant was the conveyancer retained by the plaintiffs. For convenience, I will refer to the first three respondents collectively as “the plaintiffs”, the applicant as “the conveyancer”, and the fourth respondent as “the vendor”. The vendor did not appear at the hearing of the appeal and did not provide any submissions. The contract for purchase of land was subject to a special condition relating to the obtaining of finance by the plaintiffs. The plaintiffs paid a deposit of $20,000 to the vendor on 14 May 2005. Settlement was due to take place on 24 June 2005. The plaintiffs’ solicitors gave notice to the vendor on 27 June 2005 that they were terminating the contract as the plaintiffs were unable to obtain finance. On 2 August 2005 the plaintiffs instituted proceedings in the Magistrates Court of South Australia to recover their deposit from the vendor. Thereafter the litigation continued with the filing of a Defence and Counterclaim by the vendor, and later the joinder of the conveyancer. The action eventually settled with the return of the deposit. A Notice of Discontinuance was filed by the plaintiffs against both the vendor and the conveyancer, and the vendor discontinued the counterclaim. The conveyancer then applied for costs against the plaintiffs, and sought them on the complex action scale. On 1 October 2008 the application was refused and Magistrate Millard directed each party to bear their own costs. The conveyancer now seeks permission to appeal against that order. The submissions put before me went into considerable detail in regard to the progress of the Magistrates Court matter. The evidence before me consisted of the following:·Four affidavits of the conveyancer’s solicitor, Kymberley Alissa Lawrence, sworn 5 August 2008, 21 August 2008, 22 October 2008 and 11 November 2008;·An affidavit of the plaintiffs’ solicitor, Phillip David Gallasch, sworn 25 August 2008;·Appellant’s Outline of Argument on Appeal;·Further Particulars of Ground of Appeal 1(a);·Respondent’s Outline of Argument, and·Appellant’s Reply Submissions.The affidavits of the conveyancer’s solicitor sworn 5 August 2008 and 21 August 2008, along with the affidavit of the plaintiffs’ solicitor sworn 25 August 2008, were before Magistrate Millard prior to the 1 October 2008 costs order. Approach Rule 281(b) of the 2006 Rules provides that an appeal limited to the question of costs lies only by permission of the Court. This reflects the reluctance of the Court to entertain appeals from costs orders. A preliminary issue was raised by counsel for the conveyancer as to whether permission was required for the proposed appeal. I rejected his argument that permission was not required, given the clear wording of r 281(b) of the 2006 Rules and s 40(2) of the Magistrates Court Act 1991 (SA), which provides that a right of appeal from a judgment of the Magistrates Court is limited by the rules of the Supreme Court.

Decision

Reasons for decision

A verbal report was initially sought from an “expert” conveyancer on 17 September 2007, and a written report requested on 6 November 2007. On 22 November 2007, the conveyancer’s solicitors requested amendments to the expert’s draft report. Conclusions on delay Having regard to this history, I consider that there were delays by the plaintiffs in the provision of discovery. Overall, however, the cause of greater delay was in my view attributed to the conduct of the conveyancer in the amendment of the pleadings; in the manner of pursuit of discovery and non-party discovery; and the process of obtaining and providing the expert reports. There was fault on both sides, but most significantly by the conveyancer, whose conduct through its solicitors contributed to additional costs and the matter not being listed for trial at an earlier time. Solicitors for the conveyancer seem to have taken an over-enthusiastic approach in determining what documentation was needed and what proof they required to support their client’s defence. They made continuous requests for more and more information, which in many instances did not properly relate to the pleadings as they stood at different points of time. The ultimate defence amounted to a different cause of action altogether, in the form of a set-off to deflect any order for damages made against them on the basis that the plaintiffs were not entitled to the return of their deposit. Returning to Magistrate Millard’s reasons. I do not consider that the learned Magistrate took into account some matter wholly unconnected with the cause of the action, or that he was without sufficient material to exercise his discretion to award costs, or that he did not exercise his discretion judicially. In my view, no error was demonstrated by Magistrate Millard in concluding as he did. He was entirely entitled to make the findings contained in [39] of his reasons. In addition, I have considerable doubt as to the appropriateness and relevance of the expert report on the issue of “best endeavours”. There is also no reason why a report from the “expert” conveyancer could not have been organised at an earlier point in time, as the obtaining of such a report was not dependant on any of the discovery issues. The cost involved in the obtaining of both reports is likely to have been considerable.Offers of settlement The conveyancer contends that if Magistrate Millard had been aware of the offers of settlement, his Honour would have exercised his discretion differently. In making this submission, the conveyancer referred to a letter dated 29 March 2006 whereby the conveyancer offered to bear its own costs if the plaintiffs were prepared to discontinue. The offer was rejected. This correspondence was not before the Magistrate when he made the orders as to costs. In my view, this letter was sent too early in the proceedings to amount to anything significant. It was sent prior to the conveyancer amending its defence to reflect the “best endeavours” issue. At that time not all of the issues had evolved, and I do not think that the offer should in any way affect the final costs order.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The appeal before the Court involved the refusal by the Magistrate to grant costs to the second defendant upon discontinuance of the action. The conveyancer, seeking permission to appeal, argued that the Magistrate incorrectly applied the legal principles on costs upon discontinuance. The Court considered the principles and authorities guiding the award of costs upon discontinuance and found that the Magistrate had correctly applied these principles.

The conveyancer first argued that the Magistrate impermissibly adjudicated the issues in the case by deciding that the plaintiffs acted reasonably in joining the second defendant. The Court examined the Magistrate's reasoning and concluded that the learned Magistrate had not overstepped the boundaries of his discretion. The decision to join the conveyancer was made in the context of the litigation and was reasonable under the circumstances. The Court found no basis to conclude that the Magistrate had made an improper adjudication.

Next, the conveyancer contended that the Magistrate erred in finding that the plaintiffs acted reasonably in the course of litigation and that the conveyancer’s conduct caused delay. The Court reviewed the evidence and found that the conveyancer's conduct, particularly in the manner of pursuit of discovery and amendment of pleadings, contributed significantly to the delay. The Magistrate's findings were supported by the evidence and the Court found no error in these determinations.

The conveyancer also questioned the relevance of its pursuit of discovery as to "best endeavours" prior to the amendment of pleadings. The Court found this pursuit to be a significant factor contributing to the delay and complexity of the litigation. The relevance of the discovery issue was not negated by the timing of the conveyancer's request, as the Magistrate's findings were based on the overall conduct of the conveyancer during the proceedings.

Further, the conveyancer argued that had evidence of Calderbank offers been before the Magistrate, the discretion might have been exercised differently. The Court considered the timing and substance of the offers and found that they were made too early in the proceedings to have a significant impact on the final costs order. The Court upheld the Magistrate's decision not to alter the costs order based on these offers.

Finally, the conveyancer argued that costs should have been awarded on the complex action scale. The Court noted that the notification alleged by the conveyancer as certifying the action as complex did not sufficiently alert the plaintiffs that Rule 106(7) of the Magistrates Court (Civil) Rules was being triggered. Moreover, the issues in the case were narrow and made unnecessarily prolix by procedural issues. The Court found no basis to award costs on the complex action scale.

In summary, the Court found that the Magistrate had correctly applied the legal principles in assessing the costs upon discontinuance and that no error was demonstrated in the Magistrate's findings. The refusal of Calderbank offers, while relevant, did not warrant a different exercise of discretion, and the action did not meet the criteria for a complex action scale. The Court rejected the application for permission to appeal and the proposed appeal on its merits.