JURISDICTION : SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA
IN CIVIL
CITATION: RE WILL OF AUBREY WALTER MASON (Dec); EX PARTE THE PUBLIC TRUSTEE [2012] WASC 111
CORAM: SIMMONDS J
HEARD: 25 MAY 2011
DELIVERED : 30 MARCH 2012
FILE NO/S: CIV 1816 of 2009
MATTER :Will of AUBREY WALTER MASON (Dec)
EX PARTE
THE PUBLIC TRUSTEE
PlaintiffAND
AUSTRALIAN RED CROSS SOCIETY WESTERN AUSTRALIAN DIVISION
First DefendantPETER WILLIAM RYDER
Second Defendant
Catchwords:
Succession - Wills, probate and administration - Proof of will in solemn form - Undefended trial - Presumption the will was the will of a testator who possessed sound mind, memory and understanding at the time of its execution - Raising of a doubt as to testamentary capacity - Whether residual doubt substantial enough to preclude a belief that the document propounded is the will of a testator who possessed sound mind, memory and understanding at the time of its execution
Legislation:
Evidence Act 1906 (WA), s 79C
Guardianship and Administration Act 1990 (WA), s 123, sch 5
Public Trustees Act 1941 (WA), s 35, s 36C
Result:
Orders for probate of will in solemn form were made
Category: B
Representation:
Counsel:
Plaintiff: Mr D L Jones
First Defendant : Mr C C Forward
Second Defendant : Mr M M Solomon
Solicitors:
Plaintiff: Public Trustee
First Defendant : King & Wood Mallesons
Second Defendant : Bowen Buchbinder Vilensky
Case(s) referred to in judgment(s):
Banks v Goodfellow (1870) LR5QB 549
Martin v Fletcher [2003] WASC 59
Re Estate of Hodges (Dec); Shorter v Hodges (1988) 14 NSWLR 698
Re Levy (Dec) (No 2) [1957] VR 662
Re The Full Board of the Guardianship and Administration Board [2003] WASCA 268; (2003) 27 WAR 475
Roebuck v Smoje [2000] WASC 312
Smurthwaite v Stratford [2007] WASC 68
Symes v Green (1859) 1 Sw & Tr 401; (1859) 164 ER 785
The Public Trustee v Stretch [2002] WASC 147
SIMMONDS J:
Introduction
These are the reasons for a judgment given following a trial. The trial was of an action commenced by writ of summons with a statement of claim for orders that the court pronounce for the force and validity of a will and there be a grant of probate to the plaintiff of a will in solemn form The only significant issue at the trial was that of the testator's testamentary capacity.
Following case management directions in that regard, the trial was conducted on an undefended basis. At the end of the trial I gave judgment for the plaintiff and made the orders it sought.
The following are my reasons for that judgment.
I first describe the background before describing the proceedings and the evidence in the trial. I then turn to the issues in the trial and the applicable law,…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Re Will of Aubrey Walter Mason (Dec); and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2012] WASC 111
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court considered the principles established in relevant authorities, including the case of Re The Full Board of the Guardianship and Administration Board. The court was required to determine whether the evidence presented raised a doubt as to the testamentary capacity of the deceased to such an extent that it precluded a belief that the document propounded was the will of a testator who possessed sound mind, memory, and understanding at the time of its execution. The court noted that the question of testamentary capacity is always one of fact and that the tribunal of fact must be able to declare itself satisfied of the testator's competence at the time of the execution of the will.
After examining the evidence presented, the court concluded that there was a residual doubt as to the testamentary capacity of the deceased at the time of the execution of the will. This doubt was substantial enough to preclude a belief that the document propounded was the will of a testator who possessed sound mind, memory, and understanding at the time of its execution. As a result, the court held that the will was not valid and could not be admitted to probate. The court did not proceed to consider the merits of the objectors' claims against the estate.
Orders
Orders of the court
Full text does not contain this section.
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Full text does not contain this section.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
However, Re The Full Board of the Guardianship and Administration Board [2003] WASCA 268; (2003) 27 WAR 475 [52] (EM Heenan J; Anderson, Steytler, Miller & McLure JJ agreeing), referring to Symes v Green (1859) 1 Sw & Tr 401, 402; (1859) 164 ER 785 among other authorities, says this:A will of a deceased person will only be admitted to probate, or be the subject of a grant of letters of administration with the will annexed, if it is proved that at the time of its execution the testator had testamentary capacity. This issue is always one of fact: Sutton v Saddler (1857) 3 CB (NS) 87; 140 ER 671; Earl of Longford v Purdon (1877) 1 LR Ir 75 at 79 and Timbury v Coffee (1941) 66 CLR 277 at 280. The question for the tribunal of fact is whether the testator was of sound disposing mind and understanding when he made his will: 'That is the question which the wisdom of ages has framed, and, which as often as the question arises in courts of justice, and is put into form, in those words it is put into form' - Timbury v Coffee (supra). The factors of competency are that the party must know what he is about, have sense and knowledge of what he is doing, and the effect his disposition will have, knowledge of what his property was, and who those persons were that were then within the objects of his bounty - Frere v Peacocke (1846) 1 Rob Eccl 442 at 452 - 454; 163 ER 1095 at 1099. In addressing these issues in Timbury v Coffee (supra) and a finding of the jury that the last will of the testator should not be upheld because of the effect of his insane delusions interspersed with drinking bouts, which resulted in unreasoning prejudice towards his wife, Dixon J said, at 283, quoting other authority:'"Before a will can be upheld it must be shown that at the time of making it the testator had sufficient mental capacity to comprehend the nature of what he was doing, and its effects; that he was able to realize the extent and character of the property he was dealing with; and to weigh the claims which naturally ought to press upon him. In order that a man should rightly understand these various matters it is essential that his mind should be free to act in a natural, regular, and ordinary manner" (Per Hood J, In the Will of Wilson (1897) 23 VLR 197 at 199). "If a will rational on the face of it is shown to have been executed and attested in the manner prescribed by law, it is presumed, in the absence of any evidence to the contrary, that it was made by a person of competent understanding. But if there are circumstances in evidence which counter‑balance that presumption, the decree of the court must be against its validity, unless the evidence on the whole is sufficient to establish affirmatively that the testator was of sound mind when he executed it" (Per Cresswell J; Symes v Green (1859) 1 Sw & Tr 401 at 402; 164 ER 785 - Cf per Holroyd J, In the Will of Key (1892) 18 VLR 640. "In the end the tribunal - the court or the jury - must be able, affirmatively, on a review of the whole evidence, to declare itself satisfied of the testator's competence at the time of the execution of the will (Smith v Tebbitt (1867) LR 1 P & D 398 at 436; Sutton v Sadler (1857) 3 CB (NS) 87 at 97; 140 ER 671 at 675)" (per Rich J in Landers v Landers (1914) 19 CLR 222 at 235-6.'