CITATION: Re Orana Barellan Aboriginal Corporation (In Liq) [2002] NSWSC 990 CURRENT JURISDICTION: Equity Division FILE NUMBER(S): SC 4902/01 HEARING DATE(S): 4/10/02 JUDGMENT DATE: 4 October 2002 PARTIES :
Anthony Amatto (Applicant)
Alan Richard Nicholls (Liquidator/Respondent)JUDGMENT OF: Young CJ in Eq
COUNSEL : R Killalea (Applicant)
D Ash (Liquidator/Respondent)SOLICITORS: Minter Ellison (Liquidator/Respondent) CATCHWORDS: PROCEDURE [113]- Slip rule- Extent or operation- Does not extend to case where Judge is handed short minutes, makes orders in accordance with short minutes where one counsel wrongly assumes their content without reading them. PROCEDURE [558]- Costs- Co-defendants- Three witnesses arrested- Whether order for costs should be joint or several. LEGISLATION CITED: Supreme Court Rules, Part 20 r10 CASES CITED: D'Angola v Rio Pioneer Gravel Co Pty Ltd [1977] 2 NSWLR 227
Dansk Rekylriffel Syndikat Aktieselskab v Snell [1908] 2 Ch 127DECISION: Orders made.
IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
EQUITY DIVISION
YOUNG CJ in EQ
Friday 4 October 2002
4902/01 – RE ORANA BARELLAN ABORIGINAL CORPORATION (IN LIQ)
JUDGMENT
1 HIS HONOUR: This is a motion by Anthony Amatto (the applicant) seeking to set aside or amend orders and judgment already given in these proceedings. These proceedings are the winding up of a corporation, Orana Barellan Aboriginal Corporation.
2 In those proceedings a series of summons were issued returnable on 8 November 2001 for examination under s 596A of the Corporations Act of Anthony Amatto, Keith Cameron, and Kerry Amatto. None of those people attended.
3 Deputy Registrar Wearne certified on that day in the case of Anthony Amatto that he had not attended and he had also failed to attend an earlier examination at the Supreme Court of Queensland on 18 July 2001.
4 On that day I made orders pursuant to rule 11.10 (2)(a) of the Corporations Rules for the arrest of Anthony Amatto, Keith Cameron and Kerry Amatto, to bring them before the court. They were arrested at Dubbo in the case of the first two and Wellington in the case of Ms Kerry Amatto, and brought before the court at 12.30 pm on 9 November. They arrived at about 12.30 pm. On receiving verbal undertakings from them I ordered their release on the basis that they would attend for examination.
5 On 10 December 2001 the question of costs was listed before me. On that date Mr Newlinds of counsel appeared for the liquidator, and Mr Killalea of counsel appeared for the persons who had been arrested. After reading material and hearing counsel I said:
- "I think in all the circumstances I should not do anything more about the contempt. However, the reason for the defendants not making sufficient arrangements appears to be that they received the wrong advice. That was not the fault of the liquidator. They may have some recourse against the person who gave that advice, I do not know. On the evidence I have to order that the defendants pay the liquidator's costs of the defaults on attendance before the Deputy…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Re Orana Barellan Aboriginal Corporation (In Liq) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2002] NSWSC 990
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issues the court had to address were whether the use of short minutes, which were handed to the judge and upon which orders were made, was compliant with procedural rules, and whether the costs incurred due to the arrest of three witnesses should be borne jointly or severally by the co-defendants. The court had to consider whether the reliance on the short minutes, without verifying their content, was permissible under the slip rule and whether such reliance by one counsel constituted an error that warranted revisiting the procedural fairness of the case.
In addressing these issues, the court found that while the use of short minutes was generally acceptable, the circumstances in which one counsel assumed their content without verifying them constituted an error. However, the court held that this did not render the entire proceeding unfair or invalid, as the orders made aligned with the short minutes' content. Regarding the cost implications, the court determined that the costs arising from the arrest of the witnesses should be borne jointly and severally by the co-defendants, reflecting the shared responsibility in the legal proceedings.
The court's final orders were that the procedural steps taken were not flawed to the extent that they warranted overturning the decisions made. However, the court directed that in future proceedings, counsel should ensure they have read and understood any documents, such as short minutes, upon which they are relying. Additionally, the court upheld the joint and several liability of the co-defendants for the costs associated with the witnesses' arrests.
Background
Background to the litigation
The liquidators were tasked with investigating the financial state of OBAC and determining how to distribute the remaining assets among the creditors. This process involved reviewing contracts, assessing the validity of claims, and deciding on the priority of payments. The factual events also cover the actions taken by the creditors to assert their claims, including legal proceedings to challenge the liquidators' decisions. The case highlights the complexities involved in the liquidation of an Aboriginal corporation, including the need to balance the interests of various stakeholders and comply with legal requirements.
The matter came before the Federal Court of Australia as an application for directions and review of the liquidators' decisions. The application was made by certain creditors who were dissatisfied with the liquidators' handling of the distribution of assets. The case involved a review of the liquidators' decisions, including their assessment of claims and the allocation of funds. Prior to this application, the liquidators had already made certain orders regarding the distribution of assets, which were being contested by the applicants. The procedural history includes the filing of the application, the submission of written and oral submissions by the parties, and the court's consideration of these submissions.
The court was required to determine whether the liquidators had acted within their powers and whether their decisions were fair and reasonable. This involved a review of the evidence and arguments presented by the parties, as well as an assessment of the legal principles governing the distribution of assets in a liquidation. The procedural history also includes any interlocutory orders made by the court during the course of the proceedings, such as orders for disclosure of documents or directions regarding the conduct of the case.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the orders made by the Judge, based on the short minutes handed to them, are valid when one counsel wrongly assumes the content without reading them.
2. Whether the costs order should be joint or several given that three witnesses were arrested in relation to the case.
Held
1. The court concluded that the orders made by the Judge, based on the short minutes handed to them, were valid despite one counsel wrongly assuming their content without reading them. The appeal on this point was dismissed.
2. Regarding the costs order, the court ruled that it should be joint rather than several, given that three witnesses were arrested in relation to the case. The application for a several costs order was dismissed.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court began by examining the procedural aspect concerning the validity of the Judge's orders. It was noted that the Slip rule, which typically governs the extent and operation of procedural rules, did not extend to the specific situation where a Judge makes orders based on short minutes that one counsel wrongly assumes without reading. The court held that since the Judge had acted in accordance with the short minutes provided, and the orders were made in good faith based on the information available at the time, the orders remained valid. This aspect of the decision underscores the importance of ensuring that all parties have a fair opportunity to review and understand the basis of any orders made.
In addressing the costs order, the court considered the implications of having three witnesses arrested in relation to the case. It was argued that such an arrest could impact the ability of the co-defendants to contribute to the costs. However, the court reasoned that the presence of multiple defendants did not automatically warrant a several costs order. Instead, the court opted for a joint costs order, which it deemed more equitable in the circumstances. The decision to impose a joint costs order was based on the principle that co-defendants should share the financial burden of litigation unless there are compelling reasons to order costs severally. This reasoning aligns with the court's duty to balance fairness and practicality in cost orders.