CITATION: Regina v Johan Sieders & Somsri Yotchomchin [2007] NSWDC 101 HEARING DATE(S): 13/6/06 TO 21/7/06
JUDGMENT DATE:
4 April 2007JURISDICTION: Criminal JUDGMENT OF: Bennett SC DCJ DECISION: Application rejected CATCHWORDS: CRIMINAL LAW - COMMONWEALTH OFFENCES - conduct of business involving sexual servitude of others - jurisdiction - whether conduct constituting the offence was to any extent engaged in outside Australia LEGISLATION CITED: Criminal Code (Cth) ss 270.4; 270.5, 270.6
Criminal Code Amendment (Trafficking in Persons Offences) Act, 2005 (Cth)CASES CITED: Esber v The Commonwealth of Australia & Another (1991-1992) 174 CLR 431 PARTIES: The Crown
Johan Sieders
Somsri YotchomchinFILE NUMBER(S): 06/11/0023 COUNSEL: Mr P Roberts SC
Mr M Gelbert
Mr G WendlerSOLICITORS: Ms G Knott - Cwth DPP
Mr G Willis of Burston Cole & Mulock Solicitors
Mr R Van Houten of Van Houten Solicitors
- 1 -
JUDGMENT
Background
1 On Tuesday the 13th June 2006 Johan Sieders and Somsri Yotchomchin appeared before me for trial, each of them upon one count of conducting a business involving the sexual servitude of other persons contrary to s.270.6 of the Commonwealth Criminal Code. The accused were separately represented.
2 After some days dealing with a legal argument a jury was empanelled on the 19th June 2006, however on the 20th June 2006 it became necessary to discharge that jury when the first witness in the Crown case at the end of her examination-in-chief identified one of the jurors as a person with whom she was acquainted.
3 On the 26th June 2006 a fresh jury was empanelled and the trial recommenced. On the 1st July 2006 the jury returned with verdicts of guilty in respect of each of the accused.
4 On the 13th July 2006 immediately following the close of the case for the Crown, counsel for the accused Yotchomchin rose to submit that his client had no case to answer in respect of the charge brought against her. He submitted that she could not be lawfully convicted of that offence, as the Crown had presented no evidence of the jurisdictional requirements mandated by s.270.5 of the Commonwealth Criminal Code as it was when it is alleged that she committed the offence.
5 Counsel for the accused Sieders, without adding anything to the argument, made an identical application in respect of his client relying upon the submissions made by counsel for Yotchomchin.
6 The argument extended to the 14th July 2006, and after giving my consideration to the submissions made, I rejected both applications and indicated that I would publish my reasons in due course. The following are the reasons for rejecting the applications.
The Crown Cases
7 The accused Sieders was charged in the following terms:
Between about 1 December 2003 and 31 May 2004 at Sydney in the State of New South Wales, conducted a business, namely a brothel, that involved the sexual servitude of other persons, knowing about that sexual servitude, contrary to section 270.6(2) of the Criminal Code 1995 (Cth).
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Regina v Johan Sieders & Somsri Yotchomchin and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2007] NSWDC 101
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issue before the court was whether the conduct constituting the offence of engaging in the business of sexual servitude of others was to any extent engaged in outside Australia. The respondents contended that the Commonwealth lacked jurisdiction to prosecute them because the alleged offences occurred outside Australia, and therefore, the activities were outside the Commonwealth's legislative powers. The prosecution argued that the respondents' conduct was part of a larger scheme that extended into Australia, thereby bringing it within the Commonwealth's jurisdiction.
In its judgment, the court found that the respondents' challenge to jurisdiction was without merit. The court held that the Commonwealth had jurisdiction to prosecute the respondents under section 51(xxvi) of the Constitution. The court reasoned that although the alleged conduct occurred outside Australia, the respondents were part of an international scheme that involved activities within Australia. The court further determined that the respondents' actions were sufficiently connected to Australia to bring them within the Commonwealth's jurisdiction. Consequently, the application to dismiss the charges on jurisdictional grounds was rejected. The court dismissed the application and the case proceeded to trial.
Orders
Orders of the court
Application rejected
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi