CITATION: Regina v Amir Ibrahim El Mostafa [2007] NSWDC 332 HEARING DATE(S): Please see Regina v Amir Ibrahim El Mostafa [2007] NSWDC 219 for hearing dates
JUDGMENT DATE:
27 April 2007JURISDICTION: District Court of New South Wales JUDGMENT OF: Cogswell SC DCJ at 1 DECISION: Evidence tendered by the Crown is admissible CATCHWORDS: Criminal law - Evidence - Telephone intercepts - Alias of accused - Prejudice LEGISLATION CITED: ss 135, 137 Evidence Act 1995 PARTIES: Regina
Amir Ibrahim El MostafaFILE NUMBER(S): 06/11/0574 COUNSEL: Mr Calvert for the Crown
Mr Simpson for Amir Ibrahim El MostafaSOLICITORS: Ms Flemming for the NSW DPP
Ms Duffy for Amir Ibrahim El Mostafa
JUDGMENT
1. These are applications by Mr Simpson on behalf of the accused El Mostafa to reject evidence tendered by the Crown or for me to rule that such tendered evidence is inadmissible. What is proposed to be tendered by the Crown is the product of two telephone intercepts legally obtained in which it is admitted by Mr Simpson his client, Mr El Mostafa, was a participant.
2. For the purposes of the voir dire I have had tendered and admitted into evidence a transcript of both of the relevant telephone calls. They are transcripts prepared by the defence. I also admitted into evidence some documents concerning another charge faced by Mr El Mostafa and which was dismissed.
3. Mr Simpson accepts the following propositions: that the translations are those recently obtained by the defence; that the intercepts are relevantly short in duration; that each of the calls contained his client's voice; in each call his client is referred to as MV 1 and that the telephone intercepts were lawfully intercepted.
4. I will deal first with VDA and VD2 which are both transcripts of a telephone call which is referred to as call number 5 and occurred on 23 March 2005. Mr Simpson's first submission is that any reference to his client being called Abu Fajer by the other caller should be inadmissible because I have previously given a ruling that evidence of an admission by his client given during a police interview is inadmissible. That admission was to the effect that he is known as Abu Fajer.
5. Mr Simpson argues that it would be unfair and inappropriate for the Crown to try to get in evidence of a similar admission in another way. I reject that submission. The ruling I gave was in another context and concerned an admission allegedly made in the context of a police interrogation. I do not regard it as inappropriate for the Crown to tender other evidence of admissions to the same effect which may not be affected by the same difficulties. It seems clear to me from this particular telephone call that it is open to the jury to infer that the person identified as MV1 adopts the reference to him by the name Abu Fajer.
6. The second point in respect of call number 5 is in respect of…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Regina v Amir Ibrahim El Mostafa and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2007] NSWDC 332
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court considered the relevance and admissibility of evidence obtained through telephone intercepts. It examined whether the use of the alias in the intercepted communications would unfairly prejudice the accused, thereby affecting the fairness of the trial. The court noted that the use of an alias did not inherently render the evidence inadmissible, provided that the evidence was relevant and probative of the charges against the accused. The court further found that the potential prejudice to the accused due to the use of an alias did not outweigh the probative value of the evidence. Consequently, the court ruled that the evidence was admissible and would not unfairly prejudice the accused.
The court's decision was that the evidence tendered by the Crown, despite being obtained through intercepts that referenced the accused's alias, was admissible. The potential prejudice to the accused did not render the evidence inadmissible, as the probative value outweighed any prejudicial effect. The court's ruling allowed the evidence to be presented in the trial, thereby enabling the Crown to proceed with its case against the accused.
Orders
Orders of the court
Evidence tendered by the Crown is admissible
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Full text does not contain this section.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Full text does not contain this section.