Re Walker, D.R. Ex parte Walker, D.R. v Mercantile Credits Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 11 min read
JUDGMENT No. .%3%..1j

C A T C H W O R D S

Bankruptcy - Bankruptcy notice - application to set aside - securing payment of the sum referred to in the notice to the satisfaction of the court - relevant considerations to the court's determination.

BankruDtcv Act (1966) - s.41(2)(b)(ii)

Re Harrv Reicher: Ex Darte DeDUtV Commissioner of Taxation of the Commonwealth of Australia - Federal Court Victoria, B365 of 1990.

C O O D ~ ~ J.. Brisbane. 24 ADril. 1992
RE:  DONALD ROBIN WALKER: EX PARTE: D O W D ROBIN WALKER,
MERCANTILE CREDITS LIMITED A.C.N. 000 030 508
No. 265 of 1992

LIMITED DISTRIBUTION

C A T C H W O R D S

*

Bankruptcy - Bankruptcy notice - application to set aside - securing payment of the sum referred to in the notice to the satisfaction of the court - relevant considerations to the court's determination.

Bankru~tcv Act (1966) - s.41(2)(b)(ii)

Re Harrv Reicher: Ex parte Deputv Commissioner of Taxation of the Commonwealth of Australia - Federal Court Victoria, B365 of 1990.

Coo~er J

Brisbane

24 April, 1992

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
GENERAL DIVISION
BANKRUPTCY DISTRICT
OF THE STATE OF OUEENSLAND

9             No. 265 of 1992

RE: DONALD ROBIN WALKER

1 Judcrment Debtor)

EX PARTE: DONALD ROBIN WALKER

MERCANTILE CREDITS LIMITED

A.C.N. 000 030 508

J Respondent L

MINUTES OF ORDER

JUDGE MAKING ORDER:  Cooper J
DATE OF ORDER:  24 April, 1992
PLACE :  BRISBANE
THE COURT ORDERS THAT: 
  1. The application be dismissed.

2.        The applicant pay the respondent's costs of and incidental to the application, including any reserved costs, to be taxed.

  1. The time for compliance with the bankruptcy notice be extended to 4 pm, Monday, 27 April, 1992.

NOTE:  Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Rule
124 of the Bankruptcy Rules.

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
GENERAL DIVISION
BANKRUPTCY DISTRICT

OF THE STATE OF OUEENSLAND

q No. 265 of 1992

RE: DONALD ROBIN WALKER

J Judament Debtor 1

EX PARTE: DONALD ROBIN WALKER

MERCANTILE CREDITS LIMITED

A.C.N. 000 030 508

f Respondent 1

CORAM:  Cooper J
DATE :  24 April, 1992
PLACE :  BRISBANE

EX TEMPORE REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

This is an application by Donald Robin Walker to set aside a bankruptcy notice dated 19 February 1992 or for a declaration that the applicant has secured payment of the sum referred to in the notice to the satisfaction of the court.

The respondent, Mercantile Credits Limited, advanced to the applicant the sum of $50,000 in February 1988 on mortgage security over six blocks of land at Herberton. The applicant defaulted under the mortgage and the respondent entered judgment in the District Court at Brisbane for $67,016.54 on 3 January 1992.

At the time of the original advance, the loan was
supported by a valuation of Mr. D.J. Duffield of Richard Ellis

Valuers i n the sum o f $63,000. On 24 January 1991, t h e

appl icant advised t h e respondent by way o…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Re Walker, D.R. Ex parte Walker, D.R. v Mercantile Credits L... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1992] FCA 235
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Federal Court of Australia heard an application by Donald Robin Walker to set aside a bankruptcy notice or for a declaration that he had secured the payment of the debt to the satisfaction of the court. The respondent, Mercantile Credits Limited, had advanced $50,000 to the applicant on mortgage security over six blocks of land at Herberton. The applicant defaulted on the loan, resulting in Mercantile Credits Limited entering judgment for $67,016.54. The applicant sought to set aside the bankruptcy notice on the basis that he had secured payment of the debt to the satisfaction of the court. The court considered the valuation of the land and the potential impact of contamination from nearby mining operations. The court found that the security over the land did not satisfy the test for setting aside the bankruptcy notice as it could not confidently be expected that the respondent would be assured of prompt satisfaction of the judgment. The application to set aside the bankruptcy notice was dismissed, and the applicant was ordered to pay the respondent's costs of the application. The time for compliance with the bankruptcy notice was extended to 4 pm on Monday, 27 April 1992.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves Donald Robin Walker (the applicant) who has defaulted on a mortgage loan of $50,000 advanced by Mercantile Credits Limited (the respondent). The mortgage was secured by six blocks of land at Herberton. The applicant defaulted, leading to the respondent entering judgment in the District Court at Brisbane for $67,016.54 on 3 January 1992. The applicant applied to set aside a bankruptcy notice dated 19 February 1992 or for a declaration that he has secured payment of the sum referred to in the notice to the satisfaction of the court. The applicant cited contamination issues with 15% of the land due to arsenic from the Great Northern Mine as a reason for his inability to sell the property. A revaluation of the land in March 1991 placed its value at $34,500, which the applicant disputes, arguing that other blocks of land not subject to the proceedings are more affected by the contamination.

This case was heard in the Federal Court of Australia, General Division, Bankruptcy District of the State of Queensland. The application by Donald Robin Walker to set aside the bankruptcy notice was initially adjourned to allow the applicant to obtain valuation material and conduct survey work. The case was then heard by Cooper J on 7 April 1992, with the judgment delivered on 24 April 1992.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the applicant has secured payment of the sum referred to in the bankruptcy notice to the satisfaction of the court.
2. Whether the contamination of the land due to arsenic from the Great Northern Mine justifies setting aside the bankruptcy notice.
3. Whether the value of the land, as per the applicant's valuation, is sufficient to satisfy the judgment debt.

Held
1. The court dismissed the application to set aside the bankruptcy notice.
2. The court did not find that the contamination of the land due to arsenic from the Great Northern Mine justified setting aside the bankruptcy notice.
3. The court was not persuaded that the value of the land, as per the applicant's valuation, was sufficient to satisfy the judgment debt.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered whether the applicant had secured the payment of the sum referred to in the bankruptcy notice to the satisfaction of the court. The applicant had provided a valuation from Mr. Gordon, which valued the land at $72,500. However, the court found that the valuation did not adequately consider the issue of arsenic contamination on the land. The court noted that the land had been categorised as a probable contamination site under the provisions of the Contamination of Land Act 1990, and required a written notice to be given to any intended purchaser regarding the contamination. The court was not prepared to prefer Mr. Gordon's valuation over that of Mr. Duffield, who valued the land at $34,500, as it was unclear whether Mr. Gordon had considered the contamination issue in his valuation.

The court further considered whether the contamination of the land justified setting aside the bankruptcy notice. The court noted that the applicant had consistently asserted that the land was contaminated with arsenic, which made it difficult to dispose of the property. However, the court found that the contamination issue did not provide a sufficient basis to set aside the bankruptcy notice.

Lastly, the court assessed whether the value of the land, as per the applicant's valuation, was sufficient to satisfy the judgment debt. The court was not persuaded that the market value of the land exceeded the judgment debt or that the security was sufficient to confidently expect that the respondent would be assured of prompt satisfaction of the judgment. There was real doubt as to when, if at all, and in what sum the land could be sold exercising the power of sale under the mortgage.

The court applied the principles established in Re Harrv Reicher: Ex parte Deputy Commissioner of Taxation, where Jenkinson J held that the court should ensure that the security offered is sufficient to assure the creditor of prompt satisfaction of the judgment. The court found that the security over the land at Herberton did not satisfy this test.