Re Saba and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection

Link copied
Case Copied 26 min read

[2014] AATA 579 

Division GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION

File Number

2013/4962

Re

Hanan Saba

APPLICANT

And

Minister for Immigration and Border Protection

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

Senior Member P W Taylor SC

Date 21 August 2014
Place Sydney

The decision under review is set aside.  I determine that Ms Saba had a close and continuing association with Australia during the whole of the 4 year period preceding her application for citizenship in September 1998.  I also determine that Ms Saba was, and is, likely to maintain a close and continuing association with Australia. 

I remit Ms Saba’s application to the Minister to be determined in accordance with these reasons and decision.

........................[sgd]................................................

Senior Member P W Taylor SC

CATCHWORDS

CITIZENSHIP - Citizenship application - Close and continuing association with Australia - Decision set aside - Decision remitted to Minister for redetermination

LEGISLATION

Australian Citizenship Act 1948 (Cth), ss 13(1), 13(1A), 13(4)(b)(iv)

Australian Citizenship Act 2007 (Cth), ss 21(2)(g), 22(1)(a), 22(1)(c), 22(9), 24(5)

SECONDARY MATERIALS

Australian Citizenship Instructions, s 5.18

REASONS FOR DECISION

Senior Member P W Taylor SC

21 August 2014

  1. Ms Hanan Saba is a permanent resident of Australia, currently residing in Qatar. She applied for Australian citizenship on 24 September 2013. 

  2. Ms Saba cannot satisfy the ordinary “general residence requirement” in section 22(1) of the Australian Citizenship Act 2007 (the 2007 Act).  There is an additional residency discretion available to the Minister pursuant to s 22(9) of the 2007 Act.  That discretion depends on satisfaction that Ms Saba had a close and continuing association with Australia.  The delegate was not so satisfied, and refused her application. 

  3. I have come to a different view, and I am satisfied that Ms Saba had the required close and continuing relationship with Australia.  I am also satisfied that she continues to have such a relationship.  The considerations and reasons that have led to my satisfaction are detailed below.

    MS SABA’S CITIZENSHIP AND CIRCUMSTANCES

  4. Ms Saba holds a Lebanese passport. She was born and educated in Lebanon. She lived there until just after August 1998. That was when she married her Australian citizen husband. In September 1998 she left Lebanon and came to live in Australia. They lived in the house he had purchased in 1996. Ms Saba’s parents in law lived with them. In December 1999 Ms Saba delivered her first child, a now 15 year old daughter. In June 2000 Ms Saba obtained her first permanent resident visa. (Her permanent residence status has since been renewed twice – in 2004 and 2009). In February 2001, Ms Saba gave birth to her second daughter.

  5. Things changed in early 2001. Ms Saba’s husband had been working in Australia, for some time as an employee of a very well-known Australian infrastructure and development company, but subsequently as a self-employed computer consultant. A job opportunity arose for him in Dubai, which he accepted.  Ms Saba, and their two young children accompanied him. In the years since then, Ms Saba’s husband’s expertise, professional…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Re Saba and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] AATA 579
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This case involves a judicial review of a decision by the Minister for Immigration and Border Protection, with the applicant being Ms Saba. The dispute centers on whether Ms Saba has maintained a close and continuing association with Australia, which is a requirement for her application for Australian citizenship under section 21(2)(g) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth). The court was tasked with determining whether Ms Saba's ties to Australia were sufficient to satisfy this criterion, given her extended absence from the country and her current residence in Dubai.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether Ms Saba had indeed maintained a close and continuing association with Australia during the four years preceding her citizenship application in 1998. The court examined various factors to assess the strength of her ties, including her family connections, property ownership, educational pursuits, and her husband's status as an Australian citizen. The court also had to consider the implications of her extended stay abroad due to her husband's professional opportunities in Dubai.

The court found that despite Ms Saba's lengthy absence from Australia, several factors indicated a strong and continuous association with the country. These included her establishment of a family home in Australia, her acquisition of permanent residency, her husband's Australian citizenship, and the birth of their children in Australia. Additionally, Ms Saba's ongoing participation in Australian community activities, her educational pursuits in an Australian university, and her intention to return to Australia with her family were all significant. The court concluded that these factors collectively demonstrated a close and continuing association with Australia, satisfying the statutory requirement for citizenship.

As a result of the court's findings, the decision under review was set aside, and the matter was remitted to the Minister for reconsideration in light of the court's determinations. The court held that Ms Saba had maintained a close and continuing association with Australia throughout her absence and was likely to continue doing so upon her return.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Evidence of active participation Australian community-based activities organisations: Ms Saba holds a New South Wales drivers licence. It expires in January 2015, and I would surmise that it was probably issued during her visit to Australian between December 2009 and January 2010. Ms Saba’s parents in law are active members of the Campbelltown Arabic Baptist Church. There is a reference letter of commendation dated 26 November 2013 from the pastor of the Campbelltown Arabic Baptist Church. The letter attests to the fact that Miss Saba and her husband attended the church between 1999 and 2001, when they lived in Australia. Since then they have continued their connection with the church, and attend church services, participate in church activities and meet with church members whenever they have been in Australia on their periodic return visits. Ms Saba said that she and her husband had contributed funds towards the building of a new church. On 30 May 2012 Ms Saba was offered a place in a post graduate “Master of Sustainability Science” course conducted by the University of Southern Queensland. She commenced that course in late 2012. The course is delivered online; it involves weekly assignments and significant interaction with fellow students, as well as the subject teachers. Ms Saba had completed 4 units by September 2013, and had completed, or substantially completed, another unit by the time of the Tribunal hearing. Ms Saba has only 3 further units to undertake in order to complete the Masters course. Ms Saba explained that despite the original undergraduate degree she obtained in Lebanon, she had chosen to pursue her Masters course in an Australian University. She explained that the course was not just concerned with pure scientific discipline. There were substantial issues of regulation and compliance that directly impacted upon the general field of sustainability issues. These kinds of regulatory and compliance issues required knowledge of the relevant jurisdictional legislative regime. She intended to return to Australia and apply her degree qualifications here. She explained that the course she had commenced at the University of Southern Queensland, with its emphasis on the Australian legislative and regulatory regime, would be of little or no practical benefit to her in other jurisdictions. Her contention was that her choice of University was yet another indication of her association with Australia.IMPRESSION FROM THE INCLUSIVE FACTORS Ms Saba’s limited period of Australian residence does cast doubt on the justification for a conclusion that she has a “close and continuing association with Australia”. But there is also no doubt that she migrated here in 1998 and established her matrimonial home here, with her new husband and his family. Her first two children were born here, before her departure. The family’s departure in 2001 was a fortuity, to pursue challenges and success in her husband’s field of expertise. It has resulted in a prolonged absence because of the success he has enjoyed. But Ms Saba has maintained the ties with her husband’s Australian family, maintained Australia as the only place where she owns significant assets, aspires to return to Australia with the family in the near future, and has set about obtaining high level educational qualifications that she hopes will facilitate her future employment in Australia. My conclusion is that these particular considerations, against the totality of the matters I have taken into account, sufficiently evidence the reality of the “close and continuing association with Australia” that Ms Saba professes to have.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Finally, in relation to the imprecise timing of Ms Saba’s intention to return to Australia with her family, it may be accepted that the intention to which s 21(2)(g) of the 2007 Act refers is one that is to be acted upon within a reasonably short time frame. Given that Ms Saba’s eldest daughter is now almost 15, and that Ms Saba’s husband is already taking steps to facilitate the family’s return to Australia, I am satisfied that she is likely to reside in Australia in the near future in any event. But I also note that the likelihood of an applicant residing in Australia is only one of three disjunctive criteria in s 21(2)(g) of the 2007 Act. The third criterion, which I also regard as satisfied, is the likelihood that Ms Saba will maintain a close and continuing relationship with Australia. I am of that view because I am satisfied she has maintained such an association during the period of her overseas absence. The factors that have contributed to that association, principally her family and property connections with Australia, will continue and, upon the family’s return to Australia, likely strengthen.DECISION The decision under review is set aside. I determine that Ms Saba had a close and continuing association with Australia during the whole of the 4 year period preceding her application for citizenship in September 1998. I also determine that Ms Saba was, and is, likely to maintain a close and continuing association with Australia. In the light of those determinations, I remit Ms Saba’s application to the Minister to be determined in accordance with these reasons and decision.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Pre absence migration and home-making: Ms Saba left her parents and homeland after her marriage in 1998, came to Australia, lived with her husband, and established their family home. She took out permanent residence less than two years after her migration. But for the work opportunities her husband took up in Dubai, she would have continued to live in Australia with her husband and to raise their children within the extended family she had joined. Australian citizen spouse: Ms Saba’s husband is an Australian citizen. He was an Australian resident when they married in Lebanon in 1998. They returned and spent the first two and a half years of their married life here. He left Australia only to pursue opportunities within his chosen area of training and expertise. His evidence in the Tribunal proceedings is that he intends to return to Australia, with Ms Saba and his children, and is taking steps to facilitate that future return. Australian citizen children: Ms Saba’s three children are Australian citizens and hold Australian passports. All of them were born in Australia – two of them before her departure to Dubai in April 2001. Her third child, a 12-year-old son, was born in May 2002 during an approximately 2 month period when she returned to Australia. It was a matter of deliberate decision on her part that, like his two elder siblings, he should be born in Australia – in fact at the same hospital, and delivered by the same obstetrician. The three children are currently being educated in an American School in Qatar. The school offers the International Baccalaureate program curriculum. Ms Saba explained that she and her husband had intentionally chosen such a school, in preference to another international school. This was because the International Baccalaureate was recognised in Australia as satisfying academic entrance qualifications for many Australian Universities. She said that she and her husband both aspire to have the children undertake their tertiary education in Australia. This is the primary focus of their future plans, and underlies their intention to return to Australia. That aspiration for the children’s tertiary education is entirely realistic, given not only the fact of Ms Saba and her husband’s own abilities and qualifications but also their own involvement with Australian Universities. Ms Saba has an undergraduate degree in a combined agriculture and engineering discipline from the American University in Beirut. In 2012 she started a postgraduate Masters Degree Course at the University of Southern Queensland. In December 2005, during the early part of their residence in Dubai, Ms Saba’s husband obtained his PhD from the University of Wollongong. Extended family in Australia: Ms Saba has two siblings. Her parents and her sister still live in Lebanon. She visits them periodically, usually only for a few days. Her brother, who is married and has three children, is her next door neighbour in Qatar. In contrast, Ms Saba’s husband's parents, siblings, nieces and nephews all live in Australia, and are Australian citizens. Ms Saba’s evidence made clear that she regards herself, and their children, as an integral part of her husband’s extended Australian family. Throughout her evidence, with disarmingly unselfconscious literal inaccuracy and affectionate sincerity, she repeatedly referred to her parents in law as if they were her own actual mother and father. She referred to her two sisters in law, who both live in suburban Sydney with their families, as her sisters.