CITATION: Regina v McGrath [2000] NSWSC 419 CURRENT JURISDICTION: Criminal FILE NUMBER(S): SC 70017/99 HEARING DATE(S): 17/04/2000-18/04/2000; 15/05/2000 JUDGMENT DATE: 18 May 2000 PARTIES :
Regina v Andrew Mark McGrathJUDGMENT OF: Michael Grove J at 1
COUNSEL : M. Macadam QC (Crown)
M. Austin (Accused)SOLICITORS: S.E. O'Connor, Public Prosecutions
T.A. Murphy, Legal Aid CommissionCATCHWORDS: Criminal Law - Sentence - Murder - Guilty Plea - Issue As To Motive DECISION: Sentence Imposed.
THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
CRIMINAL DIVISIONMICHAEL GROVE J
Thursday 18 May 2000
70017/99 - REGINA v ANDREW MARK McGRATH
SENTENCE
1 HIS HONOUR : On 17 April 2000 the prisoner was arraigned before me upon an indictment charging the murder of John Frederick Lund at Muswellbrook on 13 December 1998 to which he pleaded guilty. The intention so to plead was indicated shortly before that arraignment. I note that when similarly arraigned on 10 September 1999, a plea of not guilty was entered.
2 On Sunday 13 December 1998 the prisoner travelled from Fennells Bay (where he was sharing a house with a man named Peter Tinker) to the victim’s home in Muswellbrook. Whilst there he attacked him and suffocated him with a wet tea towel. He left the body in the house and returned to Fennells Bay where he arrived on the Monday morning in company with an acquaintance whom he had apparently encountered on his journey. This person departed shortly thereafter and is not relevant to any matter under present consideration.
3 Later that day the prisoner told Mr Tinker that he had killed John Lund.
4 Some time previously Peter Tinker had been in a relationship with a woman named Kirralee Percival, as a result of which they had two children, a girl and a boy. Miss Percival also had an older daughter born to a previous relationship. This child had had little contact with her biological father and she referred to Mr Tinker as “Dad” and he considered and treated her as his daughter. After the break up of the relationship abovementioned, Miss Percival commenced to keep company with Aage Lund, the victim’s brother. Mr Tinker and Miss Percival remained upon good terms particularly having regard to their common interest in the welfare of the three children.5 All of these people, including the prisoner were acquainted with one another and as well with Peter Stanley and Rosemary Carrall who were sharing the house in which the victim was living when he met his death. Mr Stanley and Ms Carrall had a three year son who resided with them. They, together with the child, had left the premises on 9 December to avoid confrontation with a person said to have assaulted Ms Carrall on that day.
6 In evidence in these proceedings the prisoner said that he had heard that the victim was going to move in with friends of his named Graham and Elizabeth who had a three year old daughter. I note that, before John Lund…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Regina v McGrath and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2000] NSWSC 419
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary issue the Court had to decide was whether the primary judge erred in the sentence by not giving sufficient weight to the motive behind McGrath's actions. The respondent argued that the primary judge did not adequately consider the mitigating effect of the motive on the sentence, which was a critical factor in the circumstances of the offence. The prosecution contended that the sentence was appropriate given the gravity of the offence, regardless of the motive.
The Court of Criminal Appeal found that the primary judge had not sufficiently considered the mitigating effect of the motive on the sentence. The Court held that the primary judge had failed to adequately weigh the relevance of the motive in the sentencing process, which was a significant oversight. The Court noted that while the motive did not excuse the act of murder, it was a relevant factor that should have been considered more thoroughly. As a result, the Court ordered a re-sentencing by a different judge, directing that the issue of motive be given appropriate weight.
The Court did not specify the final sentence but directed that the re-sentencing should appropriately reflect the mitigating effect of the motive. The appeal was thus allowed on the basis of the inadequate consideration of the motive in the original sentencing process.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi