Reinhard Wolfer v Computer Associates Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read

IN THE INDUSTRIAL RELATIONS  )    No. WI 538 of 1994

COURT OF AUSTRALIA  )

WESTERN AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY     )

BETWEEN:Reinhard Wolfer

Applicant

AND:Computer Associates Pty Ltd

Respondent

BEFORE:  Boon JR
PLACE:  Perth
HEARING DATE:                2 March 1995
JUDGMENT DATE:            12 April 1995

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

This notice of motion by the respondent to a claim of unlawful termination of employment seeks an order that the substantive application be dismissed for want of jurisdiction. The respondent alleges that this court has no jurisdiction to hear the substantive application because the applicant's relevant wages for the period of 12 months before the termination day exceeded the applicable amount of $60,000 pursuant to section 170CD of the Industrial Relations Act 1988.

BACKGROUND

The applicant worked as an account manager for mostly large accounts in computer software marketing.  He started work with the respondent on 4 January 1993 and his employment was terminated on 16 November 1994.

According to an affidavit filed by the respondent and sworn by Ken Lucas, regional manager of the respondent's business in Perth, under the applicant's contract of employment with the respondent he was entitled to receive a basic wage, a car allowance and commission on sales achieved by him.  During the period of 12 months immediately before the termination of the applicant's employment the applicant received monetary payments from the respondent in terms of such contract totalling $109,432.40.  These payments were made up as follows:

Base Salary             (December 1993 - November 1994)        Total:  $42,117.10
Car Allowance         (December 1993 - November 1994)        Total:  $2,499.96
Commission            (December 1993 - November 1994)        Total:  $67,815.34

In addition, the respondent provided superannuation benefits to the applicant in the sum of $387.50 per month as at 16 November 1994.

A further affidavit filed by the respondent states that the employer was not bound by any relevant state or federal award in respect of the applicant's employment.

Section 170CD (1) of the Act states "the following Subdivisions do not apply to a termination of employment of an employee who is not employed under award conditions if:

(a)in respect of an employee who was continuously employed by the employer during the period of 12 months immediately before the termination day - on the termination day the employee's relevant wages exceeded the applicable amount; ..."

Under Section 170CD (2) the applicable amount in this instance is $60,000.

Sub-section (4) of section 170CD defines "relevant wages", in relation to an employee, as meaning:
"... the total amount of the wages that the employee received, or was entitled to receive, from the employer in respect of:

(a)if para (1) (a) applies to the employee - the period of 12 months referred to in that para...

but, in relation to an employee whose contract of employment prescribes normal hours for the performance of work (whether by prescribing the number of hours in which, or the times at which, work is normally to be performed in a particular period), does not include any wages, additional to normal wages, in respect of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Reinhard Wolfer v Computer Associates Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1995] IRCA 150
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Industrial Relations Court of Western Australia heard a case brought by Reinhard Wolfer against his former employer, Computer Associates Pty Ltd, regarding the unlawful termination of his employment. Wolfer sought redress for his dismissal, but the respondent argued that the court lacked jurisdiction over the matter as Wolfer's relevant wages exceeded the statutory limit of $60,000 for the 12 months preceding his termination, as per section 170CD of the Industrial Relations Act 1988. The court needed to determine whether the components of Wolfer's remuneration, including commission, should be considered part of his 'relevant wages' for the purposes of section 170CD.

The court considered the ordinary meaning of 'wages' and whether it should encompass commission, in line with various statutory definitions and case law. The respondent argued that commissions should be included in 'relevant wages', citing cases that defined wages broadly. Conversely, Wolfer's counsel maintained that commissions should not be included, arguing for a distinction between 'wages' and 'remuneration'. The court ultimately decided that commissions should not be considered part of 'relevant wages', as they are irregular and do not reflect a consistent payment for services rendered. This conclusion was based on the nature of commission as performance-based, the legislative intent to exclude high-income non-award employees, and the distinction between 'wages' and 'remuneration' as used in the Act. As a result, Wolfer's relevant wages were determined to be below the statutory threshold, and the court dismissed the respondent's application for lack of jurisdiction.

The court's order dismissed the respondent's application and scheduled a mediation conference to facilitate potential settlement discussions. This decision underscored the importance of interpreting statutory terms like'relevant wages' in context and highlighted the court's role in ensuring fair application of industrial laws.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.