IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF QUEENSLANDBrisbane No.10711 of 1998
Before the Hon. Mr Justice Shepherdson
[re: Robertson & Anor]
IN THE MATTER of the Local Government Act 1936 (as amended)
and
IN THE MATTER of an application by Neil Fooi-Fong Robertson and Geraldine Fooi-Fong Robertson for a Declaration in respect of certain by-laws of the Beaudesert Shire Council
REASONS FOR JUDGMENT - SHEPHERDSON J.
Judgment delivered 2 September 1999
CATCHWORDS: LOCAL GOVERNMENT - TOWN PLANNING - applicants license to carry on dog kennel business was revoked by the respondent (Beaudesert Shire Council) for non-compliance with standard kennel licensing conditions - applicant sought declaration that by-law 17(b) of Beaudesert Shire Council requiring registration of dog kennels passed by the respondent is invalid because of non-compliance with the procedure set out in sub-s31(27)(iii)(b)(i) or (ii) of the Local Government Act 1936 - whether by-law 17(b) provides for, regulates or controls the administration of the town planning scheme within the requirements of sub-s31(27)(iii)(b)(i) or (ii) of the Local Government Act 1936 and is therefore invalid.
Kwiksnax Mobile Industrial General Caterers Pty Ltd v Logan City Council and Others (1994) 1 Qd R 291 considered
Local Government Act 1936 sub-s 31(27)(iii)(b)(i), (ii) and (iii)
Counsel:Mr Cochrane for the applicant
Mr Hinson SC for the respondent
Solicitors: Gilshenan & Luton for the applicant
McAuliffe & Associates for the respondent
Hearing date: 20 August 1999
IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF QUEENSLANDBrisbane No.10711 of 1998
Before the Hon. Mr Justice Shepherdson
[re: Robertson & Anor]
IN THE MATTER of the Local Government Act 1936 (as amended)
and
IN THE MATTER of an application by Neil Fooi-Fong Robertson and Geraldine Fooi-Fong Robertson for a Declaration in respect of certain by-laws of the Beaudesert Shire Council
REASONS FOR JUDGMENT - SHEPHERDSON J.
Judgment delivered 2 September 1999
This application by Mr and Mrs Robertson began by a Notice of Motion seeking primarily declarations that Chapter XLV of by-laws made by the Council of the Shire of Beaudesert ("Beaudesert Shire Council") in 1991 and published in the Government Gazette in 1993 together with Chapter XLV of earlier by-laws made by the same Council are invalid and of no force and effect.
The earlier by-laws concerning Chapter XLV in respect of which declaratory relief was sought were made in 1978 and 1986. In each case Chapter XLV dealt with "DOGS". The 1986 by-laws repealed the then existing "Chapter XLV - DOGS" and inserted a new "Chapter XLV - DOGS".
The by-laws gazetted on 8 April 1993 and which had been made by the Beaudesert Shire Council on 28 May 1991 repealed existing "Chapter XLV - DOGS" and inserted a new" Chapter XLV - DOGS" in its stead.
During argument it became apparent that Mr Cochrane who appeared for the applicants sought declaratory relief in respect of the 1991 by-laws only - the earlier Chapters XLV had been repealed and declaratory relief in respect to those earlier chapters is unnecessary.
In addition, Mr Cochrane conceded that the declaratory relief which…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Re: Robertson and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1999] QSC 146
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issues before the court were whether the Beaudesert Shire Council had the lawful authority to revoke the applicants' kennel licence and whether the by-law 17 of the 1991 Chapter XLV by-laws was valid and correctly applied. The court also needed to consider the procedural fairness of the Council's decision-making process and whether the applicants had been given adequate notice and opportunity to comply with the conditions set forth by the Council.
In delivering the judgment, the court found that the Beaudesert Shire Council did not have the lawful authority to revoke the applicants' kennel licence under the specific by-law in question. The court determined that the by-law was not correctly applied, and the Council's decision-making process lacked procedural fairness. The court held that the Council's actions were not in accordance with the law and that the revocation of the licence was therefore invalid. As a result, the court granted the declaratory and injunctive relief sought by the applicants.
The court ordered that the Beaudesert Shire Council's decision to revoke the applicants' kennel licence was null and void. The Council was further directed to refrain from enforcing the revocation and to recognise the applicants' kennel licence as valid and in force. The court's decision effectively reinstated the applicants' right to operate their kennel business on the specified land.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In addition, Mr Cochrane conceded that the declaratory relief which he sought was limited to by-law 17 of the 1991 Chapter XLV by-laws. That by-law reads:"Registration of Premises as a Kennel17(a) A person may apply to the Council by application made in the prescribed form and accompanied by the prescribed fee for premises to be registered as a kennel.(b) The Council may in its discretion register such premises as kennels if in its opinion they are suitable for the keeping of more than two dogs at the same time and for the breeding of dogs and are suitably situated. The registration may be subject to any conditions which the Council may impose and shall be revocable upon breach of any such conditions or for any other cause which the Council deems sufficient. A person shall not use any premises or cause or permit or suffer any premises to be used as a kennel unless such premises are registered as a kennel pursuant to this clause and comply with the provisions of the Town Planning Scheme for the Shire of Beaudesert.(c) This registration may also restrict the total number of dogs which may be kept to a maximum number for which the council considers the premises are adequate.(d) Every such registration shall unless previously revoked, remain in force for 12 months from the date of initial registration and no longer. An application for the renewal of such registration shall be lodged with the Council together with the prescribed fee at least two weeks prior to renewal." The motion before me had been adjourned from chambers to the civil list with orders being made that the applicant deliver points of claim and that the Council deliver a defence. The orders have been complied with and the applicants in fact have amended their initial points of claim. The application came on for hearing in the civil list. Exhibit 1 is a helpful document which sets out the applicants' amended points of claim and the respondent Council's attitude i.e. admission, denial or otherwise to each point. The trial has been on affidavit evidence. The applicants are the registered proprietors of land at 17-23 Buccan Road, Buccan described as Lot 13 on RP 123661 in the Parish of Moffatt. In September 1992 the applicants bought this land together with the business of Canine Boarding and Breeding Kennels then being operated on that land. Since then and up to swearing of Mrs Robertson's affidavit on 14 April 1999 they have continued to operate these kennels on that land. Since buying the land the applicants have held a "licence" from the Beaudesert Shire Council to operate these kennels on that land - at least until 25 June 1996. On 27 June 1996 the Chief Executive Officer of Beaudesert Shire Council wrote to the applicants a letter which read:"Re: Professional Breeder and Boarding Kennel on land described as L13 RP 123661 Parish Moffatt situated 17-23 Buccan Road, BuccanI refer to the above and advise that Council gave further consideration to this matter at its meeting held on 25 June 1996.As a result of this meeting I have been directed to advise that Council, in accordance with s17(b) of its Local Law XLV (dogs), has revoked your professional breeder and boarding kennels licence for land described as L13 RP 123661 Parish Moffatt situated at 17-23 Buccan Road, Buccan for non-compliance with standard kennel licensing conditions, special conditions of the licence and Council's kennel policy.You are further advised that Council will allow a period of thirty (30) days from date hereof for compliance."