Rennie, Gordon Andrew v Curley, Sean

Link copied
Case Copied 30 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

INDUSTRIAL LAW - registered organisations - rules - construction of - whether rules of CPSU/SPSF Queensland branch allowed appointment of proxies to meetings of branch council - whether relevant rule evinced an intention regarding use of proxies at meetings of branch council - whether absence of machinery provisions dealing with proxies fatal to construction contended for - effect of failure to recognise proxy on subsequent business conducted at branch council meeting

Workplace Relations Act 1996 ss 3(g), 209

Harben v Phillips (1883) 23 Ch D 14
McLeish v Kane (1978) 36 FLR 80
Campbell v The Australian Mutual Provident Society (1906) 7 SR (NSW) 99
Egan v Maher (1978) 20 ALR 421
Darroch v Tanner (1987) 16 FCR 368

GORDON ANDREW RENNIE, JOHN AXAM, PETER McKAY, CLIFTON MILES, ALAN SNOW, IAN HOLMES, DAVID BRENNAN, BRENDAN MOFFAT, DENNIS BAILEY -v- SEAN CURLEY, JOHN ANDERSON, MICHAEL CONWAY, HELEN BORRADALE, BOB ELLIS, GARY ABLETT, JULIE DAVIES, GREG SINGH, TERRY CRIMSTON and SUE CARLOS, ATHOL CAIRN KELVIN GOODALL, K. BATT, YOLANDA FILLIP, JIM WALTON, PETER KEOGH, R. TEYMANT, D. ROBINSON, B. ELLIS, D. ROBERTSON, G. KELLY, LEIGH DELANEY, G. VINES, KAREN GREEN, NEIL BAKER, J. McMAHON, J. HADAWAY, MARGARET WARNER, KAY ANASTASSIADIS, STEPHEN PINCHES, ERYL BRADY, JOHN DOYLE, I. JORDAN, FRANCIS VAN DATEL, BRIAN WEBB, R. DAVIS, BILL BRENNAN, JANET GOOD, FRANK NIMMELL, SUZANNE WALSH, CHRIS WENKE and CPSU, THE COMMUNITY AND PUBLIC SECTOR UNION

QG 65 of 1997

MARSHALL J
MELBOURNE (HEARD IN BRISBANE)
12 AUGUST 1997

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA )
)
QUEENSLAND DISTRICT REGISTRY )  QG 65 of 1997
)
GENERAL DIVISION )
BETWEEN:             

Gordon Andrew Rennie, John Axam, Peter McKay, Clifton Miles, Alan Snow, Ian Holmes, David Brennan,  Brendan Moffat and Dennis Bailey
Applicants

  AND:  

Sean Curley, John Anderson, Michael Conway, Helen Borradale, Bob Ellis, Gary Ablett, Julie Davies, Greg Singh and Terry Crimston
First Respondents

Sue Carlos, Athol Cairn Kelvin Goodall, K. Batt, Yolanda Fillip, Jim Walton, Peter Keogh, R. Teymant, D. Robinson, B. Ellis, D. Robertson, G. Kelly, Leigh Delaney, G. Vines, Karen Green, Neil Baker, J. McMahon, J. Hadaway, Margaret Warner, Kay Anastassiadis, Stephen Pinches, Eryl Brady, John Doyle, I. Jordan, Francis Van Datel, Brian Webb, R. Davis, Bill Brennan, Janet Good, Frank Nimmell, Suzanne Walsh, Chris Wenke
Second Respondents

CPSU, The Community and Public Sector Union
Third Respondent

JUDGE: MARSHALL J
PLACE: MELBOURNE (HEARD IN BRISBANE)
DATED: 12 AUGUST 1997

MINUTES OF ORDER

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The first respondents are directed to perform and observe the rules of the third respondent by treating the purported appointment of Gary Ablett to the office of Branch Councillor on 20 May 1997 as null and void.

2.The first respondents are directed to perform and observe the rules of the third respondent by treating the purported appointment of Bob Ellis to the office of delegate to Federal Council on 20 May 1997 as null and void.

3.The first respondents are directed to perform and observe the rules of the third respondent by treating…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Rennie, Gordon Andrew v Curley, Sean and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1997] FCA 765
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Rennie, Gordon Andrew v Curley, Sean, involved a legal dispute pertaining to the alleged improper administration of union affairs within the State Public Services Federation Group of the Community and Public Sector Union. The plaintiff sought to challenge the legitimacy of certain appointments and resolutions made by the union's branch council. The Queensland Industrial Relations Commission was tasked with resolving the issues brought forth by the plaintiff.

The legal issues before the court centered on the validity of specific appointments and resolutions within the union's governance structure. The plaintiff argued that the appointments of Gary Ablett as Branch Councillor and Bob Ellis as a delegate to the Federal Council were unlawful. Additionally, the plaintiff contested the legitimacy of certain resolutions passed by the Queensland Branch Council, which aimed to oppose the introduction of a national subscription rate or national membership fee prior to 1 July 1998, as well as opposing any increase in capitation dues by more than 10% before the same date. Furthermore, the plaintiff sought to nullify a motion passed by the Federal Council on 3 July 1997 regarding the annual subscription rate for union membership.

In its reasoning, the court examined the union's rules and the manner in which the appointments and resolutions were conducted. The court found that the appointments of Gary Ablett and Bob Ellis were indeed null and void due to procedural irregularities. It also determined that the resolutions passed by the Queensland Branch Council were legitimate as they adhered to the union's rules. However, the court ruled that the motion regarding the annual subscription rate passed by the Federal Council was to be declared null and void as it was not in compliance with the union's rules. Consequently, the court directed the respondents to observe the union's rules in various respects, including treating the appointments as null and void, observing the resolutions as legitimate, and voting against certain resolutions in future council meetings.

The court's final orders included directives for the respondents to treat the appointments as null and void, observe the resolutions as legitimate, and vote against certain resolutions in future council meetings. The court also directed Gregory Vines to not declare a specific motion regarding the annual subscription rate as carried by the Federal Council. The amended rule to show cause was otherwise discharged, concluding the proceedings with these specific directives in place.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The first respondents are directed to perform and observe the rules of the third respondent by treating the purported appointment of Gary Ablett to the office of Branch Councillor on 20 May 1997 as null and void.

2. The first respondents are directed to perform and observe the rules of the third respondent by treating the purported appointment of Bob Ellis to the office of delegate to Federal Council on 20 May 1997 as null and void.

3. The first respondents are directed to perform and observe the rules of the third respondent by treating as resolutions of the Branch Council the following resolutions:

(a) That the Queensland Branch Council bind the Queensland delegates to the Federal Council of the State Public Services Federation Group of the Community and Public Sector Union to oppose any motions which have the effect of introducing a national subscription rate or national membership fee prior to 1 July 1998.

(b) That the Queensland Branch Council bind the Queensland Branch delegates to the Federal Council of the State Public Services Federation Group of the Community and Public Sector Union to oppose any moves to increase the capitation dues by more than 10% prior to 1 July 1998.

4. Gregory Vines, one of the second respondents, is directed to perform and observe the rules of the third respondent by not declaring the vote on the following motion carried by Federal Council on 3 July 1997:

“That commencing from 1 July 1997, the annual subscription for membership of the Union which shall be payable by SPSF Group members shall be $185.04 per member, payable in monthly instalments of $15.42 per member PROVIDED THAT if a member is liable to pay subscription or membership fees of less than $185.04 per annum for membership to an Associated Body, then the annual subscription which shall be payable by each such member for membership of the Union shall be $90.70 payable in monthly instalments in the sum of $7.50 PROVIDED FURTHER THAT the preceding proviso shall not operate if the Associated Body has reduced the relevant subscriptions to less than $185.04 on or since 1 July 1995.

That the annual subscriptions fixed pursuant to paragraph 1 shall continue to apply until a new rate is fixed pursuant to the Rules.

That the annual subscriptions fixed pursuant to paragraph 1 shall be dealt with as follows.

(a) out of subscriptions paid by any member of any of the Signatory Bodies $5.00 per year will be used to fund the Federal Fund and the remainder shall be dealt in accordance with the Rules and the relevant provisions of the Deed; and

(b) out of subscriptions paid by any other member of the Group $5 will be used to fund the Federal Fund and the remainder of those subscriptions shall be paid to the Branch Fund of that member’s Branch and no part of such subscriptions shall be applied directly or indirectly towards any payment to, for or on behalf of any of the non-Signatory Bodies which has not entered into a legally binding arrangement with the CPSU as to the treatment of members and subscriptions unless such payment is a payment for services provided by that Body to the Union at the Union’s request.

Non-Signatory Bodies means that Associated Bodies which have not executed the Deed with the CPSU which was executed in July 1995. The term includes any legal entity outside the Union which is controlled or partly controlled by any of the non-Signatory Bodies.”

5. The first respondents are directed to perform and observe the rules of the third respondent by voting against any resolution before the Federal Council of the SPSF Group of the third respondent which imposes a national subscription or membership fee prior to 1 July 1998.

6. The first respondents are directed to perform and observe the rules of the third respondent by voting against any resolution before the Federal Council of the SPSF Group of the third respondent which increases capitation dues by more than ten per cent prior to 1 July 1998.

7. The amended rule to show cause is otherwise discharged.

Note:

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.