Red Hill Wine Pty Ltd v Red Hill Vineyard Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 23 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Red Hill Wine Pty Ltd v Red Hill Vineyard Pty Ltd [2023] FCA 1151  

File number(s): VID 193 of 2021
Judgment of: ROFE J
Date of judgment: 26 September 2023
Catchwords: COSTS – where party failed to file notice of objection within 21 day time period after estimate issued by Registrar – where party seeks to have the time extended and file notice of objection to estimate of costs – whether reason for delay and merits of the notice of objection sufficient to allow orders sought ­– application dismissed   
Legislation:

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth)

Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth)

Legal Profession Uniform Law Application Act 2014 (NSW)

Legal Profession Uniform Law Australian Solicitors’ Conduct Rules 2015

Cases cited:

Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) v ActiveSuper Pty Ltd (No 4) [2013] FCA 318

Calder v Commissioner of Taxation [2006] FCA 1299

Dahler v Australian Capital Territory [2016] FCA 257

Polis v Zombor (No 5) [2022] FCA 122

Hunter Valley Developments Pty Limited v Cohen (1984) 3 FCR 344

Division: General Division
Registry: Victoria
National Practice Area: Intellectual Property
Sub-area: Trade Marks
Number of paragraphs: 70
Date of hearing: Determined on the papers
Date of last submission/s: 8 June 2023
Solicitor for the Applicants/Cross-Respondents: Kekatos Lawyers
Counsel for the Applicants/Cross-Respondents: Mr D Allen
Solicitor for the Respondents/Cross-Claimants: mdp Law
Counsel for the Respondents/Cross-Claimants: Ms M Marcus

ORDERS

VID 193 of 2021
BETWEEN:

RED HILL WINE PTY LTD (ACN 613 025 237)

First Applicant

CHEVIOT WINE GROUP PTY LTD (ACN 160 123 151)

Second Applicant

AND:

RED HILL VINEYARD PTY LTD (ACN 115 507 648)

First Respondent

R H WINE GROUP PTY LTD (ACN 115 409 509)

Second Respondent

AND BETWEEN:

R H WINE GROUP PTY LTD (ACN 115 409 509)

Cross-Claimant

AND:

RED HILL WINE PTY LTD (ACN 613 025 237) (and another named in the Schedule)

First Cross-Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

ROFE J

DATE OF ORDER:

26 SEPTEMBER 2023

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The Amended Interlocutory Application dated 1 June 2023 be dismissed.

2.The Cross-Respondents pay the Cross-Claimant’s costs of the application.

Note:   Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.


REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

ROFE J:

  1. This matter has come before me as the docket judge in circumstances where the substantive matter has settled, well prior to trial or any evidence being filed or served. The only remaining issue in dispute is the quantum of the Cross-Claimant’s costs of the cross-claim to be paid by the Cross-Respondents.

    BACKGROUND

  2. On 29 July 2022, I made orders by consent that the Cross-Respondents jointly and severally pay the Cross-Claimant’s costs of, and incidental to, the cross-claim as agreed or taxed. On that day, I also made orders that each party to the Further Amended Statement of Claim bear their own costs of, and incidental to, the Further Amended Statement of Claim.

  3. No agreement as to the Cross-Claimant’s costs of the cross-claim was reached and on 25 October 2022,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Red Hill Wine Pty Ltd v Red Hill Vineyard Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] FCA 1151
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia, Red Hill Wine Pty Ltd sought to extend the time for filing a notice of objection to the estimate of costs issued by the Registrar and to set aside the Certificate of Taxation issued by Edwards JR. The Cross-Claimant, RHWG, filed a Form 127: Bill of Costs – Long Form, and a copy of the stamped Bill of Costs was served on the solicitors for the Cross-Respondents by email on 28 October 2022. On 9 January 2023, Edwards JR issued a notice of estimate for the Bill of Costs (the Estimate), giving the Cross-Respondents, Red Hill, 21 days to file any notice of objection to the Estimate. No such notice was filed. On 9 February 2023, a Certificate of Taxation (the Certificate) was issued by Edwards JR in the amount of $260,025. Red Hill filed an interlocutory application dated 22 February 2023 seeking to have the Certificate set aside and the time for filing a notice of objection extended. The application was eventually re-filed on 5 June 2023. The amended interlocutory application seeks orders that: (1) the Certificate be set aside; (2) the time for filing a notice of objection pursuant to r 40.25 of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) be extended to seven days after these orders are made; (3) the time for filing a notice of objection to the Estimate, and payment of $2,000 into the Litigant’s fund as security pursuant to r 40.21 of the Rules, be extended to seven days after these orders are made; and (4) no order as to costs.

The Court considered the length and lack of acceptable explanation for the delay, the prejudice to RHWG, and the doubtful merit of Red Hill’s Notice of Objection. The Court noted that the parties had settled the substantive proceeding but the overarching purpose of s 37M and s 37N of the Act — to resolve disputes “as quickly, inexpensively and efficiently as possible” — seemed to have gone missing in the costs process. The Court also noted that RHWG had made two reasonable offers to settle the costs issue, both of which turned out to be less than the Estimate. The Court found that the circumstances in this case were by no means “exceptional” — rather, Red Hill simply failed, for unexceptional reasons relating to its legal representatives own carelessness, to file a notice of objection in time. The interlocutory application was therefore dismissed. Red Hill should bear the costs of this application.

The Court made orders dismissing the Amended Interlocutory Application dated 1 June 2023 and that the Cross-Respondents pay the Cross-Claimant’s costs of the application.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The Amended Interlocutory Application dated 1 June 2023 be dismissed.

2. The Cross-Respondents pay the Cross-Claimant’s costs of the application.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

This matter has come before me as the docket judge in circumstances where the substantive matter has settled, well prior to trial or any evidence being filed or served. The only remaining issue in dispute is the quantum of the Cross-Claimant’s costs of the cross-claim to be paid by the Cross-Respondents.BACKGROUND On 29 July 2022, I made orders by consent that the Cross-Respondents jointly and severally pay the Cross-Claimant’s costs of, and incidental to, the cross-claim as agreed or taxed. On that day, I also made orders that each party to the Further Amended Statement of Claim bear their own costs of, and incidental to, the Further Amended Statement of Claim. No agreement as to the Cross-Claimant’s costs of the cross-claim was reached and on 25 October 2022, the Cross-Claimant, R H Wine Group Pty Ltd (RHWG), filed a Form 127: Bill of Costs – Long Form. A copy of the stamped Bill of Costs was served on the solicitors for the Cross-Respondents by email on 28 October 2022. On 9 January 2023, Edwards JR issued a notice of estimate for the Bill of Costs (the Estimate), giving the Cross-Respondents, Red Hill Wine Pty Ltd and Cheviot Wine Group Pty Ltd (together, Red Hill), 21 days to file any notice of objection to the Estimate. No such notice was filed. On 9 February 2023, a Certificate of Taxation (the Certificate) was issued by Edwards JR in the amount of $260,025. On 9 February 2023, the lawyers for RHWG forwarded the Certificate to Red Hill’s lawyers, together with their trust account details to enable payment, Red Hill filed an interlocutory application dated 22 February 2023 seeking to have the Certificate set aside and the time for filing a notice of objection extended. Due to difficulties experienced with the e-filing of the affidavit of Mr Kekatos in support of the interlocutory application, the application was not filed in its proper form until 28 February 2023, and was not stamped by the Registry until 15 March 2023. An unstamped copy of the interlocutory application was served on 7 March 2023 and a stamped copy of the application was served on 23 March 2023. No explanation has been provided by Red Hill for why it took over a week to serve the stamped copy of the application after Red Hill had received it from the Registry. The interlocutory application was, for reasons discussed below, incorrect and had to be re-filed in the proper form, which was eventually done on 5 June 2023. On 16 March 2023, RHWG served a Creditor’s Statutory Demand on the second Cross-Respondent, Cheviot Wine Group Pty Ltd. The statutory period for compliance with the Statutory Demand expired on 17 April 2023. On 12 May 2023, an originating process for winding up was filed by Rothwell Lawyers on behalf of RHWG. Red Hill sought to file an amended interlocutory application, the filing of which was not opposed by RHWG. The amended application is dated 1 June 2023 but was filed on 5 June 2023. The amended interlocutory application seeks orders that:(1)the Certificate be set aside;(2)the time for filing a notice of objection pursuant to r 40.25 of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) be extended to seven days after these orders are made;(3)the time for filing a notice of objection to the Estimate, and payment of $2,000 into the Litigant’s fund as security pursuant to r 40.21 of the Rules, be extended to seven days after these orders are made; and(4)no order as to costs.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Thus, even if there is some merit to Red Hill’s Notice of Objection, I am not convinced, on Red Hill’s own metric, that it is likely that Red Hill would succeed in having the costs reduced from $260,025 to $110,000, or anywhere near that figure. CONCLUSION The length and lack of acceptable explanation for the delay, the prejudice to RHWG and the doubtful merit of Red Hill’s Notice of Objection, weigh against granting an extension of time pursuant to r 1.39 of the Rules. Further, and in any event, I do not consider that it is appropriate to vary or set aside the Certificate pursuant to r 39.05. The parties have managed to settle the substantive proceeding but the overarching purpose of s 37M and s 37N of the Act — to resolve disputes “as quickly, inexpensively and efficiently as possible” — seems to have gone missing in the costs process. RHWG has sought to operate pursuant to s 37M by making two reasonable offers to settle the costs issue, both of which turned out to be less than the Estimate. The costs issue could have been finalised a year ago had those offers been accepted. Of course, Red Hill was entitled to reject those offers but the consequence, other than that it now faces an order of costs on an indemnity basis (see r 23.14), is a significant delay in resolving this issue. That did not have to be so, but Red Hill’s repeated failure to comply with deadlines and file the correct document has significantly and unnecessarily drawn out this proceeding. Granting Red Hill’s application would only lead to further costs and delays as it would likely end up in a taxation proceeding, for the reasons given above at [59]. Neither party would be winners in such a proceeding. If Red Hill fails to better the Estimate by 15% in the taxation hearing (which, for the reasons given above, is unlikely) they will pay RHWG’s costs of the taxation: r 40.33. Therefore, even if Red Hill succeeds in trimming a small percentage from RHWG’s costs, the costs of the taxation process is likely to far exceed that amount for Red Hill. As O’Bryan J stated in Polis v Zombor (No 5) [2022] FCA 122 at [43], “the discretion permitted to the Court by r 39.05 … should ordinarily be exercised only in exceptional circumstances, bearing in mind the overarching principle of the finality of litigation”. This dispute has gone on for too long and the parties, particularly RHWG, should not be subjected to further costs and delays. That is particularly so where the total costs incurred by both parties in the costs process, including this application, may well exceed the amount ultimately in dispute. Further, the circumstances in this case are by no means “exceptional” — rather, Red Hill simply failed, for unexceptional reasons relating to its legal representatives own carelessness, to file a notice of objection in time. The interlocutory application is therefore dismissed. Red Hill should bear the costs of this application. I will make orders accordingly.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Ultimately, Mr Dudman’s opinion is that it is “extremely unlikely” that the Estimate would be varied by almost 90% and, as Red Hill are only challenging the professional fees not the disbursements, the maximum variation would be 10%. CONSIDERATIONLength and explanation of the delay In my view, there are two relevant delays in this matter: 1) filing the Notice of Objection after receiving the Estimate on 9 January 2023; and 2) not filing the correct form pursuant to r 40.21 (Form 128) until 5 June 2023. Both delays are not insignificant. The explanation for the first delay is unsatisfactory and there is no explanation for the second delay. Red Hill’s explanation for the first delay boils down to assigning blame to the Graduate. This is an entirely inappropriate response. It is unclear from the material whether the Graduate was, at the relevant time, admitted to practice. Nevertheless, at most, the Graduate is likely engaged in supervised legal practice within the meaning of Sch 1 of the Legal Profession Uniform Law Application Act 2014 (NSW) and therefore a condition of his practicing certificate is that he cannot practice without supervision. Mr Kekatos, on the other hand, is the principal of his firm and has been admitted to practice for over 29 years. Rule 37.1 of the Legal Profession Uniform Law Australian Solicitors’ Conduct Rules 2015 provides that “[a] solicitor with designated responsibility for a matter must exercise reasonable supervision over solicitors and all other employees engaged in the provision of the legal services for that matter”. As set out in his affidavit dated 2 June 2023, Mr Kekatos is the solicitor on record for Red Hill and had carriage of this matter. It was therefore Mr Kekatos’ responsibility to exercise reasonable supervision over the Graduate and it was ultimately his responsibility, not the Graduate’s, as to whether the Notice of Objection was filed on time. Mr Kekatos asked the Graduate to file the Notice on 16 January 2023, but made no further inquiries with the Graduate as to whether the Notice had, in fact, been filed by the prescribed time (31 January 2023). This was both careless as a legal practitioner, and unreasonable as a supervisor. In these circumstances, I do not consider that there is any acceptable explanation for the first delay. I accept that Red Hill did seek RHWG’s consent to set aside the Certificate very shortly after receiving it from Edwards JR on 9 February 2023 and realising their error. After consent was refused, Red Hill filed the initial interlocutory application in a timely manner on 22 February 2023. However, the application filed on 22 February 2023 sought to set aside the Certificate under r 40.25, which was incorrect. As explained above, r 40.25 relates to the issuing of a notice of objection when a bill has reached the taxation stage. It was not until 5 June 2023 that Red Hill filed an amended interlocutory application seeking orders under the correct rule, r 40.21, along with the required Form 128. This was four months after the period in which an objection could have been filed had elapsed. Red Hill has provided absolutely no explanation for this second delay.