Reed v National Contracting Services Pty Ltd (formerly Quarry Transport Solutions)

Link copied
Case Copied 47 min read
CERTIFICATE OF DETERMINATION OF MEMBER 

CITATION:

Reed v National Contracting Services Pty Ltd (formerly Quarry Transport Solutions) [2022] NSWPIC 18

APPLICANT: Jason Bryant Reed
RESPONDENT: National Contracting Services Pty Ltd (formerly Quarry Transport Solutions)
MEMBER: John Wynyard
DATE OF DECISION: 14 January 2022
CATCHWORDS:

WORKERS COMPENSATION - Claim for cost of L5/S1 fusion; whether onus of proof met; whether concurrent treatment for psychiatric illness relevant to consequential condition to low back caused by fracture of the right leg; whether treatment proposed actually or potentially effective; whether proposed treatment appropriate; whether other treatment available; Held- evidence insufficient on a number of grounds; GP management of applicant revealed substantial and constant treatment by psychologists, and a Consultant Psychiatrist; no evidence as to effect of applicant’s psychological state whether suitable candidate for surgery; evidence unsatisfactory as to the cost of the proposed treatment; observations on purpose of section 60(5); award respondent.

DETERMINATIONS MADE:

1.     There is an award in favour of the respondent.

STATEMENT OF REASONS

BACKGROUND

  1. Jason Bryant Reed, the applicant brings an action against National Contracting Services Pty Ltd (formerly Quarry Transport Solutions), the respondent, for a declaration that the proposed surgery for a L5/S1 anterior lumbar fusion, anaesthetist fees and post-surgery medication is reasonably necessary.

  2. Dispute notices were issued and the Application to Resolve a Dispute (ARD) and Reply were duly lodged.

ISSUES FOR DETERMINATION

  1. The parties agree that the following issue remains in dispute:

(a)    is the proposed surgery reasonably necessary?

PROCEDURE BEFORE THE COMMISSION

  1. The matter was heard in teleconference arbitration hearing on 8 November 2021.  The applicant was represented by Mr Ross Stanton of counsel instructed by Ms Medea Hanna from Messrs PK Simpson & Co. The respondent was represented by Mr Ross Hanrahan of counsel instructed by Ms Phoebe Singer from Messrs Gair Legal. I am satisfied that the parties to the dispute understand the nature of the application and the legal implications of any assertion made in the information supplied.  I have used my best endeavours in attempting to bring the parties to the dispute to a settlement acceptable to all of them.  I am satisfied that the parties have had sufficient opportunity to explore settlement and that they have been unable to reach an agreed resolution of the dispute. 

EVIDENCE

Documentary Evidence

  1. The following documents were in evidence before the Commission and considered in making this determination:

(a)    ARD and attached documents;

(b)    Reply and attached documents;

(c)    document entitled GIO G168886K157 Jason Reed Estimate Cost of Surgery 11 November 2020, (the Cost of Surgery document), and

(d)    Application to Admit Late Documents (ALD) and attached documents from the respondent.

Oral Evidence

  1. Mr Hanrahan made an application to cross-examine Mr Reed which was refused for the reasons appearing on the transcript.

FINDINGS AND REASONS

Preliminary matters

  1. Mr Stanton objected to the inclusion of one of Dr Courtenay’s reports dated 2 November 2021 (there were three of that date) as Dr Courtenay discussed the question of injury, which Mr Stanton assumed had been admitted. Mr…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Reed v National Contracting Services Pty Ltd (formerly Quarr... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] NSWPIC 18
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicant in this workers' compensation matter sought to recover the cost of L5/S1 fusion surgery, amongst other expenses. The respondent, National Contracting Services Pty Ltd, contested the claim. The dispute was adjudicated in the New South Wales Supreme Court. The central issues revolved around whether the applicant had met the onus of proof to establish the necessity and cost of the proposed surgery, particularly in the context of concurrent treatment for psychiatric illness, which was argued to be relevant to the consequential condition of the applicant's low back injury stemming from a fracture of the right leg. The court also needed to determine whether the proposed treatment was actually or potentially effective, appropriate, and if alternative treatments were available.

The court found that the applicant's evidence was deficient in several respects. Firstly, there was no evidence that assessed whether the applicant was a suitable candidate for the proposed surgery given their psychological state. Secondly, the applicant's management by a general practitioner included extensive psychological treatment, yet there was no evidence detailing the effect of these treatments on the applicant's condition or its impact on the proposed surgical treatment. Additionally, the evidence regarding the cost of the proposed treatment was unsatisfactory, failing to meet the necessary standards of clarity and substantiation. The court observed that the purpose of the relevant section was to ensure that claims for compensation were adequately supported by evidence, a criterion which the applicant's case did not meet.

Given the insufficient evidence, the court dismissed the applicant's claim. The court highlighted that the evidence did not adequately support the need for the surgery, the suitability of the applicant for the procedure, or the appropriateness and cost of the proposed treatment. Consequently, the respondent was awarded the costs of the proceeding.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves a claim by the applicant, Mr. Reed, for the costs associated with an L5/S1 fusion surgery. Mr. Reed was injured while working for National Contracting Services Pty Ltd, formerly known as Quarry Transport Solutions. The injury resulted from a fall off a mobile elevating work platform, which led to a fracture of his right leg. Following the injury, Mr. Reed underwent multiple surgeries for his right leg. He also sought treatment for psychiatric conditions, which he claimed were consequential to the injury. The treatment for his psychiatric issues included substantial and constant management by psychologists and consultations with a Consultant Psychiatrist. Mr. Reed applied for the costs of an L5/S1 fusion surgery, which he argued was necessary due to the injury. The application was contested by the respondent, National Contracting Services Pty Ltd, which raised issues about the adequacy of the evidence provided by Mr. Reed regarding the need for the surgery and the effectiveness of the proposed treatment.

The matter came before the court as an application for workers' compensation costs related to a proposed medical treatment. Mr. Reed had previously lodged an application for workers' compensation, and this application for treatment costs was a part of that ongoing proceedings. The court reviewed the evidence and arguments presented by both parties regarding the necessity and appropriateness of the proposed L5/S1 fusion surgery. The respondent contested the application on the basis that the evidence provided by Mr. Reed was insufficient to support the claim for treatment costs. The court considered the submissions and evidence from both sides and issued a decision on the application.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the onus of proof was met by the applicant to establish the necessity for the proposed L5/S1 fusion surgery.
2. Whether the concurrent treatment for psychiatric illness, which the applicant received, is relevant to the consequential condition to the low back caused by the fracture of the right leg.
3. Whether the proposed treatment for the L5/S1 fusion is actually or potentially effective.
4. Whether the proposed treatment for the L5/S1 fusion is appropriate.
5. Whether there is other treatment available for the condition that could be considered instead of the proposed surgery.

Held
1. The court concluded that the onus of proof was not met by the applicant to establish the necessity for the proposed L5/S1 fusion surgery.
2. The concurrent treatment for psychiatric illness was not deemed relevant to the consequential condition to the low back caused by the fracture of the right leg.
3. The proposed treatment for the L5/S1 fusion was not established as actually or potentially effective.
4. The proposed treatment for the L5/S1 fusion was not found to be appropriate.
5. The court did not find sufficient evidence to determine whether there is other treatment available for the condition that could be considered instead of the proposed surgery.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the evidence provided by the applicant regarding the necessity for the proposed L5/S1 fusion surgery. It was determined that the onus of proof was not met, primarily due to the lack of evidence connecting the applicant's psychological state to the suitability for surgery. The court also highlighted the substantial and constant treatment by psychologists and a Consultant Psychiatrist as revealed by the GP's management of the applicant. Furthermore, the court found the evidence unsatisfactory concerning the cost of the proposed treatment. The court made observations on the purpose of section 60(5) and concluded that the award should respond to the respondent. The ratio decidendi established by this decision is that for a successful claim under workers' compensation, the applicant must meet the onus of proof concerning the necessity and appropriateness of the proposed treatment, including the relevance of concurrent treatments to the consequential condition.