CITATION: Regina v Rahme; Regina v El-Hayek [2004] NSWCCA 226 HEARING DATE(S): 11 June 2004 JUDGMENT DATE:
7 July 2004JUDGMENT OF: Dowd J at 1; Hislop J at 2; Smart AJ at 3 DECISION: (Rahme) See para 57 (El Hayek) See para 71 CATCHWORDS: Application of principles of totality to setting of non-parole periods when sentences accumulated - need to allow adeqiuate periods on parole when serving long sentences LEGISLATION CITED: Nil CASES CITED: Nil PARTIES :
Regina v John Claude Rahme
Regina v Nakhle El-HayekFILE NUMBER(S): CCA 60074/04; 60076/04 COUNSEL: (Rahme) Mr Ramage QC
(El-Hayek) Mr R Button
(Crown) Mr G RowlingSOLICITORS: (Rahme) E Rahme
(El-Hayek) S O'Connor
(Crown) S Kavanagh
LOWER COURTJURISDICTION: District Court LOWER COURT FILE NUMBER(S): (Rahme) 2/11/0949;01/11/0408
(El-Hayek) 01/11/0408LOWER COURT
JUDICIAL OFFICER :Solomon DCJ & Stewart ADCJ
60076/04
DOWD J
HISLOP J
SMART AJ
Wednesday, 7 July 2004
Regina v John Claude RAHME
Regina v Nakhle EL-HAYEK
Judgment
1. DOWD J: I have read the judgment of Smart AJ in draft form I agree with the proposed orders and his reasons therefor.
2. HISLOP J: I agree with Smart AJ.
3. SMART AJ: John Claude Rahme seeks leave to appeal against the following sentences:
Sentences imposed 8 November 2002
(1) Armed robbery with a dangerous weapon (gun)
(Maximum penalty 25 years)22/7/00
Belmore Park
Nth Parramatta6 years imprisonment;
NPP 4.5 years from 10/11/01(2) Demand money with menaces
(maximum penalty 10 years)22/7/00
Belmore Park
Nth ParramattaFixed term of 3.5 years from 10/11/01 (3) Sexual intercourse with a person (KB) above
age of 10 years and under the age of 16 years, namely 15 years
(maximum penalty 8 years)27/7/00
at Parramatta2.5 years imprisonment
from 10/5/06;
NPP 1.5 years ending 9/11/07(4) Supply methylamphetamine
(maximum penalty 15 years)27/7/00 at
Parramatta3.5 years imprisonment from 10/5/06;
NPP 1.5 years ending 9/11/07
4. Thus Stewart ADCJ effectively sentenced the offender to a total term of imprisonment of 8 years from 10 November 2001 to 9 November 2009 with a non-parole period of 6 years ending on 9 November 2007.
Judge Solomon
Sentences imposed 16 July 2003
| INDICTMENT OF 18 NOVEMBER 2002 | |||
| (1) | Armed robbery with a dangerous weapon (gun) (maximum penalty 25 years) | 28/7/00 at Nth Sydney TAFE College | 7 years imprisonment from 28/5/05; NPP 4 years ending 27/5/09 |
| (2) | Possess firearm (maximum penalty 8 years) | 28/7/00 at Parramatta | Fixed term of imprisonment of 2 years from 28/5/05 |
| INDICTMENT OF 23 MAY 2003 | |||
| (3) | Sexual intercourse with a person (BK) over 10 and under 16, namely 15. namely 3 counts of sexual intercourse with a minor) | 27 July 2000 at Parramatta | 2½ years imprisonment from 28 May 2009; NPP of 1½ years ending 27/11/10 |
| INDICTMENT OF 23 SEPTEMBER 2002 | |||
| (1) | Do act with intent to influence witness (maximum penalty 7 years) | 4 May 2002 at Potts Point | 2 years imprisonment from 28/11/10; NPP of 1… |
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Regina v Rahme; Regina v El-Hayek and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2004] NSWCCA 226
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues before the court involved interpreting the principles of totality and their application to the setting of non-parole periods. The applicants argued that the cumulative effect of their sentences should have been considered to ensure they had a realistic opportunity for release on parole. The court had to determine whether the non-parole periods were set in a manner consistent with these principles and whether they allowed for an adequate period on parole given the length of the sentences.
The High Court found that the non-parole periods set for the applicants did not adequately account for the cumulative effect of their sentences. The court emphasised the importance of allowing a reasonable period on parole for individuals serving long sentences, as a means of reflecting the principles of totality. The non-parole periods were deemed to be insufficient in this regard. Consequently, the court quashed the non-parole periods and remitted the matter to the original sentencing courts for reconsideration in light of the principles of totality.
In conclusion, the High Court held that the non-parole periods set for the applicants were not consistent with the principles of totality and did not allow for an adequate period on parole. The court quashed the non-parole periods and directed the original sentencing courts to reconsider the matter, taking into account the need to ensure that the applicants had a realistic opportunity for release on parole.