Repacholi Aviation Pty Ltd and Civil Aviation Authority

Link copied
Case Copied 81 min read

Administrative

Appeals

Tribunal

 

DECISION AND REASONS FOR DECISION [2006] AATA 578

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL      )

)           No   W2004/44

GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION )
Re REPACHOLI AVIATION PTY LTD

Applicant

And

CIVIL AVIATION SAFETY AUTHORITY

Respondent

DECISION

Tribunal Deputy President S D Hotop

Date30 June 2006

PlacePerth

Decision

The Tribunal sets aside the decision under review and remits the matter to the respondent (“CASA”) for reconsideration in accordance with the following directions:

·     Gerald Repacholi has “maintained a satisfactory record in the conduct or management of flying operations”, within the meaning, and for the purposes, of para (a) of cl 1.3 in Appendix 1 of section 82.0 of the Civil Aviation Orders (“CAO”);

·     Gerald Repacholi be assessed and examined, in accordance with paras (b)-(d) of cl 1.3 in Appendix 1 of section 82.0 of the CAO, by an examiner appointed by CASA, who is based in a regional office of CASA other than the Perth General Aviation Field Office (formerly known as the West Area Office), and who is acceptable to Mr Repacholi;

·     if Gerald Repacholi is assessed by the relevant examiner as “suitable to carry out the responsibilities of a Chief Pilot”, for the purposes of para (b) of cl 1.3, and passes the examinations conducted by the relevant examiner for the purposes of paras (c) and (d) of cl 1.3, he be forthwith approved as the Chief Pilot of Repacholi Aviation Pty Ltd without the requirement to undertake the flying activity specified in para (e) of cl 1.3.

......(Sgd S D Hotop)........

Deputy President

1.3The appointment may be approved only if the person has:

(a)in the opinion of CASA, maintained a satisfactory record in the conduct or management of flying operations; and

(b)been assessed, by an examiner appointed by CASA, as suitable to carry out the responsibilities of a Chief Pilot; and

(c)passed an oral examination, conducted by an examiner appointed by CASA, covering the regulatory requirements for the safe conduct of commercial operations; and

(d)passed a flight planning, loading and performance examination, conducted by an examiner appointed by CASA, based on the operator’s most complex aircraft; and

(e)if required by CASA — flown with a person nominated by CASA to demonstrate his or her suitability for appointment.

1.4CASA must:

(a)give written notice of the approval, or refusal of approval, to the operator and to the person; and

(b)if CASA refuses to approve the appointment — include in the notice the reasons for the refusal.

1.5An approval:

(a)relates only to the operator mentioned in the notice of approval; and

(b)may be subject to conditions mentioned in the notice of approval; and

(c)remains in force:

(i)for the period mentioned in the notice of approval; or

(ii)if no period is mentioned — while the person maintains a satisfactory standard of performance.

2    RESPONSIBILITIES OF CHIEF PILOT

2.1The Chief Pilot for an operator is to have control of all flight crew training and…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Repacholi Aviation Pty Ltd and Civil Aviation Authority and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2006] AATA 578
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The dispute in this case involved Repacholi Aviation Pty Ltd and the Civil Aviation Authority, with the applicant seeking approval for Gerald Repacholi as Chief Pilot. The case was heard by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT). The central issue was whether Mr Repacholi, who had previously served as Chief Pilot until his resignation in March 2002 and had a satisfactory record in flying operations, should be approved as Chief Pilot again. The tribunal had to determine whether he satisfied the conditions outlined in the Civil Aviation Orders, specifically, whether he was suitable to carry out the responsibilities of a Chief Pilot and if he passed the required examinations.

The tribunal found that Mr Repacholi had indeed maintained a satisfactory record in managing flying operations. However, the Civil Aviation Safety Authority (CASA) had refused to approve him as Chief Pilot in February 2004. The AAT considered that Mr Repacholi should be assessed by an examiner appointed by CASA, based in a regional office other than Perth, and acceptable to Mr Repacholi. The tribunal ruled that if Mr Repacholi was deemed suitable and passed the examinations, he should be approved as Chief Pilot without needing to undertake specified flying activities.

The tribunal set aside the decision under review and directed CASA to reconsider the application for Mr Repacholi's approval as Chief Pilot, following the outlined conditions. Specifically, Mr Repacholi must be assessed by an examiner appointed by CASA and pass the relevant examinations. If he meets these criteria, he should be approved as Chief Pilot without further requirements.

Orders

Orders of the court

The Tribunal sets aside the decision under review and remits the matter to the respondent (“CASA”) for reconsideration in accordance with the following directions:

· Gerald Repacholi has “maintained a satisfactory record in the conduct or management of flying operations”, within the meaning, and for the purposes, of para (a) of cl 1.3 in Appendix 1 of section 82.0 of the Civil Aviation Orders (“CAO”);

· Gerald Repacholi be assessed and examined, in accordance with paras (b)-(d) of cl 1.3 in Appendix 1 of section 82.0 of the CAO, by an examiner appointed by CASA, who is based in a regional office of CASA other than the Perth General Aviation Field Office (formerly known as the West Area Office), and who is acceptable to Mr Repacholi;

· if Gerald Repacholi is assessed by the relevant examiner as “suitable to carry out the responsibilities of a Chief Pilot”, for the purposes of para (b) of cl 1.3, and passes the examinations conducted by the relevant examiner for the purposes of paras (c) and (d) of cl 1.3, he be forthwith approved as the Chief Pilot of Repacholi Aviation Pty Ltd without the requirement to undertake the flying activity specified in para (e) of cl 1.3.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves Repacholi Aviation Pty Ltd and the Civil Aviation Safety Authority (CASA). Gerald Repacholi was approved by CASA as the Chief Pilot of Repacholi Aviation Pty Ltd in February 1995. He acted in this capacity until his resignation in March 2002. A new Chief Pilot was approved by CASA in April 2002. In November 2003, Repacholi Aviation requested CASA to approve Mr Repacholi as Chief Pilot once again. However, in February 2004, CASA refused to approve Mr Repacholi for this role. The refusal was based on CASA's consideration of Mr Repacholi’s compliance history and his dealings with CASA officers. Despite this, it was noted that Mr Repacholi had maintained a satisfactory record in the conduct or management of flying operations.

According to the Civil Aviation Orders section 82.0 Appendix 1, Mr Repacholi's approval as Chief Pilot is conditional upon being assessed by an examiner as suitable to carry out the responsibilities of Chief Pilot and passing the prescribed examinations conducted by the examiner. If these conditions are satisfied, Mr Repacholi should be approved as Chief Pilot of Repacholi Aviation Pty Ltd.

This case came before the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) as an appeal against the decision of CASA to refuse the approval of Gerald Repacholi as Chief Pilot of Repacholi Aviation Pty Ltd. The AAT reviewed the decision made by CASA in February 2004. Prior to this, Repacholi Aviation had made a request to CASA in November 2003 to reapprove Mr Repacholi as Chief Pilot. The AAT considered the relevant Civil Aviation Orders and the circumstances surrounding Mr Repacholi’s previous role and his compliance history. The AAT ultimately set aside the decision under review and directed CASA to reconsider the matter in accordance with specific directions.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether Gerald Repacholi has "maintained a satisfactory record in the conduct or management of flying operations" within the meaning and for the purposes of para (a) of cl 1.3 in Appendix 1 of section 82.0 of the Civil Aviation Orders.
2. Whether Gerald Repacholi should be assessed and examined by an examiner appointed by CASA, who is based in a regional office of CASA other than the Perth General Aviation Field Office and who is acceptable to Mr Repacholi, in accordance with paras (b)-(d) of cl 1.3 in Appendix 1 of section 82.0 of the CAO.
3. If Gerald Repacholi is assessed by the relevant examiner as "suitable to carry out the responsibilities of a Chief Pilot" and passes the examinations conducted by the relevant examiner, whether he should be forthwith approved as the Chief Pilot of Repacholi Aviation Pty Ltd without the requirement to undertake the flying activity specified in para (e) of cl 1.3.

Held
1. The court held that Gerald Repacholi has maintained a satisfactory record in the conduct or management of flying operations within the meaning and for the purposes of para (a) of cl 1.3 in Appendix 1 of section 82.0 of the Civil Aviation Orders.
2. The court held that Gerald Repacholi should be assessed and examined by an examiner appointed by CASA, based in a regional office of CASA other than the Perth General Aviation Field Office and acceptable to Mr Repacholi, in accordance with paras (b)-(d) of cl 1.3 in Appendix 1 of section 82.0 of the CAO.
3. The court held that if Gerald Repacholi is assessed by the relevant examiner as suitable to carry out the responsibilities of a Chief Pilot and passes the examinations conducted by the relevant examiner, he should be forthwith approved as the Chief Pilot of Repacholi Aviation Pty Ltd without the requirement to undertake the flying activity specified in para (e) of cl 1.3.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the compliance history and dealings of Gerald Repacholi with CASA officers to determine whether he had maintained a satisfactory record in the conduct or management of flying operations. The Tribunal found that Mr Repacholi had indeed maintained such a record, satisfying the criteria under para (a) of cl 1.3 in Appendix 1 of section 82.0 of the Civil Aviation Orders. This finding was critical as it affirmed Mr Repacholi's past competence and reliability in aviation management, thus supporting his eligibility for the Chief Pilot role.

The court then turned to the issue of assessment and examination. It was noted that Mr Repacholi's approval as Chief Pilot was conditional upon being assessed by an examiner appointed by CASA, based in a regional office other than the Perth General Aviation Field Office, and acceptable to Mr Repacholi. This requirement is detailed in paras (b)-(d) of cl 1.3 in Appendix 1 of section 82.0 of the Civil Aviation Orders. The court stressed the importance of this assessment being conducted by an independent examiner, ensuring impartiality and adherence to regulatory standards.

Lastly, the court addressed the conditions under which Mr Repacholi would be approved as Chief Pilot if he met the assessment and examination criteria. If deemed suitable by the examiner and passing the prescribed examinations, Mr Repacholi should be approved as Chief Pilot without needing to undertake the flying activity specified in para (e) of cl 1.3. This conclusion was based on the understanding that the assessment and examinations would sufficiently demonstrate Mr Repacholi's capabilities and knowledge, thereby fulfilling the requirements for the Chief Pilot role. The Tribunal set aside the decision under review and remitted the matter to CASA for reconsideration in line with these directions.