Re: Rock Bottom Fashion Market P/L

Link copied
Case Copied 18 min read

IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF QUEENSLAND

Brisbane  Application No.2254 of 1997

Before the Hon. Mr Justice Thomas

[Re:  Rock Bottom Fashion Market P/L]

IN THE MATTER of the Corporations Law

and

IN THE MATTER of ROCK BOTTOM FASHION
  MARKET PTY LTD ACN 010 888 141

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT - THOMAS J.

Judgment delivered 24 April 1997

CATCHWORDS: CORPORATIONS LAW - Winding up by the court -

service of winding up application at registered office - proof of non-delivery ‑ envelope returned with window blacked out, allegedly from wrong address - sufficiency of circumstantial case - service on sole director - service by fax - place of business of director or company

insolvency - failure to comply with statutory demand - whether application should be adjourned pending appeal against judgment giving rise to debt

irregularity in time of service - s.1322 applicable to breach of s.465A and rule 56

Corporations Law ss.220, 465A, 1322 Corporations (Queensland) Rules - 14, 56.

Counsel:M. Gynther for the applicant.

D.J. Innes (director of the respondent Company) for the respondent.          

Solicitors:Sykes Pearson & Miller for the applicant.

Hearing dates:         16 and 18 April 1997

IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF QUEENSLAND

Brisbane  Application No.2254 of 1997

Before the Hon. Mr Justice Thomas

[Re: Rock Bottom Fashion Market P/L]

IN THE MATTER of the Corporations Law

and

IN THE MATTER of ROCK BOTTOM FASHION
  MARKET PTY LTD ACN 010 888 141

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT - THOMAS  J.

Judgment delivered 24 April 1997

This is an application to wind up Rock Bottom Fashion Market Pty Ltd ("Rock Bottom").  The applicant, H R and C E Griffiths Pty Ltd is the former landlord of Rock Bottom. On 16 January 1997 in proceedings before Williams J. it obtained a judgment against Rock Bottom for $3,472.70 and for costs to be taxed. 
          A statutory demand was promptly served for the $3,472.70.  Rock Bottom failed to satisfy the demand within the 21 days or at all.  On 13 February 1997 it caused a notice of appeal to be lodged in respect of the judgment.  No application was brought to set aside the notice of demand.  There has been no attempt to pay or secure the debt.
          The main issues which have been argued are whether the application has been duly served, and whether the company is insolvent.
          The company was represented during proceedings before me by its sole director Mr Donald Innes.

  1. Service

Pursuant to the order of Williams J, Rock Bottom vacated the shop at which it had carried on business, namely shop 2B, Arcadia Walk, Noosa Junction, on 19 January 1997.  The company has not traded since that date. The main activity that seems to have been conducted on its behalf since then has been in the form of protracted disputation with solicitors for various parties, and, according to Mr Innes, some so far unsuccessful attempts to realise upon shop fittings retained by Rock Bottom when it lost possession in January.
          The statutory demand was served on or about 18 January…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Re: Rock Bottom Fashion Market P/L and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1997] QSC 67
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This is an application to wind up Rock Bottom Fashion Market Pty Ltd ("Rock Bottom"). The applicant, H R and C E Griffiths Pty Ltd is the former landlord of Rock Bottom. On 16 January 1997 in proceedings before Williams J. it obtained a judgment against Rock Bottom for $3,472.70 and for costs to be taxed. A statutory demand was promptly served for the $3,472.70. Rock Bottom failed to satisfy the demand within the 21 days or at all. On 13 February 1997 it caused a notice of appeal to be lodged in respect of the judgment. No application was brought to set aside the notice of demand. There has been no attempt to pay or secure the debt.

The main issues which have been argued are whether the application has been duly served, and whether the company is insolvent. The court found that the application has been duly served both by post to the registered office of the company and by facsimile to the fax number of the sole director at the address of the company's place of business. It also found that the company is insolvent. The court found that although the company had filed an appeal against the judgment upon which the statutory demand was based, there was no sufficient reason for adjourning or staying the present winding up proceedings. The court also found that although the application was advertised in the newspaper one day earlier than permitted by the Corporations (Queensland) Rules, this did not amount to an abuse of process or cause substantial injustice. The court made an order as per the draft submitted, with the addition of a declaration that the advertising was not invalid by reason of the contravention of rule 56.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established