Rectangular Pty Ltd v Mae Cardaci ATF the Marco Cardaci Testamentary Trust

Link copied
Case Copied 87 min read

JURISDICTION     :   SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

IN CHAMBERS

CITATION:   RECTANGULAR PTY LTD -v- MAE CARDACI ATF THE MARCO CARDACI TESTAMENTARY TRUST [2023] WASC 13

CORAM:   LUNDBERG J

HEARD:   25 JANUARY 2023

DELIVERED          :   27 JANUARY 2023

FILE NO:   COR 2 of 2023

BETWEEN:   RECTANGULAR PTY LTD

Plaintiff

AND

MAE CARDACI ATF THE MARCO CARDACI TESTAMENTARY TRUST

Defendant

FILE NO:   COR 3 of 2023

BETWEEN:   WASHBURN PTY LTD

Plaintiff

AND

MAE CARDACI ATF THE WASHBURN TRUST

Defendant


Catchwords:

Applications to set aside statutory demands – Judgment debts obtained after hearing on the merits – Pending appeals to the Court of Appeal – Stay of primary judgment refused by the Court of Appeal – Judgment debtors are former trustee companies without assets – Whether 'some other reason' for setting aside the statutory demands

Legislation:

Civil Judgments Enforcement Act 2004 (WA), s 15
Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), s 459G, s 459H, s 459J

Result:

Applications dismissed

Category:    B

Representation:

COR 2 of 2023

Counsel:

Plaintiff : M L Bennett
Defendant : E M Heenan SC

Solicitors:

Plaintiff : Bennett
Defendant : Herbert Smith Freehills

COR 3 of 2023

Counsel:

Plaintiff : M L Bennett
Defendant : E M Heenan SC

Solicitors:

Plaintiff : Bennett
Defendant : Herbert Smith Freehills

Cases referred to in decision:

Barclays Australia (Finance) Ltd v Mike Gaffikin Marine Pty Ltd (1996) 21 ACSR 235

Body Corporate Repairers Pty Ltd v Oakley Thompson & Co Pty Ltd [2017] VSC 435

Cardaci v Filippo Primo Cardaci as executor and trustee of Marco Antonio Cardaci [No 3] [2022] WASC 412

Cardaci v Filippo Primo Cardaci as executor and trustee of Marco Antonio Cardaci [No 4] [2022] WASC 453

Cardaci v Filippo Primo Cardaci as executor of the estate of Marco Antonio Cardaci [No 5] [2021] WASC 331

Cardaci v Filippo Primo Cardaci as executor of the estate of Marco Antonio Cardaci [No 5] [2021] WASC 331 (S)

Cranney Farm Pty Ltd v Corowa Fertilizers Pty Ltd [2011] NSWSC 9

Deputy Commissioner of Taxation v Broadbeach Properties Pty Ltd [2008] HCA 41; (2008) 237 CLR 473

Eumina Investments Pty Ltd v Westpac Banking Corporation [1998] FCA 824; (1998) 84 FCR 454

Food Channel Network Pty Ltd v Television Food Network, GP [2010] FCA 403

Meehan v Glazier Holdings Pty Limited [2005] NSWCA 24; (2005) 53 ACSR 229

Mibor Investments Pty Ltd v Commonwealth Bank of Australia [1994] VicRp 61; (1993) 11 ACLC 1062; (1993) 11 ACSR 362

Midas v Equator [2007] NSWSC 759

Norilya Minerals Pty Ltd v Ireland [2008] WASC 53

Ozy Homewares v Wesgordon [2007] NSWSC 982

Professional Services of Australia Pty Ltd v Lean [2018] WASC 28

Quadwest Developments Pty Ltd v THI [2009] WASC 54

Quarter Enterprises Pty Ltd v Allardyce Lumber Company Ltd [2011] NSWSC 1031

Re A.C.E.S. Sogutlu Holdings Pty Ltd [2014] NSWSC 140

Re JKAM Investments Pty Ltd [2015] NSWSC 2032

Re John Farlow Pty Ltd [2015] NSWSC 939

Re Mio Amico Pty Limited [2013] NSWSC 1292

Remote Camps Australia…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Rectangular Pty Ltd v Mae Cardaci ATF the Marco Cardaci Test... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] WASC 13
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Rectangular Pty Ltd v Mae Cardaci ATF the Marco Cardaci Testamentary Trust, the Federal Court of Australia was tasked with determining whether to set aside statutory demands served on the judgment debtors. The primary issue was whether there was a genuine dispute as to the existence or amount of the debt claimed, which is a requisite for setting aside a statutory demand under section 459H of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth). Additionally, the court had to consider whether there were any other reasons for setting aside the statutory demands, given that the judgment debtors were former trustee companies without assets and had pending appeals to the Court of Appeal, which had previously refused to stay the primary judgment.

The court examined the ratio of Eumina Investments Pty Ltd v Westpac Banking Corporation, where Emmett J had concluded that a determination by a superior court that a company had no claim against a creditor was conclusive and precluded the company from contending otherwise, even if an appeal for special leave to the High Court was pending. The court found that the judgment debtors had no genuine claim against the creditor as it had been conclusively determined by the Court of Appeal. The court also considered whether the pending appeal for special leave could be considered a genuine claim for the purposes of setting aside the statutory demand, but ultimately concluded that such a claim would not avail the judgment debtors.

The Federal Court held that the statutory demands could not be set aside as there was no genuine dispute as to the existence or amount of the debt, and there were no other reasons to do so. The court found that the determination by the Court of Appeal that the judgment debtors had no claim against the creditor was conclusive, and the pending appeal for special leave did not constitute a genuine claim that would justify setting aside the statutory demands.

The final orders of the court were that the applications to set aside the statutory demands were dismissed, and the judgment debtors were required to pay the creditor's costs of the application.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In Eumina Investments Pty Ltd v Westpac Banking Corporation [1998] FCA 824; (1998) 84 FCR 454, Emmett J heard an application by a company to set aside a statutory demand served by the respondent bank. The demand sought payment of an amount which was the subject of a costs order made by the Federal Court. The costs order was not appealed and was not the subject of any stay application. The company maintained that it had a genuine claim against the respondent bank which far exceeded the costs order debt. That claim was dismissed in the Federal Court, and then reasserted (and dismissed) in the Supreme Court of New South Wales. An appeal to the Court of Appeal of New South Wales was then dismissed. At the time Emmett J heard the matter, an application for special leave to the High Court of Australia was pending.[16] Nonetheless, at the time the application to set aside the statutory demand was heard, there had been a determination that the company had no claim against the respondent bank, as Emmett J noted (at 458). [16] The application for special leave was ultimately refused by the High Court: Eumina Investments Pty Ltd v Westpac Banking Corporation [1998] HCATrans 363 (Gleeson CJ and Gummow J). The court was of the view that the decisions appealed against turned largely upon findings of fact and the matter was not attended with sufficient prospects of achieving a different outcome to the litigation if special leave were to be granted. Emmett J rejected the company's contention that there was a genuine dispute as to the debt, for the purposes of s 459H(1) of the Act. His Honour concluded that the effect of the determination of the Court of Appeal in dismissing the appeal from the decision of the trial judge (which dismissed the company's claim against the respondent bank) was that, as at the date of service of the statutory demand, as at the date of commencement of the proceedings before his Honour, and as the date the matter was heard by his Honour, it had been determined that the company had no claim against the respondent bank. It was thus not open to the company to contend to the contrary, having regard to the doctrine of res judicata. A superior court had conclusively determined that the company had no claim. Emmett J was of the view that the only bona fide claim which the company had against the respondent bank was its claim for special leave to appeal from the decision of the Court of Appeal. His Honour was prepared to assume that the application for special leave had reasonable prospects of success and that the company had reasonable prospects of succeeding on appeal if leave were granted. Emmett J held that that assumption would not avail the company, however. It would only establish that the claim for special leave might be characterised as a genuine claim. The determination of the trial judge conclusively determined, as between the company and the respondent bank, that there was no money recoverable by the company from the respondent bank arising out of the subject matter of the proceedings.