Reflex Instruments Asia Pacific Pty Ltd v Minnovare Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

IP AUSTRALIA

AUSTRALIAN PATENT OFFICE

Reflex Instruments Asia Pacific Pty Ltd v Minnovare Limited [2016] APO 68

Patent Application:                2012101210

Title:Drill hole orientation apparatus

Patent Applicant:                   Minnovare Limited

Opponent:Reflex Instruments Asia Pacific Pty Ltd

Delegate:Dr S.D. Barker

Decision Date:  11 October 2016

Hearing Date:  Written submissions completed 19 August 2016

Catchwords:  PATENTS – extension of time to file evidence in answer – regulation 5.9(2) – whether there were exceptional circumstances that warrant an extension – extension refused

Representation:  Patent applicant:  Lord and Company

Opponent:Gilbert +Tobin, Solicitors

IP AUSTRALIA

AUSTRALIAN PATENT OFFICE

Patent Application:                2012101210

Title:Drill hole orientation apparatus

Patent Applicant:                   Minnovare Limited

Date of Decision:                   11 October 2016

DECISION

Extension of time refused.

The Commissioner will not proceed to arrange a hearing of the opposition until a decision has been made in relation to regulation 5.23.

I award costs according to Schedule 8 of the Patents Regulations against Minnovare Limited.

REASONS FOR DECISION

  1. This matter relates to a request for an extension of time to file evidence in answer and is determined under regulation 5.9 of the Patents Regulations (the Regulations) as amended on 15 April 2013 by the Intellectual Property Legislation Amendments (Raising the Bar) Regulation 2013 (No 1) (the Amendment Regulation).

    Background

  2. An application for innovation patent number 2012101210 was filed by DHS (Aust) Pty Ltd on 8 August 2012, and the patent was granted on 6 September 2012.  The ownership was subsequently changed to Minnovare Pty Ltd and more recently to Minnovare Limited (Minnovare).  The patent was examined and certified on 11 September 2013. 

  3. A request for a re-examination of the patent was filed on 15 November 2013 by a third party.  The patent was re-examined and an adverse report was issued on 22 January 2014.  Minnovare filed amendments in response the Examiner's report on 6 March 2014.  The filed amendments, which were considered to overcome the objections raised in the Examiner's adverse report, were advertised and subsequently allowed on 5 November 2014.  The allowance of the amendments concluded the re-examination process.

  4. A notice of opposition, statement of grounds and particulars and evidence in support were filed by Reflex Instruments Asia Pacific Pty Ltd (Reflex) on 29 March 2016.  A notification (the Notice Letter) was sent electronically by IP Australia to Lord & Company (Lord & Co), the patent attorneys of Minnovare, on 30 March 2016 confirming the filing of the notice of opposition, statement of grounds and particulars and evidence in support by Reflex.  Copies of all the above mentioned documents filed by Reflex on 29 March 2016 were attached to the Notice Letter.  The Notice Letter stated that evidence in answer was due by 30 June 2016.  The Notice Letter was accessed electronically by Lord & Co on 31 March 2016.  No evidence in answer was filed by Minnovare by 30 June 2016. 

  5. An officer from IP Australia contacted Lord & Co on 6 July 2016 to confirm that no evidence in answer had been filed.  On…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Reflex Instruments Asia Pacific Pty Ltd v Minnovare Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] APO 68
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The decision concerns an application for an extension of time to file evidence in answer to an opposition notice by Minnovare Limited, the patent applicant, against an opposition filed by Reflex Instruments Asia Pacific Pty Ltd. The opposition was in respect of an innovation patent for a drill hole orientation apparatus. The dispute was heard by Dr S.D. Barker, a delegate of the Commissioner for Patents. The central issue was whether exceptional circumstances existed to warrant an extension of time under regulation 5.9(2)(b) of the Patents Regulations, or if there was a basis to invoke regulation 5.23 to consider the evidence despite the late filing.

Dr Barker found that the failure to file evidence in answer was due to an administrative error by Minnovare's patent attorneys, Lord & Company. While acknowledging the error was unintentional, the court held that it did not amount to an exceptional circumstance as defined in the regulations. The failure was internal to the normal process of handling oppositions and not an external event beyond the control of the attorneys. Therefore, the error did not qualify as an exceptional circumstance warranting an extension of time. Dr Barker also noted that the arguments regarding the lack of prejudice to the opponent and public interest in resolving the dispute did not overcome the strict conditions for an extension under the amended regulations.

As a result, the Commissioner refused the application for an extension of time and did not consider the late filed evidence in answer. The Commissioner noted that a hearing of the opposition would not proceed until a decision on the potential invocation of regulation 5.23 was made. The Commissioner awarded costs to Reflex under Schedule 8 of the Patents Regulations.

Background

Background to the litigation

An innovation patent application numbered 2012101210, titled "Drill hole orientation apparatus," was filed by DHS (Aust) Pty Ltd on 8 August 2012, and subsequently granted on 6 September 2012. The patent ownership was later transferred to Minnovare Pty Ltd and then to Minnovare Limited (Minnovare). Following examination and certification on 11 September 2013, a re-examination request was filed by a third party on 15 November 2013. The patent underwent re-examination, resulting in an adverse report issued on 22 January 2014. Minnovare filed amendments to address the objections on 6 March 2014, which were allowed on 5 November 2014. On 29 March 2016, Reflex Instruments Asia Pacific Pty Ltd (Reflex) filed a notice of opposition, statement of grounds and particulars, and evidence in support against the patent. Minnovare's patent attorneys, Lord and Company, did not file evidence in answer by the deadline of 30 June 2016. On 7 July 2016, Lord and Company applied for an extension of time to file evidence in answer, which was refused by a delegate of the Commissioner. Minnovare sought a review of this decision, arguing that there were exceptional circumstances warranting an extension of time.

The matter before the court is a request for an extension of time to file evidence in answer to an opposition against an innovation patent. The application for the extension was filed by Minnovare's patent attorneys, Lord and Company, on 7 July 2016. The delegate of the Commissioner initially refused the application on 15 July 2016. Minnovare requested an oral hearing to challenge the decision, which was declined by the Commissioner. Written submissions were submitted by both parties on 10 and 12 August 2016, followed by further submissions on 19 August 2016. The decision on the application for extension of time was rendered on 11 October 2016.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether there were exceptional circumstances that warrant an extension of time to file evidence in answer under regulation 5.9(2)(b) of the Patents Regulations.
2. Whether the failure of Lord and Company's internal process constitutes an exceptional circumstance under regulation 5.9(2)(b) of the Patents Regulations.
3. Whether the failure to process the Notice Letter in the normal way within Lord and Company warrants an extension of time under regulation 5.9(2)(a) of the Patents Regulations.

Held
1. The court found that there were no exceptional circumstances that warrant an extension of time to file evidence in answer under regulation 5.9(2)(b) of the Patents Regulations.
2. The court held that the failure of Lord and Company's internal process does not constitute an exceptional circumstance under regulation 5.9(2)(b) of the Patents Regulations.
3. The court ruled that the failure to process the Notice Letter in the normal way within Lord and Company does not warrant an extension of time under regulation 5.9(2)(a) of the Patents Regulations.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court addressed the matter under regulation 5.9 of the Patents Regulations, which governs extensions of time to file evidence in patent oppositions. The decision was influenced by the principles established in TRED Design Pty Ltd v Julie-Anne McCarthy and Bradley McCarthy and Merial Limited v Novartis AG, which emphasize the importance of reasonable efforts to comply with filing requirements and the narrow conditions under which extensions may be granted. The Commissioner's discretion to grant an extension is further limited by the recent amendments aimed at reducing protracted proceedings. In this case, the Commissioner was not satisfied that the exceptional circumstances warranting an extension were present, as the failure to file evidence in answer was due to an internal administrative error by Lord and Company, which did not fall outside the normal evidentiary process. The Commissioner concluded that the error, while unintentional, did not qualify as an exceptional circumstance under the regulations, and thus, the application for an extension of time was refused. Additionally, the Commissioner found insufficient evidence to determine whether the failure to file evidence in answer was despite acting promptly and diligently, which is required under regulation 5.9(2)(a). The court's decision reflects a strict application of the regulatory framework designed to expedite the resolution of patent oppositions.