Re Setiawan and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs

Link copied
Case Copied 14 min read

DECISION AND REASONS FOR DECISION [2002] AATA 260

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL      )

)          No N2000/1563

GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE  DIVISION       )          
           Re      YURIKA ANGGRAENI SETIAWAN       
  Applicant
           And    MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS          
  Respondent

DECISION

Tribunal       The Hon. R N J Purvis Q.C., Deputy President

Date18 April 2002 

PlaceSydney

Decision      The Tribunal sets aside the decision under review and remits the matter to the Respondent for further consideration in accordance with the Tribunal's reasons for decision.  
  ..............................................
  The Hon. R N J Purvis Q.C.
  Deputy President
CATCHWORDS
IMMIGRATION – business skills (migrant) (class AD) visa – cancellation of Applicant's father's primary business skills visa – cancellation of Applicant's visa as secondary visa holder – extreme hardship – meaning of extreme hardship – subjective test

Migration Act 1958 – section 134

Man Ki Kim v Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (1995) 37 ALD 481
Siwei Wang v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [2000] AATA 961
Ashok Kumar v Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (1997) 50 ALD 488

REASONS FOR DECISION

The Hon. R N J Purvis Q.C., Deputy President            

the application

  1. This is an application made by Ms Yurika Anggraeni Setiawan ("the Applicant") seeking review of a decision by a delegate of the Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs ("the Respondent") made on 5 October 2000, cancelling the Applicant's business visa pursuant to section 134(4) of the Migration Act 1958 ("the Act"). The visa so issued to the Applicant was as a "member of the family unit" of her father, he having at one time satisfied the relevant requirements referrable to the establishment of an eligible business in Australia. The Primary Business Skills Visa of the father was cancelled pursuant to section 134(1) of the Act, the Respondent then by statute being required to cancel the secondary visa of the Applicant. The later cancellation however, is subject to the provisions of subsections 134(4) and (5) of the Act.

  2. The Applicant was given notice of the intention of the Respondent to cancel her visa but after considering submissions made by her and on her behalf the reviewable decision was made.
    the hearing

  3. At the hearing of this application the Applicant appeared on her own behalf, the Respondent was represented by Mr Paul Hardman, solicitor of Clayton Utz Lawyers.

  4. The documents lodged by the Respondent with the Tribunal pursuant to section 37 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 were admitted into evidence and were marked T1 to T22. Other written material was also tendered as exhibits and marked accordingly, namely:
    Exhibit No  Description                   Date         
    A        Applicant's letter      30 January 2001     
    B        Letter from Jeanette Ramos (TAFE teacher)     19 November 2001 

  5. Respondent's Movement Records of Applicant            

  6. Affidavit of Belinda Jayne Abey     7 September 2001  

  7. Letter from Applicant to the Tribunal       19 December 2001 

Oral evidence was given by the Applicant upon which she was cross-examined.
the issues

  1. As they are stated by the Respondent the issues before the Tribunal are:

    Given that:

  • on 5 October 2000 the Respondent cancelled the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Re Setiawan and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural A... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2002] AATA 260
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Re Setiawan and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs involved an Indonesian national, born on January 31, 1982, who arrived in Australia on October 9, 1997, under a Business Skills (Migrant) (Class AD) Visa. The dispute arose when the Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs issued a notice of intention to cancel the primary visa of the Applicant's father on June 7, 2000, and subsequently cancelled the Applicant's secondary visa on October 6, 2000. The Applicant, now studying at Sydney TAFE for a diploma in food technology, sought to remain in Australia arguing that she would suffer extreme hardship if deported.

The central legal issues before the court involved the interpretation and application of the concept of "extreme hardship" as it related to the cancellation of the Applicant's visa. The court had to determine whether the evidence presented demonstrated that the Applicant would face extreme hardship if required to return to Indonesia, thus warranting a reprieve from the visa cancellation.

In deciding the case, the court considered the evidence of the Applicant, which included her testimony regarding her education and her ties to Australia. The court also noted that the Applicant's parents had financially supported her in Australia and would likely continue to do so if she returned to Indonesia. However, the court held that while the Applicant's situation showed inconvenience and some hardship, it did not amount to the extreme hardship required to prevent the visa cancellation. The court was satisfied that the Applicant could complete her studies in Indonesia, albeit with some additional costs and inconvenience. The court further noted that the Applicant had not spent most of her childhood in Australia and had maintained regular contact with Indonesia.

The court concluded that the Applicant had not demonstrated extreme hardship within the meaning of the relevant legislation. The evidence did not support the conclusion that the Applicant would face insurmountable difficulties if required to return to Indonesia and complete her education there. Consequently, the Tribunal dismissed the Applicant's appeal against the visa cancellation.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

In Ashok Kumar v Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (1997) 50 ALD 488 it was said that "the proper application of [a provision of the Migration (1993)Regulations, which contained within it the words "extreme hardship"] requires a focused consideration of the situation of the Applicant "at the relevant date". The relevant date in the present application is as at the date of the hearing.the relevant facts The Applicant was born in Indonesia on 31 January 1982. She arrived in Australia with her family on 9 October 1997 on a Business Skills (Migrant) (Class AD) Visa, since which time she has completed her secondary education and is now studying at Sydney TAFE seeking to graduate with a diploma in food technology. On 7 June 2000 the Respondent issued a notice of intention to cancel the business skills visa of the Applicant due to the failure of her father to comply with the conditions of his visa. The secondary visa held by the Applicant was in fact cancelled on 6 October 2000 consequent upon the primary visa held by her father also being cancelled on that date, the latter by reason of the Respondent being satisfied that the father had failed to satisfy the relevant criteria required by section 134 of the Act. The Applicant's father and mother returned to Indonesia leaving the Applicant and her brother in Australia. The brother is engaged in an engineering degree course at Sydney University. The Applicant and her brother are together residing in a property owned by her parents at Maroubra, a suburb of Sydney. Apart from her earnings as a casual waitress, the Applicant has been financially supported by her parents, who have also funded the costs of airline tickets used by her in travel to and from Indonesia. In support of her application to remain in Australia, the Applicant in a letter of 30 January 2001 said (Exhibit A):"…Now, I am studying Food technology at Sydney TAFE. In a year time, I will be graduation with diploma in Food technology. But if I were to go back for good, I had to start my tertiary education all over again. Furthermore, they don't have a course in food technology and since I did not high school in Indonesia, I would have to repeat my high school before being accepted in university. If I were to graduate here, I wouldn't have a job back at my country. Moreover, I had much settle down in Australia then [sic] in Indonesia as I had spent my most memorable time here…" The disadvantages the Applicant claimed she would experience on cancellation of her visa were said by her in January 2001 to be:"… The hearing of this application commenced on the 27 September 2001 at which time the Applicant gave evidence to the effect that she was then in the final year of her two-year food technology course, the same concluding in December 2001. She was confident she would sit for her final exams in December 2001 "at the latest". On graduation the Applicant hoped to obtain a position as a laboratory assistant engaged in food testing and control of food products. She said she needed to complete her course and gain her diploma before she could obtain employment in Indonesia.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

As earlier mentioned the Applicant's parents have assisted her financially whilst she has been undertaking her diploma course. She was unable to say with any degree of certainty whether they would further assist if she undertook the study in Indonesia. On the basis of the evidence before it, the Tribunal is however satisfied that such financial assistance would be forthcoming. The parents, apart from their real estate interests in Australia, own property in Indonesia and according to the Applicant "are quite well off".submissions and decision It was submitted on behalf of the Respondent that the Applicant being required to show that she would suffer extreme hardship by reason of cancellation of the visa, the facts and circumstances disclosed by the evidence whilst showing inconvenience and some hardship did not "on any analysis show extreme hardship". The Tribunal's attention was drawn to the fact of the Applicant being able to undergo a course in Indonesia, which whilst resulting in some inconvenience and additional cost and the need to undergo additional courses could nevertheless be completed within a timeframe similar to that required in order for her to complete her course in Australia. Attention was further drawn to the attempts that had been made to alleviate the Applicant's hardship and the opportunities afforded her to resolve her situation. It is true, as was further submitted on behalf of the Respondent, that a number of the bassi upon which she initially sought relief were not relevant at the time the application came on for hearing. The Applicant had clearly not spent most of her childhood in Australia and even whilst living here had regularly returned to Indonesia. Her parents reside in that country and even be there racial tension, this has not precluded her from travelling to and from her country of birth on a regular basis. The Applicant is 20 years of age. She is presently living in Australia with her brother in a property owned by her parents. She has completed two years of a diploma course in food technology and has now one subject remaining in order to obtain her diploma. Tuition in that subject does not commence until May 2002 and would extend over a period of approximately 18 weeks. The Tribunal was not informed as to when an examination, if any, might be held. Nevertheless, in the event of the Applicant's visa being cancelled she would be required to return to Indonesia and not be able to complete her course in Australia. On the assumption that she be accepted as a Bachelor student, she would be able to undergo a course of study, more extensive than would otherwise be required, in Indonesia, which seemingly would gain her the relevant credit to obtain her diploma. However, enrolment in such a course in Indonesia would entail admission and tuition fees at a cost beyond what she would be required to pay for tuition only in Australia. It would appear on the evidence that the Applicant has successfully completed the course that she has been required to undertake to this date. The evidence of the acting head teacher at TAFE is that she "is a polite and capable student".

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established