SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND
CITATION:
Re: OSD; SMA & Anor v FJX & Anor; OSD & Anor v ABJ [2023] QSC 264
PARTIES:
In Proceeding BS 7775/23:
AN APPLICATION BY ABJ AS EXECUTOR OF THE WILL OF BST, DECEASEDIn Proceeding BS 8986/23:
SMA and ZCT as attorneys for MPA
(applicant)
v
FJX AND OSD
(respondent)In Proceeding BS 9111/23:
OSD
(first applicant)FJX
(second applicant)
v
ABJ as executor of the Will of BST, DECEASED
(respondent)FILE NO/S:
BS No 7775 of 2023; BS No 8986 of 2023; BS No 9111 of 2023
DIVISION:
Trial Division
PROCEEDING:
Applications
ORIGINATING COURT:
Supreme Court at BrisbaneDELIVERED ON:
Ex tempore reasons delivered on 30 August 2023
DELIVERED AT:
Brisbane
HEARING DATE:
31 July and 29 August 2023
JUDGE:
Muir J
ORDER:
1. In terms of the draft provided
CATCHWORDS:
EQUITY – TRUSTS AND TRUSTEES – APPOINTMENT, REMOVAL AND ESTATE OF TRUSTEES – ESTATE – GENERALLY – where the Executor, Attorneys and Beneficiaries have generally agreed to settle the proceedings – where the Executor seeks judicial advice pursuant to s 96 of the Trusts Act 1973 (Qld) or the Court’s equitable jurisdiction – where the Attorneys seek retrospective conflict transaction approval pursuant to s 73(2) and s 118(3) of the Powers of Attorney Act 1998 (Qld) – where the Attorneys seek an order justifying their steps to establish certain trusts and transfer assets to said trusts – where the Beneficiaries submit that if the court is satisfied with the terms of the settlement that their application should be dismissed
SUCCESSION – MAKING OF A WILL – TESTAMENTARY CAPACITY – SOUNDNESS OF MIND, MEMORY AND UNDERSTANDING – LOSS OR LACK OF CAPACITY AND STATUATORY WILLS – where the applicant in one of the proceedings has an enduring power of attorney for the financial matters of the testatrix, a 94 year old woman – where the testatrix has lost testamentary capacity – where the testatrix is in permanent residential care at a care facility – where the testatrix does not have capacity to make decisions about her personal health and finances – where the testatrix’s will bequeathed assets to her daughter, grandson and charities – whether the court should exercise its discretion to authorise the proposal – whether the Executor, Attorneys and Beneficiaries are entitled to their costs of the Applications on an indemnity basis
Powers of Attorney Act 1998 (Qld)
Trusts Act 1973 (Qld)BP v PM [2022] QSC 268
Buckingham v Buckingham [2020] QSC 230
E (Mrs) v E (1986) 31 DLR (4th) 1
GAU v GAV [2016] I Qd R 1
Henry Matthew Fitzgerald (deceased) v Kane & Ors [2015] QSC 372
Invensys Australia Superannuation Fund Pty Ltd v Austrac Investments Ltd [2006] 1 VR 87
JPT v DST [2014] NSWSC 1735
Karger v Paul [1984] VR 161
Macedonian Orthodox Community Church St Petka Inc v His Eminence Petar The Diocesan Bishop of The Macedonian Orthodox Diocese of Australia and New Zealand (2008) 237 CLR 66
MZY v RYI [2019] QSC…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Re: OSD; SMA v FJX; OSD v ABJ and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2023] QSC 264
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court’s reasoning was grounded in an extensive examination of the relevant documents, including MPA’s Enduring Power of Attorney and Will, as well as the Will of BST. The court found MPA’s Enduring Power of Attorney to be nonsensical and referring to non-existent documents, while BST’s Will was described as impenetrable and overly complex. The court examined the discretionary powers granted to the Executor under MPA’s Will, particularly in relation to the distribution of assets to various trusts. The court also considered the statutory provisions concerning the approval of conflicts of interest and the retrospective validation of certain actions by the Attorneys. The court ultimately concluded that the Executor, Attorneys, and Beneficiaries were entitled to their costs on an indemnity basis, provided the terms of the settlement were satisfactory.
In its orders, the court approved the settlement reached by the Executor, Attorneys, and Beneficiaries, subject to certain conditions. The court authorised the establishment of certain trusts and the transfer of assets to these trusts, while also approving the retrospective conflict transaction approval sought by the Attorneys. The court found that the terms of the settlement were fair and reasonable, and that the Executor, Attorneys, and Beneficiaries were entitled to their costs on an indemnity basis. The final orders reflect the court’s approval of the settlement and the costs incurred by the parties.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. In terms of the draft provided
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Full text does not contain this section.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
These are my reasons which I will revise, anonymise and publish at a later date.Consideration The starting point is an examination of the relevant documents governing the affairs and estates of MPA and BST. First, MPA’s Enduring Power of Attorney which she executed on 1 February 2018. On any view, this document is nonsensical or as the beneficiaries’ counsel described it in their written submissions, “absurd”. It refers to a will that did not exist at the time it was executed. It refers to a trust, the terms of which did not then exist. It refers to the discretion to transfer of assets inter vivos to this non-existent trust “in contemplation of my succession plan as a whole” but does not identify nor refer to any document which might advise as to such a plan. BST’s Will Next there is BST’s Will, dated 14 December 2017, which is well described by the various parties as both impenetrable and stiflingly complex. It is bound up in trusts and discretions, directions and wishes. The Will was drafted by the ABJ – the executor in proceeding 7775/23. Relevantly BST’s Will has the following features:(a)after payment of debts and expenses, the Executor was to hold the estate on trust as provided in the Will;(b)in the first instance, a “Life Interest Fund” was created in favour of MPA by clause 6.2;(c)however, clause 6.2 was subject to discretions in clause 6.3 and 6.4. Relevantly, clause 6.4 provided:“6.4 If MPA (or her duly authorised attorney) consents to its exercise, my Executors, prior to the commencement of or during MPA’s Life Interest, shall have the discretionary power to distribute all or any part of the assets that would otherwise have formed the Life Interest Fund to any other trust (whether or not such trust existed at the time of making my Will), in which MPA has, directly or indirectly, an absolute, contingent or expectant interest or in which MPA is the income and/or capital beneficiary.”(d)clause 8 of the Will created a “Capital Protected Trust” with the principal beneficiary being BST’s nephew OSD. This is described in more detail below, but interleaved between the “Life Interest Fund” (ie. a life interest for MPA) and the “Capital Protected Trust” (an income trust for OSD) was another discretionary provision in clause 7.2 which relevantly enabled the distribution by the Executor of all or any part of the assets to “any other trust” provided that it was also a “Capital protected trust with income beneficiaries confined to the same beneficiaries that would have been the Principal Capital Protected Beneficiaries of the Capital Protected Trust”.(e)the “Capital Protected Trust” under clause 8 was to be called the “BBA and XCV Capital Protected Testamentary Trust”. In his lifetime, OSD was to be the “Principal Capital Protected Beneficiary” for distributions of income for medical treatment, therapy or rehabilitation costs, health care or aged care costs or for any education or associated costs. With OSD’s consent, income for such purposes could also be distributed to “any person who is a Descendant of a grandparent of OSD…” (pausing there, this includes FJX) “… the Children of any of the persons specified in the preceding paragraph”.(f)the terms of the “Capital Protected Trust” continue that, relevantly, if FJX survives her son OSD, the same distributions may be made for FJX or with her consent to “any person who is a Descendant of a grandparent of FJX and so on.(g)on FJX’s death, the benefit continues for “FJX’s Descendants” in the same manner.(h)the terms of the Will also provided that if the income was insufficient to meet the stated needs in any year, the Trustees could use 1% of the capital in addition to the income.(i)the Will then created a further trust, to be called the “BBA and XCV Perpetual Charitable Fund” to be held in perpetuity for certain purposes including certain named charities. Given the terms of the “Life Interest Fund” and the “BBA and XCV Capital Protected Trust”, the charities would not likely benefit for many decades hence.MPA’s Wills