Re Trusts of Kean Memorial Trust Fund

Link copied
Case Copied 51 min read

IN RE THE TRUSTS OF THE KEAN MEMORIAL

TRUST FUND;
THE TRUSTEES OF THE KEAN MEMORIAL
TRUST FUND v THE ATTORNEY-GENERAL FOR SOUTH

AUSTRALIA

[2003] SASC 227

  1. BESANKO J: This is an application by the trustees of the Kean Memorial Trust Fund (“the Trust”) for the determination of certain questions of construction and for orders under ss 59B and 69B of the Trustee Act 1936 (“the Act”) and the inherent jurisdiction of the Court. The defendant is the Attorney-General for South Australia.

  2. The action was commenced by inter partes summons dated 24 June 1999.  A number of affidavits were filed in support of the orders sought in the summons.  The summons has since been amended and further affidavits have been filed by the trustees.  In these reasons it is sufficient to refer to the orders sought in a document filed by the trustees entitled “A Scheme for the Execution of the Trusts of the Kean Memorial Trust Fund” (the “scheme document”).  It is the orders in the scheme document which the trustees now seek.

  3. A Judge of this Court has already made two important orders in this action, and in due course it will be necessary to set out these orders and the circumstances in which they were made.

  4. Unfortunately, the Judge who heard the application for the orders now sought became ill and I was assigned to complete the matter.  The parties were content for me to do so by reading the scheme document, the affidavits and a transcript of the submissions made to the Judge.

    The Facts

  5. Eileen Margaret Kean late of Findon in the State of South Australia (“the testatrix”) died on 24 September 1994.  She executed a will which was admitted to probate by this Court in its testamentary causes jurisdiction on 2 June 1995.

  6. The testatrix’s will consists of two documents.  The first is a document called “The Last Will and Testament” which was executed by the testatrix on 4 February 1981.  In the grant of probate it is referred to as paper writing marked “A”.  The relevant clause of the document provides as follows:

    “3.I GIVE DEVISE AND BEQUEATH the whole of my real and personal estate to my trustees UPON TRUST to pay thereout my funeral and testamentary expenses and debts and carry out the distribution of my estate as follows:-

    …

    (d)     As to the rest and residue of my estate to be applied in ‘THE KEAN MEMORIAL TRUST FUND” for ST JOSEPHS PARISH SCHOOL Richmond as defined in a letter to the said Kevin Vincent Kerin on the 5th January 1981.

    To date this Trust Fund has not been finalised but it is my desire that should I predecease its implementation my Trustees are to ensure its fulfilment.”

  7. The second document is a letter from the testatrix to Mr Kevin Kerin, solicitor, prepared on 5 January 1981 (but incorrectly dated 5 January 1980).  In the grant of probate it is referred to as paper writing marked “B”.  The relevant parts…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Re Trusts of Kean Memorial Trust Fund and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2003] SASC 227
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Re Trusts of Kean Memorial Trust Fund involved the trustees of the Kean Memorial Trust Fund, who sought orders to clarify their powers and duties under the will of the deceased, Eileen Margaret Kean. The case was heard in the Supreme Court of South Australia. The trustees sought various orders to clarify and expand their powers in administering the trust fund established by the deceased’s will, which was intended for the benefit of St Joseph’s Parish School in Richmond.

The court was required to determine whether the trustees had the authority to delegate certain of their powers, particularly in relation to the acquisition and management of properties within the trust’s designated zones. Additionally, the court needed to address whether the trustees could be relieved of the obligation to maintain confidentiality regarding the trust’s details. The court also had to consider whether the trustees should incorporate under the Associations Incorporation Act, and how this might affect their powers and responsibilities.

The court found that it was appropriate to grant the trustees certain powers of delegation, subject to their consideration of incorporating under the Associations Incorporation Act. The court proposed to hear further submissions from the parties on this matter. Regarding the obligation of confidentiality, the court indicated it was inclined to relieve the trustees from this obligation but sought further input on the precise terms of such relief. The court also agreed to grant orders for the acquisition and management of properties within the designated zones, pending further input on whether these orders should apply to all properties within the zones. Finally, the court declined to grant certain orders that would have allowed the trustees to undertake specific actions outside the scope of the trust’s original intentions.

The court made orders under s 59B of the relevant Act to allow the trustees to acquire and manage properties within the designated zones, subject to further input on extending these powers to all properties within the zones. The court also granted relief from the obligation of confidentiality, pending further input on the terms of such relief. Orders were made to grant certain powers of delegation, subject to the trustees’ consideration of incorporation under the Associations Incorporation Act. Certain other orders were declined as they were found to be outside the scope of the trust’s original intentions.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Unfortunately, the Judge who heard the application for the orders now sought became ill and I was assigned to complete the matter. The parties were content for me to do so by reading the scheme document, the affidavits and a transcript of the submissions made to the Judge.The Facts Eileen Margaret Kean late of Findon in the State of South Australia (“the testatrix”) died on 24 September 1994. She executed a will which was admitted to probate by this Court in its testamentary causes jurisdiction on 2 June 1995. The testatrix’s will consists of two documents. The first is a document called “The Last Will and Testament” which was executed by the testatrix on 4 February 1981. In the grant of probate it is referred to as paper writing marked “A”. The relevant clause of the document provides as follows:“3.I GIVE DEVISE AND BEQUEATH the whole of my real and personal estate to my trustees UPON TRUST to pay thereout my funeral and testamentary expenses and debts and carry out the distribution of my estate as follows:-…(d) As to the rest and residue of my estate to be applied in ‘THE KEAN MEMORIAL TRUST FUND” for ST JOSEPHS PARISH SCHOOL Richmond as defined in a letter to the said Kevin Vincent Kerin on the 5th January 1981.To date this Trust Fund has not been finalised but it is my desire that should I predecease its implementation my Trustees are to ensure its fulfilment.” The second document is a letter from the testatrix to Mr Kevin Kerin, solicitor, prepared on 5 January 1981 (but incorrectly dated 5 January 1980). In the grant of probate it is referred to as paper writing marked “B”. The relevant parts of the letter are as follows:“The purpose of the TRUST FUND is to initiate a fund for the purchase of properties adjoining the ST JOSEPH’S PRIMARY SCHOOL and ST ALOYSIUS CHURCH, BROOKER TERRACE, RICHMOND, as they become available for sale and at a fair market price.As I have devoted my entire working life to the education, welfare and recreational needs of school children I feel that this contribution, if wisely invested, could benefit this CRAMPED SCHOOL and in particular the children who attend it in years to come.The areas marked out on the sheet enclosed are in two (2) zones. ZONE I being first priority and ZONE II being second, depending on resources available.When the houses purchased in these Zones have reached the end of their useful life as a place of residence for tenants or others as nominated they are to be demolished to provide a grassed playing area for the school children with a minimum of encroachment by school buildings, etc.Although this may appear rather ambitious, with good management I feel this project will succeed.The TRUST FUND is for this reason to be administered by the CATHOLIC ENDOWMENT SOCIETY, the ST JOSEPH’S SCHOOL BOARD, yourself, MR KEVIN KERIN, for all legal matters, etc. and MR RALPH MARTIN.It is my wish that MR RALPH MARTIN upholds my interests in this venture and therefore has the POWER OF VETO in all decisions relating to the TRUST FUND during my lifetime and his.…It is my wish that the information contained in this letter be kept in strict confidence at all times.”

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Judge raised with counsel for the trustees the possibility that the question of the trustees’ ability to delegate was linked to the question of whether the trustee should be an incorporated body under the Associations Incorporation Act. I am inclined to think that an appropriate order giving the trustees the authority to delegate certain powers is justified, but I will give the trustees the opportunity to consider whether that should be considered at the same time as consideration is given to incorporating an entity under the Associations Incorporation Act.Conclusions In relation to Part I of the scheme document, I wish to hear the parties further in relation to paragraph 3(2). I am prepared to make an order under s 59B of the Act in terms of paragraph 3(1) in relation to properties in Zone I and to hear the parties as to whether the order should extend to properties in Zone II. I am prepared to make an order under s 59B of the Act in terms of paragraph 3(3). I am prepared to make an order under s 59B relieving the trustees from the obligation of confidence (paragraph 3(4)), but I wish to hear the parties further as to the precise terms of such an order. In relation to Part II of the scheme document, I am prepared to make orders in terms of paragraphs 4(1), 4(2), 4(3), 4(4) (as amended), and 4(5) (as amended). I am not prepared to make orders in terms of paragraphs 4(6) and (8). In relation to paragraph 4(7), I am disposed to make an order giving the trustees certain powers of delegation, but I will give the trustees the opportunity to give further consideration to the terms of any such order. In relation to Part III of the scheme document, I am not prepared to make orders in terms of paragraphs 5(1) – (4) inclusive of the scheme document.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established