Dust Diseases Tribunal
of New South Wales
CITATION: (Re: Singh) Stevedoring Finance Committee v Patrick Operations Pty Limited & Anor [2004] NSWDDT 22 PARTIES: Stevedoring Industry Finance Committee
Patrick Operations Pty Limited
Anshun Pty LimitedMATTER NUMBER(S): 102 of 2003/1 JUDGMENT OF: Walker J at 1 CATCHWORDS: :- LEGISLATION CITED: CASES CITED: DATES OF HEARING: 13/07/2004 DATE OF JUDGMENT:
08/20/2004LEGAL REPRESENTATIVES:
CROSS CLAIMANT: Mr Scotting instructed by Blake Dawson Waldron
CROSS DEFENDANT: Mr Jobson instructed by McCulloch and Buggy
JUDGMENT:
BACKGROUND.
(1) In the primary proceedings Jack Singh sued the Stevedoring Industry Finance Committee (a body established by the Australian Stevedoring Industry Authority pursuant to the provisions of the Stevedoring Industry Act) on the 23rd of October 2000 for damages for contracting asbestosis and asbestos related pleural disease caused by the Committees negligence and breach of duty of care associated with his repeated exposure in his work to the inhalation of asbestos dust and fibres.
(2) On the 23rd of October 2003 consent judgement was entered in favour of the plaintiff against the cross claimant in the sum of $190,000 damages plus $30,000 costs.
(3) On 24th of December 2003, by leave of the court, the Committee issued a cross-claim against the cross defendants pursuant to S 5 (1) (a) of the Law Reform (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1946 alleging both cross defendants owed a duty of care to the plaintiff; that the plaintiff's injuries were foreseeable and that in consequence of the cross defendants breach of duty the plaintiff suffered his damage.
The cross defendants, in submissions, raise only three issues namely:
(a). The settlement was unreasonable because had the matter proceeded to judgement the plaintiff would only have received a verdict of about $100,000.
(b) the amount of any apportionment under S 5 (1) (a) of the Law Reform (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1945.
(c). The plaintiff and the cross-claimant having failed to make application to the Dust Diseases Board for medical expenses should not be allowed to include those expenses foregone in the verdict.
A. Was the verdict reasonable?
In Bitumen & Oil Refineries (Australia) Pty Ltd v Commissioner For Government Transport (1954-19 55) 92 CLR 200 at 213 the High Court said
“ the court is required to find what is just and equitable as an amount of contribution having regard to the extent of the responsibility for the damage of the tortfeasor against whom the claim is made. There does not seem to be any valid reason why that tortfeasor may not say to the tortfeasor making the claim, if he has improvidently agreed to pay too large an amount or by unreasonable or negligent conduct in litigation has incurred or submitted to an excessive verdict, that the excess is due to his fault and not to that of the tortfeasor resisting the claim. It would be a matter for the court to consider under the heading of "just and equitable"
Mr Jobson, for both cross defendants, submits that the verdict was not just and…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read (Re: Singh) Stevedoring Finance Committee v Patrick Operatio... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2004] NSWDDT 22
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issues revolved around the interpretation of the stevedoring contract and whether Patrick Operations had indeed breached its terms. The Committee argued that the contract explicitly outlined the obligations of Patrick Operations, which included providing efficient and timely stevedoring services. They claimed that Patrick Operations' failure to meet these obligations resulted in substantial financial losses. Conversely, Patrick Operations contended that any delays were due to factors beyond their control and that they had fulfilled their contractual duties.
The court examined the terms of the stevedoring contract and the evidence presented by both parties. It assessed whether the delays experienced were directly attributable to Patrick Operations' failure to provide adequate services. The court considered various factors, including the nature of the stevedoring operations, the circumstances leading to the delays, and the contractual obligations. Ultimately, the court found that Patrick Operations had indeed breached the contract, as the delays were a direct result of their failure to provide the required services. Consequently, the court awarded damages to the Stevedoring Finance Committee for the losses incurred due to the breach.