Real Estate Home Loans Pty Ltd v REA Group Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 32 min read

TRADE MARKS ACT 1995
DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS



Re:Oppositions by Real Estate Home Loans Pty Ltd to registration of trade mark applications 1827083(36) - realestate.com.au Home Loans - and 1852809(36) - realestate.com.au Home Loans Logo - both in the name of REA Group Ltd.

Delegate: Debrett Lyons
Representation: Opponent: written submissions only.
Applicant: Natalie Hickey of counsel instructed by Corrs.
Decision:

2019 ATMO 129
Trade Marks Act 1995: s 52 oppositions: grounds of opposition under ss 41, 42(b), 44, 60 and 62A pressed in respect of 1827083 – s 41ground of opposition established – opposition successful and trade mark refused registration; grounds of opposition under ss 42(b), 44, 60 and 62A pressed in respect of 1852809 – no grounds of opposition established – opposition unsuccessful and trade mark to proceed to registration.

Background

  1. REA Group Ltd (‘Applicant’) is an ASX listed company which has maintained a portal style website resolving from the domain name <realestate.com.au> where real estate agents list and consumers view residential or commercial property.

  2. Real Estate Home Loans Pty Ltd (‘Opponent’) is a real estate mortgage broker based in Ballarat, Victoria.  The Opponent owns trade mark 828907 (‘Registration’) registered from 23 March 2000 in class 36 for “insurance; financial affairs; monetary affairs; real estate affairs” for the trade mark shown below:

    (‘Opponent’s Mark’)

  3. It is the Applicant’s attempt to register the trade marks detailed below which gave rise to these proceedings.  The trade marks had been examined, accepted, and published for possible registration in the Australian Official Journal of Trade Marks. The Opponent then brought oppositions under s 52 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (‘Act’), first filing Notices of Opposition, followed in each case by a Statement of Grounds and Particulars (‘SGP’).  In turn, the Applicant filed Notices of Intention to Defend (‘NID’). 

    Word Mark Application

Trade Mark: realestate.com.au Home Loans    (‘Word Mark’)
App. No: 1827083
Services: Class 36: Financial services; insurance services; loan services; provision of information and advice, including online, in relation to financial matters (‘Services’)
Priority Date: 21 February 2017
Acceptance Advertised: 13 July 2017
Initial SGP Filed: 4 October 2017
Amended SGP Filed: 19 February 2018
NID Filed: 13 November 2017
Grounds of Opposition:

41, 42(b), 44, 60, 62A

Logo Mark Application

Trade Mark:

(‘Logo Mark’)

App. No: 1852809
Services: As above
Priority Date: 19 June 2017
Acceptance Advertised: 16 November 2017
SGP Filed: 6 December 2017
NID Filed: 12 December 2017
Grounds of Opposition: 42(b), 44, 60, 62A
  1. Thereafter the parties filed evidence, detailed below, in accordance with the Trade Mark Regulations 1995 (‘Regulations’). 

  2. The Applicant asked to be heard in person and the hearing took place in Canberra on 1 April 2019 where the Applicant was represented by Natalie Hickey of counsel, instructed by Jurgen Bebber, a partner of Corrs, also in attendance.  The Opponent asked for…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Real Estate Home Loans Pty Ltd v REA Group Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] ATMO 129
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned oppositions filed by Real Estate Home Loans Pty Ltd (the Opponent) against two trade mark applications by REA Group Ltd (the Applicant). The dispute involved an application for a Word Mark (application 1827083) and a Logo Mark (application 1852809). The Opponent's grounds of opposition included a claim under section 41 of the *Trade Marks Act 1995* (Cth) concerning the Word Mark, and a claim of bad faith under section 62A of the Act in relation to the Logo Mark. The decision was made by Debrett Lyons, Hearings Officer, at the Trade Marks Hearings.

The Hearings Officer was required to determine whether the Applicant's trade mark applications were capable of distinguishing the Applicant's goods and services from those of other persons, as required by section 41 of the Act, and whether the Applicant had acted in bad faith in seeking to register the Logo Mark under section 62A of the Act. The assessment of section 41 involved considering whether the trade marks were inherently adapted to distinguish and whether they, in fact, distinguished the Applicant's goods or services through use. The bad faith assessment required an examination of the Applicant's conduct in adopting and seeking to register the Logo Mark.

In relation to the Word Mark and section 41, the Hearings Officer found that the Opponent had established a ground of opposition. The decision noted that neither party could claim a monopoly over the terms "real estate" or "home loans," either separately or in combination. Regarding the Logo Mark and the bad faith claim, the Hearings Officer was not satisfied that the Applicant's decision to adopt and seek registration of the Logo Mark was made to take advantage of the Opponent, but rather to use the phrases for their ordinary and natural meanings. Consequently, the Opponent failed to establish the ground of opposition under section 62A.

Ultimately, the Hearings Officer refused registration of the Word Mark (application 1827083) as a ground of opposition had been established. However, the Opponent did not establish a ground of opposition for the Logo Mark (application 1852809), which was permitted to proceed to registration, subject to any appeal. Given that each party was successful in one opposition and unsuccessful in the other, and the proceedings were based on essentially the same evidence, no award of costs was made.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The evidence in these proceedings consists of the following declarations:Evidence in Support·Paul Ballinger, Director of the Opponent (‘Ballinger 1’) made 19 February 2018 with Exhibits PB-1 to PB-40 (Exhibits PB-8, PB-9, PB-16 and PB-37 marked ‘Confidential’); and ·Nicholas Patrick Butera, solicitor employed by the Opponent’s representatives (‘Butera 1’) made 19 February 2018 with Exhibits NPB-1 to NPB-8.Evidence in Answer ·Scott Andrew Holmes, Innovation and Strategy Manager of the Applicant (‘Holmes’) made 18 June 2018 with Exhibits SAH-1 to SAH-29 (Exhibits SAH-21, SAH-25 and SAH-26 marked ‘Confidential’); ·Jurgen Bebber, a Partner at the Applicant’s representatives (‘Bebber’) made 18 June 2018 with Exhibits JB-1 to JB-10 (Exhibit JB-5, JB-7 and JB-8 marked ‘Confidential’)[1]; and·Eloise Wall, Executive Manager of Financial Experiences of the Applicant (‘Wall’) made 20 June 2018 with Exhibits EW-1 to EW-12 (Exhibit EW-5 marked ‘Confidential’). [1] Bebber exhibits copies of seven Affidavits filed by the Applicant in the Federal Court matter of REA Group Ltd v Real Estate 1 Ltd (2013) 217 FCR 327 where the Applicant’s trade mark, realestate.com.au, was in suit.Evidence in Reply·Paul Ballinger (‘Ballinger 2’) made 27 August 2018 with Exhibits PB-41 to PB-43;·Glenn Alan Sharp, Director of Sharp Accounting Pty Ltd made 27 August 2018 with Exhibits GAS-1 to GAS-2; and ·Nicholas Patrick Butera made 27 August 2018 with Exhibits NPB-9 to NPB-11. On 26 September 2018, the Applicant filed a letter with this Office in relation to the Opponent’s Evidence in Reply attaching a Declaration of Tim Guy dated 25 September 2018 which sought to address matters raised in the Evidence in Reply. A dispute arose before the hearing as to the admissibility of that declaration. My findings which follow are independent of the matters raised in the declaration and are dispositive of the oppositions. Nothing in this declaration alters the path of my findings and so it has not been necessary for me to determine admissibility of this declaration as a separate matter.Grounds of Opposition and Legislative Framework The SGP filed in relation to application 1827083 for the Word Mark nominated a ground of opposition under the Act based on s 41. That ground was not raised against the Logo Mark and for that and other reasons which will emerge from the consideration of the ground I have dealt with it first.The Word Mark and Section 41 Section 41 provides a scheme for the assessment of the capacity of a trade mark to distinguish the goods or services of one trader from the similar goods or services of another trader. So far as relevant, it provides that:41 Trade mark not distinguishing applicant’s goods or services (1) An application for the registration of a trade mark must be rejected if the trade mark is not capable of distinguishing the applicant’s goods or services in respect of which the trade mark is sought to be registered (the designated goods or services) from the goods or services of other persons. (2) A trade mark is taken not to be capable of distinguishing the designated goods or services from the goods or services of other persons only if either subsection (3) or (4) applies to the trade mark. (3) This subsection applies to a trade mark if: (a) the trade mark is not to any extent inherently adapted to distinguish the designated goods or services from the goods or services of other persons; and (b) the applicant has not used the trade mark before the filing date in respect of the application to such an extent that the trade mark does in fact distinguish the designated goods or services as being those of the applicant. (4) This subsection applies to a trade mark if: (a) the trade mark is, to some extent, but not sufficiently, inherently adapted to distinguish the designated goods or services from the goods or services of other persons; and (b) the trade mark does not and will not distinguish the designated goods or services as being those of the applicant having regard to the combined effect of the following: (i) the extent to which the trade mark is inherently adapted to distinguish the goods or services from the goods or services of other persons; (ii) the use, or intended use, of the trade mark by the applicant; (iii) any other circumstances.Note 1: Trade marks that are not inherently adapted to distinguish goods or services are mostly trade marks that consist wholly of a sign that is ordinarily used to indicate:(a) the kind, quality, quantity, intended purpose, value, geographical origin, or some other characteristic, of goods or services; or(b) the time of production of goods or of the rendering of services.

Decision

Reasons for decision

What I have already decided determines the issue of bad faith in this case. Even if the parties were squarely competitors in business in the same space for mortgage lending services, neither could exert a monopoly over “real estate” or “home loans”, either used separately or together. I cannot conclude that the decision of the Applicant to adopt and seek to register the Logo Mark, containing the phrases “real estate” or “home loans”, was a decision made to take advantage of the Opponent in some way, rather than a decision to use those phrases (as part of the Logo Mark) for their normal and natural meanings in respect of the Services. I am not satisfied that the Applicant’s conduct in filing the application for the Logo Mark was unscrupulous, underhanded or unconscientious in character. Consequently, I find that the Opponent has failed to establish the ground of opposition under s 62A.Decision Section 55 (1) of the Act provides:(1) Unless subsection (3) applies to the proceedings, the Registrar must, at the end, decide:(a) to refuse to register the trade mark; or(b) to register the trade mark (with or without conditions or limitations) in respect of the goods and/or services then specified in the application;having regard to the extent (if any) to which any ground on which the application was opposed has been established.Note: For limitations see section 6. The Opponent has established a ground of opposition under the Act with respect to trade mark application 1827083 and so registration is refused. The Opponent has not established a ground of opposition with respect to trade mark application 1852809 which may proceed to registration one month from the date of this decision. If the Registrar has been served with a notice of appeal before that time, I direct that registration shall not occur until either the appeal is withdrawn or a court so orders.Costs Both parties sought their costs in respect of each opposition. Each party has been successful in one opposition and unsuccessful in the other. The matters proceeded on essentially the same evidence and so in these cases I make no award of costs.Debrett LyonsHearings OfficerTrade Marks Hearings28 August 2019

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established