NEW SOUTH WALES DUST DISEASES TRIBUNAL
CITATION: (Re Olsen) Eraring Energy v Babcock Australia Pty Ltd [2006] NSWDDT 8
PARTIES:
Eraring Energy (Cross Claiment)
Babcock Australia Pty Ltd (Second Cross Defendant)
CASE NUMBER: 2/05/2 of
CATCH WORDS: Claims Resolution Process
LEGISLATION CITED:
Dust Diseases Tribunal Regulation
CORAM: O'Meally P
DATES OF HEARING: 5 April 2006
EX TEMPORE DATE: 05/04/2006
LEGAL REPRESENTATIVES
Goldrick Farrell Mullan (Cross Claiment)
Moray & Agnew (Second Cross Defendant)
JUDGMENT:
RULING
O'MEALLY P
A dispute has arisen concerning the liability of Babcock Australia Pty Ltd (Babcock) to pay costs claimed by Eraring Energy (Eraring) in a cross-claim by Eraring against Babcock and others.
On 6 January 2005 one Oscar Olson (the plaintiff) issued a Statement Of Claim seeking damages from Eraring, Cockatoo Dockyard Pty Ltd and Sarkam Pty Ltd in respect of an asbestos disease.
On 14 November 2005 Eraring issued a cross-claim seeking from Babcock International Ltd, Babcock, Amaca Pty Ltd and Wallaby Grip Ltd contribution to the damages it might be found liable to pay to the plaintiff. The cross-claim against Babcock International Ltd was discontinued.
The plaintiff’s claim against the three defendants was settled and agreement was reached between the defendants and cross-defendants on the contribution each should make to the plaintiff's damages.
The agreement pursuant to Cl 44 of the Dust Diseases Tribunal Regulation (the Regulation) was filed on 6 February 2006 and relevantly provided that the first defendant, Eraring, should contribute 31.85 per cent of the amount agreed to be accepted by the plaintiff in full satisfaction of his claim, which sum, I am told, was to include costs. The second defendant, Cockatoo Dockyard Pty Ltd, agreed to contribute 5 per cent. The third defendant, Sarkam Pty Ltd agreed to contribute 25 per cent. There was a cross-claim other than that with which I am presently concerned, that being the first cross-claim in which the Commonwealth of Australia was the cross-defendant, but in the cross-claim with which I am presently concerned, namely, the second cross-claim, Babcock agreed to contribute 4.875 per cent of the sum to be awarded to the plaintiff, Amaca agreed to contribute 17.875 per cent and Wallaby Grip Ltd 10.4 per cent.
Eraring seeks that Babcock pay in addition to the 4.875 per cent it has paid to the plaintiff, Erarings’ costs of the cross-claim. Babcock disputes it has any liability or obligation to pay any amount other than 4.875 per cent of the judgment sum.
Cl 44 of the Dust Diseases Tribunal Regulation relevantly provides as follows:
(1) An agreement or determination as to apportionment among defendants for the purposes of this Division is conclusively binding on the defendants for the purposes of the settlement, or determination by the Tribunal, of the plaintiff's claim and payment of the plaintiff's damages.
(2)The agreement or determination is not binding for the purposes of the subsequent taking, or determination by the Tribunal, of a dispute between defendants as to apportionment.
(3)If a defendant disputes the contribution that the defendant is liable…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read (Re Olsen) Eraring Energy v Babcock Australia P/L and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2006] NSWDDT 8
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue the tribunal had to decide was whether Babcock Australia P/L, as the cross-defendant, was liable to pay costs to Eraring Energy, the cross-claimant, in accordance with the Dust Diseases Tribunal Regulation Cl 44. This regulation outlines the circumstances under which costs may be awarded in relation to settled claims and cross-claims within the tribunal. The tribunal needed to interpret and apply the relevant regulation to determine if Babcock Australia P/L's liability for costs was established.
In its decision, the tribunal carefully considered the terms of the settlement and the application of Dust Diseases Tribunal Regulation Cl 44. It found that Babcock Australia P/L was indeed liable to pay costs to Eraring Energy, as the cross-claimant, in accordance with the regulation. The tribunal concluded that the regulation was clear in its provisions and that the circumstances of the settlement met the criteria for awarding costs. The tribunal thus ruled in favour of Eraring Energy, ordering Babcock Australia P/L to pay the costs associated with the cross-claim.
As a result of the tribunal's decision, Babcock Australia P/L was ordered to pay the costs of the cross-claim to Eraring Energy. This outcome was based on the tribunal's interpretation of Dust Diseases Tribunal Regulation Cl 44 and its application to the specific circumstances of the settled claims and cross-claims. The tribunal's ruling provided clarity on the liability for costs in such cases and reinforced the importance of adhering to the tribunal's regulations in the resolution of disputes.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi