Reiter v Commissioner of Taxation

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Reiter v Commissioner of Taxation [2001] FCA 1068

INCOME TAX – ascertainment of assessable income – whether payments made in error to applicant by WorkCover Corporation of South Australia were assessable income – whether applicant “recovered” damages under a foreign law within meaning of subs 55(3) of Workers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1986 (SA) – whether income “derived” by applicant within meaning of subs 25(1) of Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (Cth) – whether income “received” by applicant within meaning of s 26(j) of Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (Cth)

Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (Cth) ss 25(1), 26(j)
WorkCover Corporation Act 1994 (SA) ss 4, 13
Workers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1986 (SA) ss 35, 36, 55

Wigens v Cook (1859) 28 LJCP 312 considered
Fergusson v Davison (1882) 8 QBD 470 considered
Ings v London and South Western Railway Company (1868) 4 LR CP 17 followed
Federal Commissioner of Taxation v Clarke (1927) 40 CLR 246 considered
Zobory v Commissioner of Taxation (1995) 64 FCR 86 followed

THOMAS JOSEPH REITER v COMMISSIONER OF TAXATION
S 16 of 2001

BRANSON J
SYDNEY (Heard in ADELAIDE)
8 AUGUST 2001


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

S 16 of 2001

BETWEEN:

THOMAS JOSEPH REITER
APPLICANT

AND:

COMMISSIONER OF TAXATION
RESPONDENT

JUDGE:

BRANSON J

DATE OF ORDER:

8 AUGUST 2001

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY (Heard in ADELAIDE)

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.        The decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal be set aside.

2.The case be remitted to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal to be heard and decided again in the light of the reason for judgment of the Court.

Note:    Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

S 16 of 2001

BETWEEN:

THOMAS JOSEPH REITER
APPLICANT

AND:

COMMISSIONER OF TAXATION
RESPONDENT

JUDGE:

BRANSON J

DATE:

8 AUGUST 2001

PLACE:

SYDNEY (Heard in ADELAIDE)

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

INTRODUCTION

  1. This is an “appeal” from a decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (“the Tribunal”) whereby the Tribunal affirmed a decision of the respondent disallowing the applicant’s objection to the notice of assessment for the year ending 30 June 1997 dated 2 October 1997 issued to him by the Deputy Commissioner of Taxation (“the DCT”). The question of law raised by the appeal is whether the amount of $16,773 paid by WorkCover Corporation of South Australia (“the Corporation”) to the applicant between 17 December 1996 and 30 June 1997 is assessable income of the applicant under subs 25(1) or s 26(j) of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (Cth) (“the ITAA”).

  2. For the reasons given below I have concluded the appeal should be allowed and the case formally remitted to the Tribunal to be heard and decided again in the light of these reasons for judgment.

    BACKGROUND FACTS

  3. The Corporation is a body corporate which owes its existence under its present name to s 4 of the WorkCover…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Reiter v Commissioner of Taxation and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2001] FCA 1068
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Reiter v Commissioner of Taxation, the applicant, Reiter, appealed against a decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) which had determined that certain income maintenance payments received by Reiter were assessable for income tax purposes. The background to the dispute involved Reiter being injured in an accident during his employment, resulting in income maintenance payments under the Workers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1986 (SA). Following a legal action in the Supreme Court of Victoria, a settlement was reached where Reiter repaid a portion of his income maintenance payments to WorkCover. The primary issue before the court was whether the portion of the income maintenance payments received by Reiter from 18 December 1996 to 30 June 1997 was assessable income under the Income Tax Assessment Act 1997 (Cth).

The court held that the term "recovered" in section 55(3) of the WRC Act should not be interpreted in a technical sense that would limit its scope to recovery by action resulting in an enforceable court judgment. Instead, the court found that if a worker settled a proceeding for compensation or damages, they would have recovered compensation or damages in respect of a disability under a foreign law within the meaning of section 55(3). Consequently, the court concluded that the amount of $16,773 paid by the Corporation to Reiter was income "derived" by him within the meaning of section 25(1) of the ITAA. The decision of the AAT was set aside, and the case was remitted to the AAT to be heard and decided again in light of the court's reasons for judgment.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal be set aside.

2. The case be remitted to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal to be heard and decided again in the light of the reason for judgment of the Court.

Background

Background to the litigation

For the reasons given below I have concluded the appeal should be allowed and the case formally remitted to the Tribunal to be heard and decided again in the light of these reasons for judgment.BACKGROUND FACTS The Corporation is a body corporate which owes its existence under its present name to s 4 of the WorkCover Corporation Act 1994 (SA). Section 13 of that Act provides that one of the functions of the Corporation is to administer the Workers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1986 (SA) (“the WRC Act”). The Tribunal summarised the background history of this applicant’s dispute with the DCT as follows:“The applicant was employed by K & S Freighters Pty Ltd as a heavy vehicle driver. On 19 February 1993, the applicant was injured in Laverton, Victoria, during the course of his employment. As a result of the injury, the applicant received weekly income maintenance payments pursuant to section 35 of the Workers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1986 (SA) (WRC Act).Following the accident, the applicant took legal action in the Victorian Supreme Court and on 17 December 1996 was awarded common law damages, less an amount to be deducted by agreement pursuant to provisions of the WRC Act. The applicant’s employer lodged an appeal against the verdict and WorkCover instituted separate recovery proceedings against the applicant in the Supreme Court of South Australia.While the two separate court actions were proceeding the applicant continued to receive income maintenance payments in terms of the WorkCover system. The judgment sum was invested in a term deposit account on trust for the applicant pending the outcome of the appeals.On 17 December 1997 a settlement was reached between the parties. The invested judgment sum was released to the applicant on condition that he repaid to WorkCover the ‘income maintenance’ payments that he had received from 18 December 1996 to 16 December 1997 totalling $32,304.48. After the WorkCover payments were deducted, the applicant received a total of $612,235.90.The applicant’s tax returns disclosed all of the income maintenance payments received as assessable income, including those received after 17 December 1996. On 14 December 1998 the applicant’s accountants requested the respondent to amend the applicant’s income tax returns for the years 1993 to 1997 inclusive to exclude the amounts previously shown as income maintenance payments received. The letter to the respondent included the statement that:‘The reasons for the request is that as a result of a compensation settlement an amount of $102,167.54 was repaid to WorkCover Corporation for income previously paid to me over the period 26th February 1993 to 9th December 1997, and it is requested that my assessment be amended to reduce my taxable income by the amounts repaid to WorkCover.’It seems that the letter of request dated 14 December 1998 was regarded by the respondent as a formal objection.On 10 May 1999, the respondent disallowed the applicant’s objection. The applicant conceded or agreed with the respondent’s decision in respect to the years of income 1993 to 1996 inclusive. However, the applicant did not accept the respondent’s decision in relation to the 1997 year of income and on 1 November 1999 appealed to this Tribunal for review of the respondent’s decision to include as assessable income an amount of $16,773 which represented income maintenance payments received from 18 December 1996 to 30 June 1997. Inherent in that rejection is the notion that the entitlement to receive those benefits ceased upon the judgment of damages and that the appeal therefrom was of no consequence.” (reference to exhibits deleted)

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

BRANSON J
However, such of the amount of $16,773 as was paid to the applicant by the Corporation as weekly payments before the expiration of the stay of execution of the judgment of the Supreme Court of Victoria (“the pre-bar amount”), if any, has not, in my view, been shown to be paid other than in accordance with the Act. The applicant did not advance submissions in support of the contention that the applicant held the pre-bar amount, if any, in trust for the Corporation. In my view it is plain that he did not. I conclude that the pre-bar amount, if any, was part of the gross income derived by the applicant within the meaning of subs 25(1) of the ITAA.CONCLUSION For the above reasons the decision of the Tribunal must be set aside. It is appropriate to stress, however, that the ground upon which this appeal has succeeded is a ground that was not relied upon before the Tribunal. As the Court did not hear from the parties on the issue of the proportion, if any, of the amount of $16,773 that was received by the applicant before the expiration of the stay of execution of the judgment of the Supreme Court of Victoria, the case must formally be remitted to the Tribunal to be heard and decided again in the light of these reasons for judgment.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: BRANSON J

The respondent has at all times contended that the amount of $16,773 paid by the Corporation to the applicant was assessable income in the applicant’s hands by reason of the operation of either subs 25(1) or s 26(j) of the ITAA. The respondent argued that the monies were properly paid to the applicant in accordance with an obligation imposed on the Corporation by the WRC Act, and that no constructive trust arises where a person is legally entitled to receive, and does in fact receive and apply to his or her own use, payments made to that person.CONSIDERATION As the applicant through his counsel, Ms Macdonald, acknowledged, the issue on this appeal is narrow. It is, in effect, whether the amount of $16,773 paid to the applicant by the Corporation was income “derived” by him within the meaning of subs 25(1) of the ITAA. The applicant accepted that if the amount of $16,773 was properly payable to him under the WRC Act it was income “derived” by him and became assessable for income tax purposes under the ITAA. The applicant initially relied on pars (a) and (h) of subs 36(1) and subs 55(3) of the WRC Act to support his contention that the relevant amount was not properly payable to him under the WRC Act. However, ultimately the applicant did not dispute that, although par 36(1)(a) of the WRC authorises the Corporation to discontinue weekly payments to a worker where the worker consents to the discontinuance, the subsection does not compel the Corporation to discontinue weekly payments in every case in which the worker consents to the discontinuance. That is, in the circumstances of this case, the crucial provisions of the WRC Act are par 36(1)(h) and subs 55(3). Having regard to the terms of subs 55(3) of the WRC Act (see [10] above), the contention of the applicant that the amount of $16,773 was not properly payable to him involves identification of time when the applicant “recovered” damages under the law of Victoria within the meaning of the subsection. The word “recover” has a technical legal meaning whereby it signifies recovery by action resulting in an enforceable court judgment (see, for example, Wigens v Cook (1859) 28 LJCP 312; Fergusson v Davison (1882) 8 QBD 470). The applicant contends that the word “recovered” in subs 55(3) of the WRC Act should be understood in this technical sense, or at least in a way which includes this technical sense. The respondent contends that the word should be understood in a non-technical way so as to mean obtain actual possession of, or control of, the monies which constitute the relevant compensation or damages. On the meaning of the word for which the respondent contends, a worker who obtained a judgment under a foreign law, but was not able to enforce the judgment debt, say because of the insolvency of the judgment debtor, would not have “recovered” damages under the foreign law. In my view, the terms “recovered” and “recovery” in subs 55(3) of the WRC Act are not intended to encompass only recovery by action resulting in an enforceable court judgment. If they were, the subsection would have a surprisingly narrow and artificial impact, particularly so far as the bar on recovery under the WRC Act is concerned. In my view, if a worker instituted a proceeding under a foreign law claiming compensation or damages and subsequently settled the proceeding on the basis that the proceeding would be discontinued upon the worker receiving payment on an agreed amount of money, the worker would be likely, depending on the circumstances leading to the settlement, to have recovered compensation or damages in respect of a disability under a foreign law within the meaning of subs 55(3). He or she would, it seems to me, almost certainly have done so if the settlement was consequent upon an admission of liability made by the other party to the proceeding. Similarly, in my view, if a worker asserted an entitlement under a foreign law to compensation or damages in respect of a disability, and that assertion led to an acknowledgment of liability and payment of compensation or damages, the worker would have recovered compensation or damages in respect of that disability under the foreign law within the meaning of subs 55(3) of the WRC Act. The bar to recovery of compensation in respect of the same disability under the WRC Act is, in my view, plainly intended to be a bar to recovery whether by legal action or otherwise.