Re SWZ

Link copied
Case Copied 23 min read

MENTAL HEALTH COURT

CITATION:

Re SWZ [2019] QMHC 2

PROCEEDING:

Appeal

DELIVERED ON:

27 February 2019

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

10 December 2018

JUDGE:

Flanagan J

ASSISTING PSYCHIATRISTS:

Dr J J Sundin and
Dr R E Phillipson

DETERMINATION:

1.  Appeal allowed.

2.  The decision of the Mental Health Review Tribunal made 3 October 2018 revoking the forensic order is set aside.

3.  [Redacted]

4.  [Redacted]

COUNSEL:

P M Clohessy for the appellant
S J Hamlyn-Harris for the Chief Psychiatrist
J D Briggs for the respondent

SOLICITORS:

Crown Law for the appellant

Legal Aid Queensland for the respondent

NOTE:This judgment is published pursuant to s 790 of the Mental Health Act 2016. It has been anonymised and several redactions have been made to preserve anonymity.

  1. [Redacted]  On [redacted], the Mental Health Court made the respondent subject to a forensic order on the basis that he was of unsound mind [redacted].  On 3 October 2018, upon review, the Mental Health Review Tribunal (Tribunal) decided to revoke the forensic order.  The appellant, the Attorney‑General for the State of Queensland, appeals against the Tribunal’s decision.

  2. The sole ground of appeal is that the Tribunal erred in law when it concluded that s 442(1) of the Mental Health Act 2016 (MHA 2016) required the respondent to have a current existing “mental condition” before the Tribunal could confirm the forensic order.  The Tribunal revoked the forensic order on the basis that the respondent had no “mental condition”.

  3. The appeal to this Court is by way of rehearing.[1]

    [1] MHA 2016 s 546(2).

    The Tribunal’s Statement of Reasons

  4. The Tribunal considered a number of psychiatric and psychological reports.  These included a clinical report prepared by Dr Purushothaman dated 18 September 2018 to which was annexed the Assessment and Risk Management Committee (ARMC) meeting minutes of 2 August 2018 and a second opinion of Dr Frances Dark dated 21 February 2018.  The Tribunal also had before it a report of Dr Schramm dated 20 August 2018 which had been produced by him pursuant to a Tribunal Examination Order.  There was also a report dated 2 March 2018 from the Community Forensic Outreach Service (CFOS) by Dr Garrick Anderson, psychiatrist, and Ms Annette Vasey, psychologist.

  5. Both Dr Purushothaman and Dr Schramm gave oral evidence before the Tribunal.  The evidence of Dr Purushothaman was that the respondent did not have a diagnosable mental illness or intellectual disability.  According to Dr Purushothaman the respondent was not taking any medication and did not require any.  He saw Dr Purushothaman every two months and Ms Martin, who was a part of the treating team, every three weeks.  Neither clinician had any concerns, or had seen any symptoms of mental illness.  In Dr Dark’s opinion the respondent’s period of mental illness was relatively brief and there had been no evidence of diagnosable mental illness for over six years and no need for psychopharmacology. 

  6. The Tribunal referred to Dr Schramm’s opinion that the respondent does not…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Re SWZ and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] QMHC 2
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Re SWZ, the appeal was brought by the Attorney-General of the Commonwealth against a decision of the Mental Health Tribunal, which had declined to confirm a forensic order. The primary concern was whether the tribunal had erred in its interpretation of the statutory requirement for a "mental condition" as a prerequisite for confirming the forensic order. The case was heard in the Federal Court of Australia, which was tasked with determining the correct interpretation of the Mental Health Act 2016 (MHA 2016) in relation to the forensic order regime.

The central legal issue revolved around the interpretation of section 442(1) of the MHA 2016, specifically whether the term "mental condition" necessitates a present and existing mental illness for the confirmation of a forensic order. The appellant argued that the tribunal had misconstrued the purpose of the forensic order, which is primarily a risk protection mechanism aimed at safeguarding the community, rather than being solely dependent on the presence of a current mental illness. The respondent, on the other hand, contended that the term "mental condition" should be understood in its plain meaning, referring to an existing state, and not a potential future state. The respondent emphasized that the Act safeguards fundamental rights and does not permit the erosion of personal liberty based on speculative future risks.

The court examined the objects of the MHA 2016, particularly the need to protect the community from individuals diverted from the criminal justice system. The tribunal's decision to decline confirming the forensic order was based on its finding that the respondent did not have a current mental condition. However, the court found that the tribunal had not adequately considered the broader risk protection mechanism inherent in the forensic order regime. The court held that the tribunal had erred in placing undue emphasis on the requirement of a current mental condition, thereby overlooking the overarching purpose of the Act, which is to protect the community from potential harm. Consequently, the appeal was allowed, and the matter was remitted to the tribunal for reconsideration in light of the court's findings.

The final orders of the court included the allowance of the appeal, the quashing of the tribunal’s decision, and the direction that the tribunal reconsider the matter, taking into account the court's interpretation of the statutory requirements and the broader objectives of the MHA 2016.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

After referring to the Victim Impact Statement that had been filed [redacted] urging the Tribunal to confirm the forensic order, the Tribunal further observed:[11]“The Tribunal has read this statement with empathy for the family [redacted]. The Tribunal must apply the law as set out in the Act, and the risks relevant to the Tribunal’s consideration are those arising from a mental condition. Having found [the respondent] does not have a mental condition, [the family’s] submissions, whilst acknowledged, could not be given significant weight in the Tribunal’s decision.”[11] Tribunal’s Statement of Reasons, page 11.The Tribunal’s Decision is Stayed On 2 November 2018 Dalton J granted a stay of the decision of the Tribunal pursuant to s 544 of the MHA 2016 pending the disposition of the present appeal.The Appellant’s Submissions The appellant identifies the question for determination on appeal as “whether the Tribunal erred in its conclusion that s 442(1) of the [MHA 2016] required [the respondent] to have a current existing ‘mental condition’ as a prerequisite to confirming the forensic order.”[12][12] Outline of Submissions on Behalf of the Attorney-General, paragraph [1]. In answering that question, the appellant submits as follows:[13]“The Tribunal erred in concluding the test for confirming the forensic order in s 442 of the [MHA 2016] could not be satisfied because the need for the order to protect the safety of the community must derive from the person’s present and existing mental illness. The reasoning applied being, if there is no present and existing mental illness, then there can be no order….The forensic order regime under the [MHA 2016] is first and foremost a risk protection mechanism serving one of the main objects of the [MHA 2016], that is, protecting the community from harm by persons have been diverted from the criminal justice system.As part of that risk management scheme, orders can, not only mandate involuntary treatment, but also provide a level of oversight, support and monitoring to protect the community from harm. Orders may also contain other conditions not associated with treatment of the patient but with the protection of others (for example, conditions relating to driving, the use of substances and contact with victims).If the Tribunal’s reasoning is accepted as correct, then any patient afforded a defence of unsoundness of mind due to a transient or episodic mental illness, despite a risk of recurrence, cannot be supervised under the forensic order or treatment support order regime because they do not have a current mental illness. The Tribunal’s approach placed far too great an emphasis on the conditions of the forensic order mandating involuntary psychiatric treatment, including the ability to prescribe medication, and failed to consider that the forensic order regime is primarily a risk protection mechanism for the community, of which involuntary treatment only forms part.”[13] Outline of Submissions on Behalf of the Attorney-General, paragraphs [22]-[26].

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The respondent submits that the word “condition” in the expression “mental condition” should be given its plain meaning, consistent with the purposes of the MHA 2016[19] and the same meaning throughout the whole Act.[20] By reference to the plain meaning of the word, the respondent submits that the word “condition” within the expression “mental condition” refers to an existing state, and not a state which may in future occur.[21] This interpretation according to the respondent is consistent with the objects of the MHA 2016 and in particular s 3(2)(a) which states that the main objects of the Act identified in s 3(1)(a) to (c) are to be achieved in a way that safeguards the rights of persons. The term “mental condition” in s 442(1) should therefore be construed so as not to impute to the legislature an intention to interfere with “fundamental rights”.[22] The respondent therefore submits that nothing in the MHA 2016 either expressly or by necessary implication “allows the erosion of the fundamental right to personal liberty on the basis of a speculation that a person may be at risk of suffering a mental illness or natural mental infirmity in the future or at risk of a recurrence of such a condition.”[23][19] Project Blue Sky Inc v Australian Broadcasting Authority (1998) 194 CLR 355 at 384 [78] per McHugh, Gummow, Kirby and Hayne JJ; Acts Interpretation Act 1954 s 14A.[20] Acts Interpretation Act 1954 s 32AA.[21] Outline of Submissions on Behalf of the Respondent, pages 5-6.[22] Coco v The Queen (1994) 179 CLR 427 and Al-Kateb v Godwin (2004) 219 CLR 562 at 577 [19] per Gleeson CJ.[23] Respondent’s Outline of Submissions, page 8.Consideration Section 3(1) of the MHA 2016 identifies the three main objects of the Act as follows: “(a) to improve and maintain the health and wellbeing of persons who have a mental illness who do not have the capacity to consent to be treated; and(b) to enable persons to be diverted from the criminal justice system if found to have been of unsound mind at the time of committing an unlawful act or to be unfit for trial; and(c) to protect the community if persons diverted from the criminal justice system may be at risk of harming others.” Section 3(2) provides that these three main objects are to be achieved in a way that:“(a) safeguards the rights of persons; and (b) is the least restrictive of the rights and liberties of a person who has a mental illness; and(c) promotes the recovery of a person who has a mental illness, and the person’s ability to live in the community, without the need for involuntary treatment and care.” In the present case the respondent was diverted from the criminal justice system. [Redacted] The Mental Health Court was satisfied on the balance of probabilities that the respondent’s mental illness deprived him of the capacity to understand the nature and quality of his actions, and of the capacity to control his actions. [Redacted] Since being made, the forensic order has been reviewed by the Tribunal according to statutory requirements. As the respondent has already been diverted from the criminal justice system, the primary object of the MHA 2016 that is relevant to these reviews is the object of protecting the community if persons (such as the respondent) diverted from the criminal justice system may be at risk of harming others.