FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
Hughes, in the matter of Substar Holdings Pty Ltd (in liquidation) [2020] FCA 1863
File number: WAD 243 of 2020 Judgment of: MCKERRACHER J Date of judgment: 23 December 2020 Catchwords: CORPORATIONS – application by liquidators to be appointed as receivers of trust assets – where trust deed disqualifies the corporate trustee upon insolvency – where corporate trustee cannot realise its right to indemnity and exoneration as bare trustee – where judicial advice sought that the liquidators are justified in treating the property in the name of the company as property of the trust Legislation: Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) ss 420, 420(2)(s), 420(2)(t), 420(2)(u), 420(2)(w), 555, 556, 560, 561, Sch 2 ss 90-15, 90-20
Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 57
Trustees Act 1962 (WA) s 7
Federal Court (Corporations) Rules 2000 (Cth) r 2.8
Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) rr 14.21, 14.22
Cases cited: Amirbeaggi, in the matter of Simpkiss Pty Ltd (in liq) [2018] FCA 2121
Brereton, in the matter of MyHouse (Aust) Pty Limited (administrators appointed) [2020] FCA 610
Caterpillar Financial Australia Limited v Ovens Nominee Pty Ltd [2011] FCA 677
Cremin, in the matter of Brimson Pty Ltd (in liq) [2019] FCA 1023; (2019) 136 ACSR 649
Jones v Matrix Partners Pty Ltd (2018) 260 FCR 310; [2018] FCAFC 40
Krejci, in the matter of Union Standard International Group Pty Ltd (Administrators Appointed) (No 2) [2020] FCA 1111
Staatz v Berry, in the matter of Wollumbin Horizons Pty Ltd (in liq) (No 3) [2019] FCA 924
Division: General Division Registry: Western Australia National Practice Area: Commercial and Corporations Sub-area: Corporations and Corporate Insolvency Number of paragraphs: 46 Date of last submission: 10 December 2020 Date of hearing: Determined on the papers Counsel for the Applicants: Mr A McDonald Solicitor for the Applicants: Pragma Lawyers ORDERS
WAD 243 of 2020 IN THE MATTER OF SUBSTAR HOLDINGS PTY LTD (IN LIQUIDATION) ACN 154 916 711
BETWEEN: BRIAN HUGHES AND DANIEL JOHANNES BREDENKAMP IN THEIR CAPACITY AS JOINT AND SEVERAL LIQUIDATORS OF SUBSTAR HOLDINGS PTY LTD ACN 154 916 711
First Applicant
SUBSTAR HOLDINGS PT LTD (IN LIQUIDATION) ACN 154 916 711
Second Applicant
ORDER MADE BY:
MCKERRACHER J
DATE OF ORDER:
23 DECEMBER 2020
THE COURT ORDERS THAT:
Orders
1.Pursuant to s 57 of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) the liquidators of Substar Holdings Pty Ltd (in Liq) (ACN 154 916 711) (Company), Bryan Hughes and Daniel Bredenkamp, Pitcher Partners, Level 11, 12-14 The Esplanade Perth in the State of Western Australia be appointed as receivers and managers (Receivers) of the property of the Taurus Investments Trust and any other property held by the Company on trust (Trust Property).
2.The Receivers be authorised to take possession of, preserve, maintain and sell the assets comprising the…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Re Substar Holdings Pty Ltd (in liq) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2020] FCA 1863
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court found that upon Substar's liquidation, it ceased to be the trustee of the Taurus Investments Trust and instead held all trust assets as a bare trustee. The trust deed disqualified the corporate trustee from acting as trustee upon insolvency. Furthermore, the court ruled that the liquidators were justified in treating the property in the name of Substar as property of the trust, as the corporate trustee could not realise its right to indemnity and exoneration. The court's decision allowed the liquidators to act as receivers and managers of the trust property, take possession of, preserve, maintain, and sell the assets, and distribute the proceeds to the trust's beneficiaries and creditors. The court also granted liberty to apply for further orders and set aside or vary the orders if necessary.
Orders
Orders of the court
Orders
1. Pursuant to s 57 of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) the liquidators of Substar Holdings Pty Ltd (in Liq) (ACN 154 916 711) (Company), Bryan Hughes and Daniel Bredenkamp, Pitcher Partners, Level 11, 12-14 The Esplanade Perth in the State of Western Australia be appointed as receivers and managers (Receivers) of the property of the Taurus Investments Trust and any other property held by the Company on trust (Trust Property).
2. The Receivers be authorised to take possession of, preserve, maintain and sell the assets comprising the Trust Property.
3. The Receivers have all the powers that a receiver has in respect of the business and property of a company under s 420 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) (other than in subs 420(2)(s), (t), (u) and (w)) as if the reference in that section to ‘the corporation’ were a reference to the Taurus Investments Trust or the Taurua Investments Trust including, without limitation, the power to do all things necessary or convenient to:
(a) investigate transactions made using funds derived from the Trust Property;
(b) demand the books and records of the Taurus Investments Trust or the Taurua Investments Trust from any person;
(c) determine and make payment of any claims against the Trust Property;
(d) in accordance with the priorities set out in s 556 of the Corporations Act, distribute the proceeds of the sale of the assets of the Taurus Investment Trust or the Taurua Investments Trust (after payment of the costs, expenses and remuneration of the Receivers in their capacity as the Receivers and as liquidators of the Company) to any creditors of the Taurus Investments Trust or the Taurua Investments Trust; and
(e) distribute any surplus thereafter to the beneficiaries of the Taurus Investments Trust or the Taurua Investments Trust.
4. The costs, expenses and remuneration of the Receivers in:
(a) acting as the liquidator of the Company; and
(b) acting as the Receivers of the assets and undertaking of the Trust;
be paid from the Trust Property.
5. The Receivers be allowed remuneration for the work undertaken, over the period from 4 August 2020 to 25 November 2020, for and relevant to the purpose of the liquidation of the Company, in the sum of $74,676.50 (plus GST).
6. The need for the Receivers to file a guarantee under r 14.21 and r 14.22 of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) be dispensed with.
7. The first applicants’ costs of this application be paid out of the Trust Property.
8. Liberty be granted to any person affected by these orders, including any creditor of the Company or the Taurus Investments Trust, the Taurua Investments Trust or any beneficiary of the Taurus Investments Trust or the Taurua Investments Trust, to apply to vary or set aside these orders on 7 business days’ notice to the applicants and to the Court by sending an email to Associate.McKerracherJ@fedcourt.gov.au.
9. Liberty be granted to the applicants to apply to the Court for orders discharging and releasing the Receivers on 7 business days’ notice by sending an email to Associate.McKerracherJ@fedcourt.gov.au.
Directions
10. The Receivers are justified in treating:
(a) all of the assets of the Taurus Investments Trust as assets beneficially held by the Company, as bare trustee, subject to any charge or lien that the Company has over the assets of the Taurus Investments Trust to secure the payment of any debts properly incurred by the Company as trustee; and
(b) all liabilities incurred by the Company in the conduct of its business as liabilities of the Taurus Investments Trust.
11. The Receivers, in their capacities as liquidators of the Company and Receivers are justified in distributing the Trust Property as follows:
(a) first, paying the amount of the applicants’ costs of this application as determined in accordance with Order 7 above;
(b) second, paying the amount of approximately $74,676.50 to the Receivers for their remuneration as determined in accordance with Order 5 above;
(c) third, paying the Receivers further expenses and remuneration in their capacity as liquidators of the Company and in their capacity as the Receivers, from 26 November 2020 to the conclusion of the receivership and liquidation of the Company, on a time basis at a reasonable fee according to the hours for which they, or any employee of Pitcher Partners, engage or have engaged in work necessary for and relevant to the purpose of the receivership or liquidation after 4 August 2020, such remuneration to be calculated at the standard hourly rates of Pitcher Partners from time to time for work of that nature, together with all reasonable out of pocket expenses; and
(d) fourth, distributing the balance, after payment of the amounts in (a) - (c) above, to the admitted creditors of the Company in accordance with the priority regime established by ss 555, 556, 560 and 561 of the Corporations Act and distribute any surplus thereafter to the beneficiaries of the Taurus Investments Trust.
Further or alternative orders
12. There be liberty to apply.
Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Full text does not contain this section.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Significantly for present purposes, cl 7.6 of the Trust Deed provides that the trustee of the Trust will be determined and vacated if, among other things, the trustee enters into liquidation or has a receiver appointed. Accordingly, on the date that the liquidation commenced, Substar ceased as trustee of the Trust and has, since that time, held all Trust assets as a bare trustee.LACK OF RECORDS AND NON-COOPERATION OF DIRECTOR A substantial portion of the primary and supplementary affidavits are directed to detailing the steps taken by the Liquidators to elicit information about the Company’s affairs from its sole Director, and the actions that have had to be taken as a result of his alleged non-cooperation. (The relevant papers have been served on the director’s legal representatives who have not contested any aspect of the account.) They reveal the following chronology of attempted conferral with the Company’s Director and Shareholder in the months since the liquidation commenced:(a)on 4 August 2020, Mr Delaney of the Liquidators’ staff attempted to contact the Director and the Shareholder via mobile numbers that had been provided to the Liquidators by Substar’s petitioning creditor. Voice mail messages were left (where possible) but no response was forthcoming;(b)on 5 August 2020, Mr Delaney contacted accounting firm, Macri Partners, which a company search for Substar obtained via Equifax Inc. on 4 August 2020 disclosed to be the registered officeholder of Substar. In a telephone conversation with Mr Joseph Macri of Macri Partners, Mr Delaney was advised that the Shareholder had been made bankrupt effective 20 November 2017 and that a bankruptcy trustee was acting on his behalf. Mr Macri advised that following the Shareholder’s incapacitation, his son had become Director of Substar. Mr Macri advised that Macri Partners held very little books and records for Substar and was not responsible for preparing its tax returns or financial statements. Mr Macri did not have any contact telephone number for the Director but was able to provide an additional mobile number for the Shareholder;(c)on 6 August 2020, Mr Bredenkamp of the Liquidators sent, by registered post, a letter to the Director enclosing a notice to deliver all accounting books and records of Substar and a request to complete a Report on Company Activities and Property (ROCAP). They did not receive a response;(d)on 6 August 2020, Mr Delaney had a telephone conversation with Mr Alex Cimetta of SV Partners who confirmed that Mr Field remained the bankruptcy trustee for the Shareholder, Leopold Scala. Mr Cimetta advised Mr Delaney words to the effect: Leopold was a difficult individual to get a hold of and he does not have an email address. The only time our office was able to get a hold of him was when members of our staff went to his house. Mr Cimetta confirmed the Shareholder’s contact telephone number to be the same as the number provided by Mr Macri. Mr Cimetta also advised Mr Delaney that the bankruptcy trustee had been unable to locate any of the 20 motor vehicles that had been registered in Leopold Scala’s name at the time of the bankruptcy trustee’s appointment;(e)on 6 August 2020, Mr Pattinson of the Liquidators’ staff received a call from the Shareholder requesting information about the liquidation. Mr Pattinson requested contact information for the Director and also requested that the Shareholder instruct the Director to contact the Liquidators to arrange an appropriate time to meet with them to discuss the business, property and affairs of Substar. The Shareholder advised Mr Pattinson with words to the effect that:he intended to pay out the creditors of the liquidation following receipt of proceeds from the sale of one of his other properties and that he would call Mr Pattinson back the following day to schedule a meeting with himself, the Director and the Liquidators. No subsequent meeting or response was forthcoming from the Shareholder;(f)on 11 August 2020, the Liquidators sent, by registered post, a letter to the Director enclosing a second notice to deliver all accounting books and records of Substar and a request to complete a ROCAP, by no later than 18 August 2020. The Liquidators did not receive a response;(g)on 13 August 2020, having received no engagement from the Director and no subsequent engagement from the Shareholder, Mr Pattinson, Mr Delaney and Mr Lobb of the Liquidators’ staff attended upon each of the locations of Substar’s three real properties (as detailed below) and also the Director’s registered address in Waterford (the Scala Family Residence) with a view to determine if any assets or records were located at these properties. The Liquidators located five motor vehicles and were advised by a person at a neighbouring business that the Shareholder had last attended that property on 7 August 2020. The Liquidators did not meet either the Director or the Shareholder at any of these locations;(h)on 14 August 2020, Mr Pattinson made attempts to contact the Director and the Shareholder on the three telephone numbers previously provided to the Liquidators on 4 and 5 August 2020. Voice mail messages were left (where possible) but no response was forthcoming;(i)on that same date, Mr Pattinson attempted to contact the Director via Facebook messenger. The message which appears to have been sent to the Director’s correct account based on available photographic images was not read by the Director;(j)on 19 August 2020, Mr Pattinson made further attempts to contact the Director and the Shareholder on the three telephone numbers. Voice mail messages were left on the answering service (where possible), but no response was forthcoming;(k)on 20 August 2020, having determined the Shareholder to be an officer of Substar, the Liquidators sent, by registered post, a letter to the Shareholder enclosing a notice to deliver all accounting books and records of Substar and a request to complete a ROCAP, by no later than 27 August 2020. The Liquidators did not receive a response;(l)on 24 August 2020, the Liquidators engaged repossession agents to attend upon and recover three vehicles registered in Substar’s name that had been located at the Scala Family Residence. Mr Delaney received a further telephone call from the Shareholder advising that he was working on a plan which would have the effect of setting aside the liquidation and that his solicitor, Mr Joseph Cianfrini of JNC Legal, would be in contact with the Liquidators shortly;(m)on 25 August 2020, Mr Pattinson sent text messages to the Director and the Shareholder’s two mobile numbers requesting they call the Liquidators and engage in the process;(n)on the same date, having not received any subsequent correspondence, Mr Pattinson contacted Mr Cianfrini to obtain an understanding of whether he was acting for the Director and further requested that he instruct his client to attend upon our offices for a meeting. Mr Pattinson also requested Mr Cianfrini remind his client of its outstanding requirements to provide certain information to assist the Liquidators with the progression of the liquidation, including the ROCAP and books and records. Mr Cianfrini advised Mr Pattinson with words to the effect that:he had not yet received instruction in this matter from the Director or [the Shareholder] but had acted for [the Shareholder] Leopold Scala in the past and would contact them and revert in due course;(o)on the same date, Mr Delaney sent an email to Mr Cianfrini setting out the Liquidators’ understanding of the telephone conversation and information that had been requested, providing a deadline of 4 September 2020 for provision of a response from the Director; (p)on 3 September 2020, having not received any response from Mr Cianfrini or the Director, Mr Pattinson of my staff contacted Mr Cianfrini via telephone seeking an update. Mr Cianfrini advised Mr Pattinson words to the effect that ‘his client required an additional week to furnish the information requested’. Mr Pattinson agreed to provide an extension to 11 September 2020;(q)on 4 September 2020, the Liquidators sent a letter to Mr Cianfrini which confirmed their acceptance of the extension request;(r)on 11 September 2020, Mr Cianfrini contacted the Liquidators and advised Mr Delaney words to the effect that ‘the Director and [the Shareholder] were available to attend upon [the Liquidators’] offices later that same date’. Messrs Pattinson, Delaney and Lobb subsequently met with the Director, the Shareholder and Mr Cianfrini that same day. At the meeting, the Liquidators provided the Director with a copy of the documentation previously sent via registered mail on 6 August 2020 and obtained a contact email address from the Director. At the meeting, the parties discussed:(i)the history and financial position of Substar, including the Liquidators’ findings from its enquiries to date;(ii)the importance of the Director’s assistance with expeditious completion of the ROCAP and provision of any books and records that were in his possession. In this regard, it is noted that the Director advised that, prior to making further enquiries, that to the best of his knowledge the Company did not have any books and records; had never prepared any financial records given he did not believe it was required to do so; and, he could not recall the party or parties that had acted as settlement agent for the real properties registered in the name of Substar;(iii)the current and anticipated costs of the liquidation process. In this regard, it is noted that Mr Pattinson explained to the Director and Shareholder that the Liquidators had been required to commit more time and cost than what would typically have been incurred in a liquidation of this nature due to the lack of engagement and assistance provided by the Director and Shareholder to date. Mr Pattinson stressed that their assistance in the provision of timely information and responses to the Liquidators’ requests would reduce any further time and cost; (iv)the Director’s view that all assets registered in the name of Substar were assets of the Trust;(v)the possibility that Substar had been rendered a bare trustee by virtue of the commencement of the liquidation; and(vi)the information that the Liquidators required from the Director to enable the Liquidators to make a determination on how the liquidation of Substar could progress;(s)on 15 September 2020, Mr Pattinson sent Mr Cianfrini and the Director an email containing:(i)information requested by the Director at the meeting; and (ii)a summary of his understanding of the discussions at that meeting and the agreement reached with respect to a deadline for provision of a completed ROCAP, books and records and provision of the information pertaining to a proposal that would be made by the Director;(t)on 18 September 2020, Mr Pattinson called Mr Cianfrini to provide an update on a material change to the total claims received in the liquidation and also to request an update on the progress of his client’s outstanding tasks. Mr Cianfrini discussed the proposal that his client was contemplating and also requested an extension for provision of the outstanding documentation. This extension request was granted to a new deadline of 25 September 2020;(u)on 24 September 2020, Mr Pattinson called Mr Cianfrini to provide a further update on the Liquidators’ estimated claims and to seek an update in respect of the Director’s response to the Liquidators’ requests. Mr Cianfrini discussed his client’s difficulties with completing the ROCAP and books and records listing and Mr Pattinson suggested that he get his client, the Director, to arrange a time to meet with the Liquidators’ staff at their offices, where they could assist him with its completion by answering any queries that were forthcoming. Mr Cianfrini also explained the high-level proposal his client was intending to put forward to the Liquidators to address Substar’s claims and liquidation costs. Mr Pattinson requested that Mr Cianfrini make the proposal in writing and noted that the proposal would only be capable of acceptance if the Director was able to address his outstanding administrative requirement (i.e. ROCAP, books and records listing) and provide information to satisfy the Liquidators that the assets registered in the name of Substar were assets of the Trust;(v)on 25 September 2020, Mr Cianfrini sent a letter addressed to Mr Pattinson via email setting out the proposal discussed in the telephone call the previous day. The letter also included the Director’s request for a meeting with the Liquidators on 30 September 2020, to assist him with addressing his outstanding administrative tasks;(w)on the same date, Mr Pattinson sent an email to Mr Cianfrini and the Director advising that the Liquidators were willing to accommodate the Director’s meeting request and would respond more formally to the Director’s proposal, following completion of the Director’s outstanding administrative tasks;(x)on 29 September 2020, the Director attended upon the offices of the Liquidators where he completed the ROCAP and books and records listing, with the assistance of Mr Delaney and Mr Lobb. The Liquidators noted that the Director has acknowledged that he is not in possession of any books and records;(y)on 30 September 2020, Mr Bredenkamp sent a letter to Mr Cianfrini and the Director which explained that the proposal that they had submitted on 25 September 2020 was not in a form that enabled the Liquidators to make a determination on whether the Liquidators could accept same. In his request, Mr Bredenkamp set out further information that the Liquidators required and requested the Director submit a revised proposal by no later than close of business on 7 October 2020. No response has been forthcoming to date;(z)on 15 October 2020, Mr Pattinson called Mr Cianfrini for an update on the status of his client’s revised proposal that addressed the outstanding matters set out in Mr Bredenkamp’s letter dated 30 September 2020. Mr Cianfrini advised Mr Pattinson with words to the effect that:he had not read the letter but that it was his understanding the Director was progressing his efforts to gather funding to satisfy Substar’s debts and that he would revert once he had considered the letter and received instruction from his client;(aa)later that same date, Mr Lobb sent the Director an email which referred to the discussion with Mr Cianfrini earlier that same date and noted the deadline to respond to the Liquidators’ letter dated 30 September 2020 had passed. The email requested that the Director address the outstanding matters in this letter by no later than 21 October 2020;(bb)on 20 October 2020, Mr Pattinson received a telephone call from Mr Cianfrini during which Mr Cianfrini advised Mr Pattinson words to the effect that: the Director was unable to address all the matters in the Liquidators’ letter of 30 September 2020 and that the Director had been unable to secure the requisite finance to meet the Substar’s debts and liquidation costs. Mr Cianfrini further advised Mr Pattinson in words to the effect that his client understood an application would likely be required to progress the matter and that his client was supportive of this approach. Mr Cianfrini requested that given the quantum of Substar’s outstanding debts and liquidation costs were substantially less than what the assets were likely to be realised for, his client had requested that the Liquidators engage with the Director during the course of their realisation process (if the orders sought were received) and prioritise the realisation of certain assets that the Director deems to be non-core when seeking to generate proceeds required to satisfy the outstanding claims and liquidation costs. Mr Cianfrini advised Mr Pattinson in words to the effect that:following satisfaction of the debt, his client would like to have the liquidation set aside and legal title in any residual assets that the Liquidators were not required to realise upon should remain in the name of the Company. Mr Pattinson advised Mr Cianfrini that in first instance, the Liquidators would likely proceed by marketing all assets for sale concurrently but would engage with the Director during the realisation process given his apparent interest in the residual equity. Mr Pattinson acknowledged the Director’s desire with respect to maintenance of Substar and noted the Liquidators would need to consider, with the assistance of its legal counsel, the legal mechanism by which this goal could be achieved. Mr Pattinson noted that a determination of whether the assets were beneficially owned by the Trust was still yet to be made and that the Liquidators were continuing to make enquiries into this matter in the absence of books and records that confirmed the same. Mr Cianfrini noted that his client had recovered a recent rate notice from the City of Canning which he believed would assist in the Liquidators’ determination and noted that he would send this to the Liquidators later that day;(cc)on 21 October 2020, Mr Pattinson received a telephone call from Mr Cianfrini during which Mr Cianfrini advised in words to the effect: that following their discussion of 20 October 2020, he had sought instructions from his client who had now advised him that he did not require Substar to remain as corporate trustee of the Trust and that he now had the belief that he would be able to secure sufficient external funding to satisfy [Substar’s] debts and liquidation costs in full. Mr Cianfrini advised that as a consequence, the Liquidators would not need to realise upon the assets registered in the name of Substar and would only need to clarify what amount was required to satisfy [Substar’s] debts and liquidation costs’. Mr Pattinson advised Mr Cianfrini that the Liquidators intended to proceed with filing this application, but would include the content of their discussion in the affidavit to be submitted to the Court. Mr Pattinson enquired as to the timing of receipt of funding. Mr Cianfrini advised that his client was yet to receive confirmation but anticipated that it would be obtained prior to completion of a formal dividend distribution process by the Liquidators, which he understood would take approximately two months to complete;(dd)on 22 October 2020, Mr Saul Davies of Taylor Smart Lawyers (TSL), a law firm that had assisted Substar with real property and settlement advice, telephoned Mr Pattinson to respond to his earlier requests of 15 October 2020 and 20 October 2020 for documentation pertaining to settlement of the three real properties registered in the name of Substar. Mr Davies advised Mr Pattinson in words to the effect that:TSL had located the requested settlement documentation and it was his view that this documentation clearly shows that at the time of each acquisition, there was intent that these properties were to be beneficially held by multiple trusts. Mr Davies advised that given his view the documentation pertained to Trust assets, it was his preference that prior to providing the settlement documentation to the Liquidators, TSL first receive consent from the Director and/or the Shareholder to release the information requested by the Liquidators. Later that same date, Mr Pattinson sent an email to Mr Cianfrini, copying the Director and Mr Davies to the email correspondence, setting out his understanding of his discussion with Mr Davies earlier that date and requesting Mr Cianfrini instruct TSL to release the information sought by the Liquidators; and (ee)on 27 October 2020, Mr Cianfrini returned Mr Pattinson’s telephone call from earlier that same date and advised in words to the effect that ‘he was still awaiting instruction from his client.’ Mr Pattinson advised Mr Cianfrini that it was incumbent for the Liquidators to expeditiously proceed with the application they had previously discussed and accordingly the Liquidators intended to file the following day, being 28 October 2020. Mr Pattinson noted that were the Liquidators to subsequently receive the information requested from TSL prior to the hearing date, they would file this documentation with the Court, as was in fact done on 27 November 2020 when the supplementary affidavit was filed.