\ /G
a U D ~ ~ ~ N T NO. ..-..,. B-../..-.o~-e
IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA )
GENERAL DIVISION 1 No. NB 1086 of BANKRrJPTc Y DISTRICT OF THE STATE OF) 1990
NEW SOUTH WALES 1
RE: RODNEY STBVENTON
BankruptEX PARTE: DAVID EARNEST WILLIS BLACRWEL'L as trustee of the bankrupt estate of Rodney Steventon Applicant AND: JOHN HAAIT Respondent
CORM: WILCOX J PLACE : SYDNEY DATE : 3 MAFICH 1992
EXTEHPORE REASONS FOR JUDGMENT
WILCOX J: This is an application by David Blackwell, as
said sum of $75,000.
trustee of the bankrupt estate of Rodney Steventon, firstly, for a declaration that the payment of the sum of $75,000 by the direction of the bankrupt to the respondent, John Hanna Maait on or about 17 March 1989 is void as against the applicant pursuant to s.122 of the Bankru~tcv Act 1966; and, secondly, for an order that Mr Maait pay to the applicant the
Although there has been a considerable amount of material put before the Court, the critical evidence is both short and uncontested. Rodney Steventon was made bankrupt on 19 June 1990 on the petition of one Angela Bell Needham. The act of bankruptcy on which MS Needham relied was the failure of the debtor to comply on or before 4 January 1989 with a bankruptcy notice issued by one Walter Dowling. It is agreed between the present parties that the debt to Mr Dowling was paid out at a later date. This date was well after 16 March 1989, the apparent date of the payment of the $75,000 in issue in the present proceeding.
The transaction between Mr Steventon and Mr Haait arises out of a loan made by Mr Maait to Mr Steventon in 1987. There was a considerable amount of detail about the circumstances of the loan and the representations which were made by Mr Steventon to Mr Maait when the transaction was entered into. But is not necessary for me to go to that evidence. It sufficient to say that a sum of $56,000 was loaned and this bore interest. Mr Steventon defaulted in his compliance with the agreed arrangements and, on 17 June 1988,
Mr Maait commenced a proceeding to recover the debt. He
obtained judgment on 19 August 1988.
Mr Maait issued a bankruptcy notice in relation to his judgment debt. It was served upon Mr Steventon on 2 November 1988. The bankruptcy notice required compliance within 14 days, but there was no compliance. Consequently, Mr Steventon committed an act of bankruptcy on 16 November 1988.
Mr Maait then caused a petition to be issued. It was served
on 15 December 1988 and was, therefore, pending when Mr Steventon committed a second act of bankruptcy: the failure to comply with the bankruptcy notice issued by Mr Dowling. Mr Maait's petition was dismissed by consent on 16 March 1989, the impugned payment of $75,000 being made at about that time and as a condition of Mr Maait's consent to the…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Re Rodney Steventon; Ex Parte David Ernest Willis Blackwell... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1992] FCA 157
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court had to decide whether the payment of $75,000 made by Steventon to Maait was a voidable preference under section 122 of the Bankruptcy Act 1966. Additionally, the court had to determine if the transaction fell within the exception provided in section 122(2) of the Act, which protects a payment made in good faith and for valuable consideration in the ordinary course of business. The key issue was whether the payment could be considered as having been made in the ordinary course of business, given that it was made in the context of pending bankruptcy proceedings and as a condition for the dismissal of a bankruptcy petition.
The court found that the payment was indeed a voidable preference as it gave Maait a preferential treatment over other creditors. The court rejected the argument that the payment was made in the ordinary course of business, noting that it was clearly a transaction carried out with bankruptcy proceedings in view. The court held that the payment could not be considered as a fair transaction that a person might undertake without having any bankruptcy in view. As a result, the court concluded that the exception under section 122(2) of the Act did not apply, and the trustee's application must succeed.
The court ordered that John Maait pay the costs of the application to the trustee, David Blackwell. The trustee was thus entitled to an order in accordance with the terms of the application.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi