Reid v Commissioner of Patents

Link copied
Case Copied 26 min read
20 CLR 261

THE COMMISSIONER OF PATENTS

RESPONDENT.

THE KING

THE COMMISSIONER OF PATENTS.

Ex PARTE REID. Patent-Application-Refusal by Commissioner to accept--Grounds of refusal-

Application informal-Appeal to High Court-Application under intercolonial atrrangements-Amendment-Mandamus-Patents Act 1903-1909 (No. 21 of 1903-No. 17 of 1909), secs. 32, 33, 46, 47, 121, 122-Patents Regulations MELBOURNE, 1912 (Statutory Rules 1912, No. 76), regs. 4, 31; Sched. 2, Form A6.

The applicant having applied in New Zealand for protection of an invention applied for a patent for the same invention pursuant to secs. 121 and 122 of the Patents Act 1903-1909, the application being in accordance with Form A6 in Schedule 2 to the Patents Regulations 1912, and he lodged with the appli- cation a copy of the complete specification which had been lodged in New Zealand. The Commissioner refused to accept the application on the ground that a copy of the provisional specification which had been lodged in New Zealand did not also accompany the application. The Commissioner sub- sequently refused an application for leave to amend the application by converting it into an ordinary application for a patent under secs. 32 and 33.

Held, by Griffith C.J. and Gavan Duffy J. (Isaacs J. dissenting), that the refusal to accept the application was not a refusal from which an appeal lay to the High Court under secs. 46 and 47, and that an appeal did not lie

20 CLR 262

from the refusal to allow the amendment, but that a mandamus should go to the Commissioner directing him to proceed with the hearing of the application for a patent.

By Griffith C.J.-The words any other lawful ground of objection in sec. 46 of the Patents Act 1903-1909 refer to objections to the specification, and do not include an objection that the application for a patent with which the specification is lodged is irregular in form.

APPEAL from the Commissioner of Patents, order nisi for mandamus, and motion referred to the Court.

Alexander Walker Reid on 21st August 1913 filed an applica- tion for a patent for an invention entitled " An improved milking machine pulsator," the application being in accordance with Form A6 in Schedule 2 to the Patents Regulations 1912, which is applicable to applications for a patent under international or intercolonial arrangements as provided for in secs. 121 and 122 of the Patents Act 1903-1909. In the application the applicant stated that on 16th December 1912 he had made an application in New Zealand for protection of the same invention, and with the application was lodged a certified copy of the New Zealand complete specification for the invention.

On 10th January 1914 the Deputy Commissioner wrote to the applicant informing him that, on consideration of the New Zea- Hand documents accompanying the application, it appeared that a provisional specification had been lodged by the applicant in New Zealand, and that he was therefore not entitled to the benefit of sec. 121, as the period of three months allowed by reg. 31 for lodging…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Reid v Commissioner of Patents and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1915] HCA 42
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Alexander Walker Reid applied for a patent in Australia under intercolonial arrangements, claiming priority based on an earlier application in New Zealand. The Commissioner of Patents refused to accept the application, stating that a copy of the provisional specification lodged in New Zealand had not been provided within the prescribed time, rendering the application irregular. Reid then sought to amend his application to convert it into an ordinary patent application, but this was also refused. Reid appealed to the High Court, seeking both an appeal against the refusal to amend and an order for mandamus to compel the Commissioner to hear his original application.

The legal issues before the High Court were whether the Commissioner's refusal to accept the application was a decision from which an appeal lay to the High Court, whether the subsequent refusal to allow an amendment was appealable, and whether a writ of mandamus should issue directing the Commissioner to proceed with the hearing of the patent application. The Court was also required to interpret the scope of "any other lawful ground of objection" under section 46 of the Patents Act 1903-1909 and the effect of non-compliance with Patent Regulations regarding the lodging of specifications.

Griffith C.J. and Gavan Duffy J. held that the Commissioner's refusal was not a decision appealable under sections 46 and 47 of the Act, as it related to an irregularity in the form of the application rather than an objection to the specification itself. They also found that the refusal to allow the amendment was not appealable. However, they determined that a writ of mandamus should issue, as the Commissioner had failed to consider the merits of the application and had instead declined to proceed based on preliminary, and in their view, irrelevant grounds. Isaacs J., dissenting, concluded that the Commissioner's refusal was a final decision under section 46, making it appealable, and that the applicant had not established grounds for mandamus.

The majority ordered that the order nisi for mandamus be made absolute, directing the Commissioner to proceed with the hearing of the application.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established