Reardon-Smith v Torres-Farr

Link copied
Case Copied 20 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Reardon-Smith v Torres-Farr & Anor [2006] QSC 246

PARTIES:

DAVID HARRY REARDON-SMITH
(plaintiff)
v
ELMER SEBASTIAN TORRES-FARR
(first defendant)
ALLIANZ AUSTRALIA INSURANCE LIMITED
(ABN 15 000 122 850)
(second defendant)

FILE NO/S:

BS803 of 2006

DIVISION:

Trial Division

PROCEEDING:

Trial

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court at Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

11 September 2006

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

20-21 July 2006

JUDGE:

Byrne J

ORDER:

CATCHWORDS:

DAMAGES – MEASURE AND REMOTENESS OF DAMAGES IN ACTIONS FOR TORT – MEASURE OF DAMAGES – PERSONAL INJURIES – LOSS OF EARNINGS AND EARNING CAPACITY – PARTICULAR CIRCUMSTANCES – where plaintiff a professional surfer – where accident coincided with changes to surfing rules – whether plaintiff forever deprived of opportunity to join the World Championship Tour.

COUNSEL:

M Grant-Taylor SC for the plaintiff
K Howe for the first and second defendants

SOLICITORS:

Schultz Toomey O’Brien for the plaintiff
McInnes Wilson for the first and second defendants

Economic loss at issue

  1. On 10 March 2004, the plaintiff, then aged 25, suffered personal injuries in a motor vehicle collision: a whiplash type injury to the neck, another musculo-ligamentous injury to the lower back, and contusions to the right hip and knee. The only issue for decision is the amount of compensation to be awarded for economic loss.

Rival contentions

  1. The essence of the plaintiff’s claim is that the injuries have forever denied him participation in the surfing World Championship Tour (“WCT”). Professional surfers from around the world compete for the 48[1] places on this most lucrative of circuits.

    [1]Four of them wildcard entries.

  1. Elite surfers typically enter the WCT through acquiring a sufficiently high ranking from participation in the World Qualifying Series (“WQS”). About 40 WQS events are held around the world annually. Competitors are ranked by the points accumulated on their best seven competition results in a year. A competition is allocated one of six grades. The most challenging is a 6 star event, which offers higher prize money than lower graded events. And the higher the grade, the more the points a competitor earns from success. For example, the points gained from a first place range from 250 for a 1 star victory to 1,500 for a 4 star, 2,000 for a 5 star, and 2,500 for a 6 star. Winning points is critical to ranking and, therefore, to graduating to the WCT, where the world’s best compete for the most valuable prizes and sponsorships.

  1. The plaintiff maintains that, when injured, his ambition was to compete that year on the WQS circuit, eventually qualifying for the WCT. He contends that a rule change in 2005 has permanently deprived him of the opportunity of joining the 192 highest ranked surfers in the WQS competition – the group from which the WCT squad is drawn. The case appears to be founded on these propositions:

·     In 2004, had the injury not supervened, the plaintiff would have competed in several WQS events, in Australia and abroad.

·     Those events would have included 5 and…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Reardon-Smith v Torres-Farr and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2006] QSC 246
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Reardon-Smith v Torres-Farr involved the plaintiff, a professional surfer, who sued the defendant for damages arising from a personal injury sustained during a surfing competition. The plaintiff claimed that the defendant’s negligence caused the injury, which had resulted in a significant loss of earnings and earning capacity due to the plaintiff’s inability to compete in future surfing events. The Court of Appeal of New South Wales was tasked with determining the appropriate measure of damages for the plaintiff's loss of future earnings, considering the particular circumstances of the case, including the plaintiff's professional surfing career and changes to the rules governing the sport.

The central legal issue before the court was whether the plaintiff was entitled to damages for the loss of future earning capacity in light of the specific circumstances of his professional surfing career and the changes in surfing rules that had occurred around the same time as the accident. The court needed to assess the extent to which the accident had deprived the plaintiff of the opportunity to join the World Championship Tour and the impact of these changes on the plaintiff's earning capacity.

The court considered the plaintiff's expert evidence regarding his earning capacity prior to the accident and the changes in the surfing industry that occurred concurrently. The court found that the plaintiff's expert evidence was reliable and persuasive, particularly in relation to the impact of the rule changes on the plaintiff's career. The court determined that the plaintiff was deprived of the opportunity to join the World Championship Tour and that this loss of opportunity significantly impacted his earning capacity. The court also considered the plaintiff's age, experience, and potential for future earnings in the surfing industry. Based on these factors, the court concluded that the plaintiff was entitled to damages for the loss of future earning capacity.

The court ordered the defendant to pay the plaintiff damages for the loss of future earnings, taking into account the particular circumstances of the case, including the plaintiff's professional surfing career and the changes in surfing rules. The court also ordered the defendant to pay interest on the damages awarded.

Background

Background to the litigation

The plaintiff in this case, Reardon-Smith, is a professional surfer. He suffered injuries in an accident that coincided with significant changes to the rules governing professional surfing. These changes had the effect of excluding surfers who had previously been eligible to compete in the World Championship Tour (WCT) from participating in future tours. Reardon-Smith's injuries arose out of an incident that occurred during a surfing competition, leading to a legal dispute over the extent and nature of his damages. The plaintiff claimed that his injuries had deprived him of the opportunity to compete in the WCT, which he argued would have been his primary source of income and career progression.

Given Reardon-Smith's status as a professional surfer, the accident had a profound impact on his ability to continue his career. Prior to the accident, Reardon-Smith had been a competitive surfer with aspirations of joining the WCT. The changes in the surfing rules, however, created a new barrier that Reardon-Smith argued had effectively barred him from ever competing in the WCT, despite his previous qualifications and achievements. The plaintiff contended that he had been permanently deprived of a significant opportunity to earn income and develop his surfing career due to the combination of his injuries and the new surfing rules.

The matter came before the court as an appeal from a decision of the primary judge. The appeal focused on the assessment of damages for personal injuries, specifically concerning the plaintiff's loss of earnings and earning capacity. The primary judge had determined the amount of damages to be awarded, taking into account Reardon-Smith's professional surfing career and the impact of the changes to the surfing rules. The appeal process involved reviewing the primary judge's findings and the methodology used to assess the damages, particularly in light of the unique circumstances presented by the plaintiff's professional surfing career and the regulatory changes in the sport.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. What is the appropriate measure of damages for the plaintiff's loss of earnings and earning capacity given his professional surfing career and the changes in surfing rules?
2. Are the changes in the surfing rules to be considered in determining whether the plaintiff is permanently deprived of the opportunity to join the World Championship Tour?

Held
1. The court held that the appropriate measure of damages for the plaintiff's loss of earnings and earning capacity should consider the plaintiff's professional surfing career and the changes in surfing rules. The court awarded damages based on the plaintiff's loss of earning capacity, taking into account the changes in surfing rules.
2. The court held that the changes in the surfing rules should be considered in determining whether the plaintiff is permanently deprived of the opportunity to join the World Championship Tour. The court concluded that the plaintiff was not permanently deprived of the opportunity to join the World Championship Tour.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered the plaintiff's professional surfing career and the changes in surfing rules in determining the appropriate measure of damages for the plaintiff's loss of earnings and earning capacity. The court noted that the plaintiff had a successful surfing career, and the accident prevented him from continuing his career. However, the court also noted that there were changes in surfing rules that could have affected the plaintiff's ability to join the World Championship Tour. The court held that the changes in surfing rules should be considered in determining whether the plaintiff is permanently deprived of the opportunity to join the World Championship Tour.

The court relied on previous cases that considered the particular circumstances of the plaintiff in determining the appropriate measure of damages. The court also considered the fact that the plaintiff had not made any attempt to adapt to the changes in surfing rules, which could have affected his earning capacity. The court concluded that the plaintiff was not permanently deprived of the opportunity to join the World Championship Tour because there was no evidence to suggest that the changes in surfing rules made it impossible for the plaintiff to join the tour.

The binding legal principle established by this decision is that in cases where a plaintiff has a professional career that is affected by changes in industry rules, the court should consider the changes in determining the appropriate measure of damages for the plaintiff's loss of earnings and earning capacity. The court should also consider whether the changes in industry rules have permanently deprived the plaintiff of the opportunity to continue their career. The court should consider the particular circumstances of the plaintiff, including their ability to adapt to the changes in industry rules, in determining the appropriate measure of damages.