Reading Entertainment Australia Pty Ltd v Birch Carroll and Coyle Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 58 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Reading Entertainment Australia Pty Ltd v Birch Carroll & Coyle Ltd [2001] FCA 1752

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – discovery – complex commercial issues arising in relation to causes of action for exclusive dealing against certain parties and knowing concern in relation thereto against remaining parties – discovery categories in dispute formulated by applicant – scope of documents in such categories potentially massive – similar fact documents sought in relation to geographical areas beyond the area of the market the subject of alleged misuse of power –formula for “high level” documents disputed on grounds of oppressive scope thereof – whether within framework of pleadings – cost and expense of discovery.

Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) ss 45, 46(1), 46(7), 47 and 75B
Federal Court Rules O 15 r 2(3), O 15 r 2(5), O 15 r 3(1), O 15 r 3(2)

BT Australia Pty Ltd v State of New South Wales (Sackville J, 20 May 1996, unreported) followed
Dowling v Dalgety Australia Ltd (1992) 34 FCR 109 referred to
Eastman Kodak Co v Image Technical Services Inc (1992) 504 US 451 referred to
F Hoffman-La Roche AG v Chiron Corporation and Another (2000) 47 IPR 516 followed
Melway Publishing Pty Ltd v Robert Hicks Pty Ltd (2001) 75 ALJR 600 referred to
South Sydney District Rugby League Football Club v News Ltd [2000] FCA 519 followed
The Lubrizol Corporation Inc v Imperial Chemical Industries plc [2000] FCA 1464 followed
Trade Practices Commission v CC (NSW) Pty Ltd (1995) 58 FCR 426 cited

Heydon, Trade Practices Law, para 5.410.29
JS Lockhart, ‘Handling Trade Practices Cases’ (1994) 17 University of New South Wales Law Journal 298
Federal Court Practice Note No. 14 published on 3 December 1999

READING ENTERTAINMENT AUSTRALIA PTY LIMITED v BIRCH CARROLL & COYLE LIMITED & OTHERS

NG 326 of 1997

CONTI J
11 DECEMBER 2001
SYDNEY


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

NG 326 OF 1997

BETWEEN:

READING ENTERTAINMENT AUSTRALIA PTY LTD
APPLICANT

AND:

BIRCH CARROLL & COYLE LIMITED
FIRST RESPONDENT

VILLAGE ROADSHOW EXHIBITION PTY LTD
SECOND RESPONDENT

PACIFIC CINEMAS (GARDEN CITY) PTY LTD
THIRD RESPONDENT

AMP LIFE LIMITED (ACN 079 300 379)
FOURTH RESPONDENT

AMP HENDERSON GLOBAL INVESTORS LIMITED
(ACN 001 777 591)
FIFTH RESPONDENT

VILLAGE ROADSHOW LIMITED (ACN 010 672 054)
SIXTH RESPONDENT

PACIFIC CINEMAS (LOGANHOLME) PTY LTD
(ACN 010 854 298)
SEVENTH RESPONDENT

JUDGE:

CONTI

DATE OF ORDER:

11 DECEMBER 2001

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.Interlocutory applications for discovery dismissed.

2.Liberty to apply on seven days’ notice.

3.Costs reserved.

Note:    Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

NG 326 OF 1997

BETWEEN:

READING ENTERTAINMENT AUSTRALIA PTY LTD
APPLICANT

AND:

BIRCH CARROLL & COYLE LIMITED
FIRST RESPONDENT

VILLAGE ROADSHOW EXHIBITION PTY LTD
SECOND RESPONDENT

PACIFIC CINEMAS (GARDEN CITY) PTY LTD
THIRD RESPONDENT

AMP LIFE LIMITED (ACN 079 300 379)
FOURTH RESPONDENT

AMP HENDERSON GLOBAL INVESTORS…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Reading Entertainment Australia Pty Ltd v Birch Carroll and... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2001] FCA 1752
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Reading Entertainment Australia Pty Ltd v Birch Carroll and Coyle Ltd, the court was faced with a dispute over the scope and admissibility of certain interrogatories in the context of an application for discovery of documents. The plaintiff, Reading Entertainment Australia, sought to obtain documents from the defendants, the Cinema Respondents, which they believed would demonstrate that the defendants had engaged in anti-competitive practices. The defendants argued that the interrogatories were overly broad and amounted to procedural "fishing", which is prohibited under the relevant legal principles. The court had to determine whether the interrogatories were valid and whether they fell within the scope of the legal rules governing discovery.

The key legal issue before the court was whether the interrogatories were permissible under the relevant provisions of the law, specifically Section 46 of the Act, which addresses anti-competitive conduct. The court needed to examine the scope of the categories formulated by Reading, and whether these categories were relevant to the particular market in which the alleged anti-competitive conduct occurred, namely the South Brisbane market. The court also had to consider the principle of "purpose" in the context of Section 46, and whether evidence of purpose in one market could be used to establish purpose in another market.

The court found that the interrogatories were overly broad and amounted to procedural "fishing", which is not permissible under the law. The court held that the interrogatories were not relevant to the particular market in which the alleged anti-competitive conduct occurred, and that evidence of purpose in one market could not be used to establish purpose in another market. The court therefore dismissed the interlocutory applications for discovery and reserved the issue of costs.

The court's decision in this case highlights the importance of ensuring that interrogatories are narrowly tailored to the particular issues in the case, and that they do not amount to procedural "fishing". The court's decision also underscores the need for parties to carefully consider the relevance of evidence in a particular market when bringing claims under Section 46 of the Act. The dismissal of the interlocutory applications for discovery serves as a reminder to parties to ensure that their discovery requests are properly framed and relevant to the issues in the case.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Interlocutory applications for discovery dismissed.

2. Liberty to apply on seven days’ notice.

3. Costs reserved.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

CONTI J
Greater Union did not provide any affidavit testimony, but relied on Village’s submissions and evidence as indicative of the reality of the scope of the categories formulated by Reading in terms of oppressive research and retrieval, thereby attracting the need for the Court’s consideration of the application of Rules 2(5) and 3 set out in [24-25] above, in the light of the policy spoken of in The Lubrizol as set out in [26] above.Conclusions upon the discovery issues arising between Reading on the one hand and the Cinema Respondents on the other The principal attack brought by the Cinema Respondents against the viability of the categories of interrogatories in dispute, which are set out in [19] above, is based upon the discovery principle of “fishing”, some authoritative statements as to the meaning whereof I have extracted in [22] above. As explained in [23-27] above, it is that symbolic description of procedural misuse to which the recent Federal Court discovery rules and practice note were introduced on 3 December 1999. Reading has sought to circumvent the complaints of the Cinema Respondents as to procedural “fishing” on Reading’s part by focusing upon the element of “purpose” contained in s 46 of the Act, in the manner and to the extent broadly explained in [29-33] above. At the risk of my proffering an unduly abbreviated description of the means adopted by Reading for justifying the expansive scope of the categories reproduced in [19] above, in terms which presently reflect a degree of modification from what had been earlier submitted by Reading, the categories in dispute framed by Reading are directed to documents brought into existence by the Cinema Respondents which Reading considers will serve to demonstrate purposive conduct on their part undertaken in Australia generally, and in certain parts of Australia specifically, which conduct serves to demonstrate the existence of the elements of a s 46 purpose of the Cinema Respondents undertaken in the South Brisbane market. The conceptual obstacle to Reading’s approach outlined above is that s 46 is relevantly directed to a purpose of damaging a competitor in either the market in which the offender has a substantial degree of power, or in some other market, whereas the issue presented to the Court in the s 46 cause of action is whether the Cinema Respondents have abused their power in the South Brisbane market for the purpose of preventing Reading’s entry into or engagement in that market. As was emphasised in F Hoffman-La Roche in the passage extracted in [21] above, “The framework within which discovery may be ordered is fixed by the pleadings… They determine the issues….”. The relevant issue here addressed is alleged conduct within the South Brisbane market in contravention of s 46. Even if, as Reading contends, that evidence of purpose per se in relation to one place is evidence of that purpose relevantly in relation to another place, which in a s 46 context is I think insufficient in principle, it does not follow that discovery may be sought relevantly in relation to the former purpose. The circumstance therefore that the Cinema Respondents may have a substantial degree of market power in a relevant market or markets outside of South Brisbane, and have abused such power in such external market or markets, is not an element in Reading’s s 46 cause of action as presently framed. I should add that I do not think that the provisions of sub-section (7) of s 46 assist Reading’s submissions based upon “purpose”, which do not use purpose in any sense disconnected from the market in which a corporation has a substantial degree of power.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: CONTI J