CITATION: Regina v Flood [1999] NSWCCA 240 FILE NUMBER(S): CCA 60333/98; 60334/98 HEARING DATE(S): 28 June 1999 JUDGMENT DATE:
28 June 1999PARTIES :
Regina v Jeffrey James Flood
Regina v Scott Joseph FloodJUDGMENT OF: Sully J; Bell J
LOWER COURT JURISDICTION: District Court LOWER COURT FILE NUMBER(S) : 98/51/0074 LOWER COURT JUDICIAL OFFICER: Hosking DCJ
COUNSEL: J. C Nicholson SC/C. Lyons (Appellant)
L. M. B. Lamprati (Crown)SOLICITORS: T. A. Murphy (Appellant)
C. K. Smith (Crown)CATCHWORDS: CASES CITED: R v Coleman (1990) 47 ACrimR 306;
R v Fletcher-Jones (1994) 75 ACrimR 381 at 387;
R v Johnson [1917] 17 SR(NSW)481-4; and R v Sorlie [1925] 25 SR(NSW) 532 at 539DECISION: Leave to appeal granted in each case.; Appeal dismissed in each case.
IN THE COURT OF
CRIMINAL APPEAL60333/98
60334/98SULLY J
BELL J28 June 1999
1 SULLY J: On 2 June 1998 the present applicants, who are brothers, stood for sentence before his Honour Judge W.D Hosking QC, then sitting in the District Court at Coffs Harbour. Each applicant had pleaded guilty before his Honour to four offences which were related offences arising out of one set of circumstances.JUDGMENT
REGINA v Jeffrey James FLOOD
REGINA v Scott Joseph FLOOD
2 The first offfence to which each applicant pleaded guilty was an offence of armed robbery, an offence which contravenes s 97(1) of the Crimes Act and attracts a statutory maximum penalty of penal servitude for twenty years. The second and third matters involved the stealing of a motor vehicle, a contravention of s 154AA(1) of the Crimes Act and attracting a statutory maximum penalty of penal servitude for ten years. The fourth offence was that of detaining a person with intent to hold for advantage, a contravention of s 90A of the Crimes Act and attracting a statutory maximum penalty of penal servitude for fourteen years
3 In respect of the offence of armed robbery, the learned sentencing Judge imposed a penalty in the case of each applicant of penal servitude for six years apportioned between a minimum term of three years and six months and an additional term of two years and six months. In respect of the two offences relating to the stealing of a motor vehicle, his Honour imposed a fixed term of penal servitude for two years and to be served concurrently with the sentence imposed in respect of the armed robbery. In respect of the detaining with intent to hold for advantage offence, his Honour fixed a term of penal servitude for three years imposed as a fixed term and to be served concurrently with the other penalties.
4 Each applicant seeks leave to appeal against the severity of those sentences.
5 The objective facts can be shortly stated as follows: on the day in question, which was 7 March 1998, the two applicants approached a young man called Bottero in a public carpark. Put simply, they told him they were intending to rob him; forced him into…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Regina v Flood and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
Details
- Case
- [1999] NSWCCA 240
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The Court of Criminal Appeal of New South Wales considered an appeal against sentence by two brothers, Jeffrey James Flood and Scott Joseph Flood, who had pleaded guilty to multiple offences including armed robbery, motor vehicle theft, and detaining a person with intent to hold for advantage. The appeals were dismissed, but leave to appeal was granted. The brothers had pleaded guilty to offences arising from the armed robbery and subsequent detention of a young man, Mr Bottero, in a public carpark. They forced him into his parents' vehicle, robbed him, and drove him to various locations before releasing him. The primary judge in the District Court had sentenced each brother to six years for armed robbery, two years for the motor vehicle thefts (to be served concurrently), and three years for the detaining offence (also to be served concurrently), resulting in an effective sentence of six years.
The applicants argued that the sentencing judge had erred by not considering their intoxication as a mitigating factor and by overestimating the gravity of the kidnapping aspect of the offence. The Court found that the sentencing judge's comments about intoxication did not constitute a legal error, as the judge had acknowledged that intoxication could explain why an offence occurred but was not a licence to commit crimes. Regarding the gravity of the kidnapping, the Court held that the sentencing judge's characterisation of the offence as a "grave aggravation" was not semantically flawed when considered in the broader context of the remarks on sentence. The Court also noted that the brothers had committed the offences while on parole and on a bond, respectively, which made their actions proportionately more serious. The Court concluded that the sentences were appropriate given the severity of the offences and that no other sentence was warranted in law. The Court further recommended that the applicants be given every opportunity to participate in rehabilitative courses while in custody.
The applicants argued that the sentencing judge had erred by not considering their intoxication as a mitigating factor and by overestimating the gravity of the kidnapping aspect of the offence. The Court found that the sentencing judge's comments about intoxication did not constitute a legal error, as the judge had acknowledged that intoxication could explain why an offence occurred but was not a licence to commit crimes. Regarding the gravity of the kidnapping, the Court held that the sentencing judge's characterisation of the offence as a "grave aggravation" was not semantically flawed when considered in the broader context of the remarks on sentence. The Court also noted that the brothers had committed the offences while on parole and on a bond, respectively, which made their actions proportionately more serious. The Court concluded that the sentences were appropriate given the severity of the offences and that no other sentence was warranted in law. The Court further recommended that the applicants be given every opportunity to participate in rehabilitative courses while in custody.