Republic Consulting Pty Ltd v Nhan Chiem

Link copied
Case Copied 23 min read

TRADE MARKS ACT 1995



DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS

Re:Opposition by Republic Consulting Pty Ltd to registration of trade mark application 940889(35) - re:public - filed in the name of Nhan Chiem.

Delegate: Terry Williams
Representation: Opponent: Stephen Burley of counsel, instructed by Lance Scott, solicitor, of Spruson & Ferguson
Applicant: written submissions only
Decision: 2008 ATMO 20
Section 52 opposition – section 58 – section 59 established – registration refused.

Background

  1. Nhan Chiem (“the applicant”) has applied to register the trade mark re:public in respect of services described as “Marketing, public relations”.  The application was filed on 22 January 2003 (“the critical date”).  The applicant is, and was at the critical date, resident in Hong Kong. 

  2. The application has been examined and advertised as having been accepted for possible registration.  Registration is opposed by Republic Consulting Pty Ltd (“the opponent”).  The current dispute arises because both parties appear to have done various things consistent with adopting the signs re:public and REPUBLIC, respectively, as trade marks, and to have done so at about the same time[1].

    [1] There are some subtleties in the way the opponent represents its trade mark.  For convenience, I will render it in upper case, and revert to this matter as necessary below.

  3. The parties have used the process in part 5 of the regulations under the Trade Marks Act (“the Act”) to file and serve evidence to support their respective positions.  Ultimately, the matter was set down for me to hear and decide, under delegation from the Registrar of Trade Marks.  At the hearing, Stephen Burley of counsel, instructed by Lance Scott, solicitor, of Spruson & Ferguson, appeared for the opponent.  The applicant relied on written submissions.  I will come to those in due course.

    Grounds of opposition

    General

  4. The opponent is newly-incorporated under the laws of New South Wales.  It is a small company with a number of directors, two of whom are Liza-Jane Loch and David Mair, and it provides public relations, advertising and marketing services.  From the official file it is apparent that there is a degree of bad feeling between the opponent and the applicant, some of which has arisen out of perceptions about a discussion between Mr Mair and the applicant on a confidential basis.  That discussion took place at a lunch engagement in Sydney in November 2002 when the applicant returned, briefly, to Australia.  The subject of that discussion was the proposed usage, by the applicant, of the mark presently in suit.

  5. I understand the applicant feels that he has a moral right to the trade mark.  He is, I think, mistaken about the existence of that right and I will endeavor to explain why this is so, but his sentiment is understandable.  I very much doubt that the applicant will be satisfied that I have fully investigated the issues unless I deal also with this moral claim. 

  6. The high point of that claim rests on an email, sent to the applicant…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Republic Consulting Pty Ltd v Nhan Chiem and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] ATMO 20
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application by Republic Consulting Pty Ltd to register the trade mark RE:PUBLIC. The application was opposed by Nhan Chiem. The hearing officer, Terry Williams, was required to determine whether the applicant's proposed mark was substantially identical or deceptively similar to the opponent's registered trade mark REPUBLIC.

The central legal issue was whether the inclusion of a colon in the applicant's mark, RE:PUBLIC, rendered it substantially identical or deceptively similar to the opponent's mark, REPUBLIC, for the purposes of trade mark law. The hearing officer had to consider the principles of comparison of trade marks, including the "total impression" test and the assessment of essential features.

The hearing officer applied the principles established in *The Shell Co. of Australia Ltd. v. Esso Standard Oil (Australia) Ltd.* and *Carnival Cruise Lines Inc v Sitmar Cruises Ltd*. He noted that while the colon had a negligible effect on the sound of the mark, it created a distinct visual and semantic difference, introducing a play on words relevant to public relations services. This visual and conceptual distinction meant that RE:PUBLIC was not substantially identical to REPUBLIC. The hearing officer found that the opponent had established its ground of opposition.

Consequently, the hearing officer refused to register the application and ordered that the applicant pay the costs of the opponent.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The usual text cited as authority for substantially identical is set out in The Shell Co. of Australia Ltd. v. Esso Standard Oil (Australia) Ltd. [1961] HCA 75; (1963) 109 CLR 407. Windeyer J said at paragraph 12 of his judgment – my emphasis added and omitting citations: In considering whether marks are substantially identical they should, I think, be compared side by side, their similarities and differences noted and the importance of these assessed having regard to the essential features of the registered mark and the total impression of resemblance or dissimilarity that emerges from the comparison. "The identification of an essential feature depends", it has been said, "partly on the Court's own judgment and partly on the burden of the evidence that is placed before it": …. Whether there is substantial identity is a question of fact…. The minimum requirement of similarity to establish ownership was discussed by Gummow J in Carnival Cruise Lines Inc v Sitmar Cruises Ltd [1994] FCA 936; (1994) 120 ALR 495. He commented: It requires a total impression of similarity to emerge from a comparison between the two marks. In a real sense a claim to proprietorship of the one extends to the other. But to go beyond this is, in my view, not possible. There is, as Mr Shanahan points out in his work, p. 158, real difficulty in assessing the broader notion of deceptive similarity in the absence of some notional user in Australia of the prior mark (something postulated by s. 33) or prior public recognition built up by user (para. 28 (a)). Mr Burley argued that REPUBLIC and RE:PUBLIC were substantially identical. He noted that the colon made no difference to the sound of the mark, and that the word used in that case is clearly REPUBLIC with a punctuation mark in it. However, while Mr Burley is obviously correct about the negligible effect on the sound of the mark, an unmistakable change has been made to the import of the word as this arises visually. The applicant and Mr Mair have both given evidence about their satisfaction with the play on words that is introduced into RE:PUBLIC when used in relation to public relation services. I agree entirely. Mr Burley attempted to draw comfort from the decision in Hugo Boss v Jackson (1999) 47 IPR 423 at 435 (BOSS vs BOSS!) but I do not think the analogy is appropriate. Used at the end of a word, an exclamation mark is familiar as adding emphasis: “tiger!”, “danger!” and so forth. It changes the emotional emphasis but not the substance. The same punctuation mark used within a word creates a very different effect: as for example “ti!ger”, “d!anger” and so on. Mr Mair appreciated the cleverness of the effect created by the colon between “re” and “public”, saying in an email to the applicant “yours is clever, ours is run of the mill”. To emphasize the latter, the opponent has introduced a search of the ASIC National Names Index which shows that there are, or have been, 57 different company names that feature the word “republic”.

Decision

Reasons for decision

In the lack of such an answer, which I note it would have been very easy and entirely within the applicant’s power to make, I take the ground of opposition as established.Conclusion A ground of opposition having been established, I refuse to register the application and I direct that the applicant pay the costs of the opponent. Terry WilliamsHearing OfficerTrade Marks Hearings5 March 2008

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.