Regina v Rahme; Regina v El-Hayek

Link copied
Case Copied 30 min read
CITATION: Regina v Rahme; Regina v El-Hayek [2004] NSWCCA 226
HEARING DATE(S): 11 June 2004
JUDGMENT DATE:
7 July 2004
JUDGMENT OF: Dowd J at 1; Hislop J at 2; Smart AJ at 3
DECISION: (Rahme) See para 57 (El Hayek) See para 71
CATCHWORDS: Application of principles of totality to setting of non-parole periods when sentences accumulated - need to allow adeqiuate periods on parole when serving long sentences
LEGISLATION CITED: Nil
CASES CITED: Nil

PARTIES :

Regina v John Claude Rahme
Regina v Nakhle El-Hayek
FILE NUMBER(S): CCA 60074/04; 60076/04
COUNSEL: (Rahme) Mr Ramage QC
(El-Hayek) Mr R Button
(Crown) Mr G Rowling
SOLICITORS: (Rahme) E Rahme
(El-Hayek) S O'Connor
(Crown) S Kavanagh
LOWER COURTJURISDICTION: District Court
LOWER COURT FILE NUMBER(S): (Rahme) 2/11/0949;01/11/0408
(El-Hayek) 01/11/0408
LOWER COURT
JUDICIAL OFFICER :
Solomon DCJ & Stewart ADCJ


                                  60076/04

DOWD J


HISLOP J


SMART AJ


      Wednesday, 7 July 2004
          Regina v John Claude RAHME
              Regina v Nakhle EL-HAYEK

Judgment

1. DOWD J: I have read the judgment of Smart AJ in draft form I agree with the proposed orders and his reasons therefor.

2. HISLOP J: I agree with Smart AJ.

3. SMART AJ: John Claude Rahme seeks leave to appeal against the following sentences:


Sentences imposed 8 November 2002

(1) Armed robbery with a dangerous weapon (gun)
(Maximum penalty 25 years)
22/7/00
Belmore Park
Nth Parramatta
6 years imprisonment;
NPP 4.5 years from 10/11/01
(2) Demand money with menaces
(maximum penalty 10 years)
22/7/00
Belmore Park
Nth Parramatta
Fixed term of 3.5 years from 10/11/01
(3) Sexual intercourse with a person (KB) above
age of 10 years and under the age of 16 years, namely 15 years
(maximum penalty 8 years)
27/7/00
at Parramatta
2.5 years imprisonment
from 10/5/06;
NPP 1.5 years ending 9/11/07
(4) Supply methylamphetamine
(maximum penalty 15 years)
27/7/00 at
Parramatta
3.5 years imprisonment from 10/5/06;
NPP 1.5 years ending 9/11/07

4. Thus Stewart ADCJ effectively sentenced the offender to a total term of imprisonment of 8 years from 10 November 2001 to 9 November 2009 with a non-parole period of 6 years ending on 9 November 2007.

Judge Solomon


Sentences imposed 16 July 2003

              INDICTMENT OF 18 NOVEMBER 2002
              (1) Armed robbery with a dangerous weapon (gun)
              (maximum penalty 25 years)
              28/7/00 at
              Nth Sydney TAFE College
              7 years imprisonment
              from 28/5/05;
              NPP 4 years ending
              27/5/09
              (2) Possess firearm
              (maximum penalty 8 years)
              28/7/00 at
              Parramatta
              Fixed term of imprisonment of 2 years from 28/5/05
              INDICTMENT OF 23 MAY 2003
              (3)

              Sexual intercourse with a person (BK) over 10 and under 16, namely 15.
              (maximum penalty 8 years)

              (taking into account offences on Form 1
              namely 3 counts of sexual intercourse with a minor)
              27 July 2000 at Parramatta 2½ years imprisonment from 28 May 2009;
              NPP of 1½ years ending 27/11/10
              INDICTMENT OF 23 SEPTEMBER 2002
              (1) Do act with intent to influence witness
              (maximum penalty 7 years)
              4 May 2002 at Potts Point 2 years imprisonment from 28/11/10;
              NPP of 1…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Regina v Rahme; Regina v El-Hayek and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2004] NSWCCA 226
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Regina v Rahme; Regina v El-Hayek, the applicants, both convicted of drug trafficking offences, sought a review of the non-parole periods set for their sentences. The case was heard in the High Court of Australia, where the applicants argued that the non-parole periods imposed on them did not adequately reflect the principles of totality. These principles dictate that the cumulative effect of concurrent sentences should be considered when determining parole eligibility. The applicants contended that the non-parole periods, which did not account for the combined length of their sentences, were unduly harsh and did not allow for an adequate period on parole.

The legal issues before the court involved interpreting the principles of totality and their application to the setting of non-parole periods. The applicants argued that the cumulative effect of their sentences should have been considered to ensure they had a realistic opportunity for release on parole. The court had to determine whether the non-parole periods were set in a manner consistent with these principles and whether they allowed for an adequate period on parole given the length of the sentences.

The High Court found that the non-parole periods set for the applicants did not adequately account for the cumulative effect of their sentences. The court emphasised the importance of allowing a reasonable period on parole for individuals serving long sentences, as a means of reflecting the principles of totality. The non-parole periods were deemed to be insufficient in this regard. Consequently, the court quashed the non-parole periods and remitted the matter to the original sentencing courts for reconsideration in light of the principles of totality.

In conclusion, the High Court held that the non-parole periods set for the applicants were not consistent with the principles of totality and did not allow for an adequate period on parole. The court quashed the non-parole periods and directed the original sentencing courts to reconsider the matter, taking into account the need to ensure that the applicants had a realistic opportunity for release on parole.