Re Murphie, R.J

Link copied
Case Copied 4 min read

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTFUUIA

GENERAL DIVISION
BANKRUPTCY DISTRICT

OF THE STATE OF OUEENSLAND

No OB 2398 of 1991

RE: ROBERT JOHN MURPHIE

Debtor

MINUTES OF ORDER

JUDGE MAKING ORDER:  Cooper J
DATE OF ORDER:  7 April, 1992
WHERE MADE:  Brisbane
THE COURT ORDERS THAT: 

1.        The application is dismissed.

Note-
-- Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Rule
124 of the Bankruptcy Rules.

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
GENERAL DIVISION
BANKRUPTCY DISTRICT

OF THE STATE OF OUEENSLAND

No OB 2398 of 1991

RE: ROBERT JOHN MURPHIE

Debtor

C O W :  Cooper J
DATE :  7 April, 1992
PLACE :  Brisbane

EX TEMPORE REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

This is an application by the bankrupt, Robert John Murphie, for discharge from his bankruptcy. The bankrupt was declared bankrupt on his own petition on 22 October, 1991.

The court has before it a list of the creditors of
the bankrupt, the majority of which in terms of number either

do not oppose or did not respond to notice being given of the

Colin David Giddings, appears and does oppose the discharge of application to the court today. The major creditor, however,

the bankrupt at this time in circumstances where Mr. Giddings claims a debt of approximately $28,000.00 which debt has not been satisfied in whole or in part by the payment of any dividend by the estate.

A perusal of the report of the Official Receiver and the affidavit of the applicant shows that the applicant has no assets and no income which as a matter of probability will lead to the payment of a dividend at any future time. He was severely injured in or about 1983 and as a result of those injuries has proceedings on foot in the Supreme Court of Queensland seeking substantial damages. Unfortunately, those proceedings are not moving ahead at any great rate.

The primary ground put forward by the applicant for his discharge is contained in paragraph 18 of his affidavit in support of the application which reads :-

" I c o n s i d e r t h a t should m y bankrup tcy
c o n t i n u e f o r t h e t h r e e y e a r p e r i o d no
u s e f u l purpose would be s e r v e d " .

During his evidence, it became clear that the principal matter of concern to the bankrupt is the possible loss of the house property which he and his wife own in Monto but which is subject to a mortgage to the Queensland Housing Commission. There is in reality little, if any, equity in the property and the attitude of the Queensland Housing Commission, as deposed to by the bankrupt, is that it will not

allow his wife to acquire from the official Trustee his half

interest in the property. He is concerned that he and his

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Re Murphie, R.J and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1992] FCA 240
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Re Murphie, the debtor, Robert John Murphie, applied for discharge from bankruptcy. The matter was heard in the Federal Court of Australia, General Division, Bankruptcy District of the State of Queensland. The primary issue before the court was whether to grant the debtor an early discharge from bankruptcy, given that no dividend had been paid to creditors and the debtor had no assets or income to satisfy his debts. The major creditor, Colin David Giddings, opposed the discharge as the debtor owed him approximately $28,000, which had not been satisfied in any part.

The court considered the debtor's affidavit and evidence, noting that he had no assets or income likely to result in a dividend for creditors in the future. The debtor argued that his continued bankruptcy would serve no useful purpose. The court recognised the debtor's concern about losing his home due to the lack of equity in the property and the Queensland Housing Commission's refusal to allow his wife to acquire his half-interest in the property. However, the court determined that even if the debtor were discharged, the issue of the house would remain unresolved.

The court exercised its discretion and found that there was no cogent reason to grant an early discharge. The Official Receiver neither supported nor opposed the order, but the major creditor opposed the discharge. Consequently, the court dismissed the debtor's application for discharge. The court left open the possibility of a future application if the debtor's circumstances were to change in a way that warranted reconsideration of the discharge.

Background

Background to the litigation

Robert John Murphie, the debtor, was declared bankrupt on his own petition on 22 October 1991. The debtor subsequently applied for discharge from bankruptcy, which was opposed by one of his major creditors, Colin David Giddings, who claimed an outstanding debt of approximately $28,000.00. At the time of the application, no dividend had been paid to any creditors, and the debtor had no assets or income that would likely result in future payments. The debtor was severely injured in about 1983 and had pending proceedings in the Supreme Court of Queensland seeking substantial damages. The debtor expressed concern over the potential loss of his home, which was subject to a mortgage with the Queensland Housing Commission and had little to no equity.

The matter came before the Federal Court of Australia, General Division, Bankruptcy District of the State of Queensland, as an application by the debtor for discharge from bankruptcy. The application was heard and dismissed by Judge Cooper on 7 April 1992. The court considered the report of the Official Receiver, the affidavit of the debtor, and the submissions of the debtor and the creditor, Colin David Giddings. The debtor argued that his continued bankruptcy served no useful purpose, while the creditor opposed the discharge due to the outstanding debt. The Official Receiver neither supported nor opposed the making of the order.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the debtor should be granted a discharge from bankruptcy at such an early point in time.
2. Whether the debtor's lack of assets and income, coupled with his pending court proceedings, is a cogent reason for an early discharge.

Held
1. The court dismissed the debtor's application for a discharge from bankruptcy at such an early point in time.
2. The court found that the debtor's lack of assets and income, coupled with his pending court proceedings, did not constitute a cogent reason for an early discharge.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered the application by Robert John Murphie for a discharge from bankruptcy. The debtor was declared bankrupt on his own petition on 22 October 1991. The majority of creditors did not oppose or did not respond to the application, but the major creditor, Colin David Giddings, opposed the discharge as the debtor's debt of approximately $28,000.00 remained unsatisfied. The debtor had no assets or income, and there was little probability of a dividend being paid to creditors in the future. The debtor argued that continuing his bankruptcy would serve no useful purpose and expressed concern about losing his home due to the mortgage held by the Queensland Housing Commission. However, the court found that the debtor's reasons for an early discharge were not cogent enough, particularly in the absence of any dividend paid to creditors. The Official Receiver neither supported nor opposed the order, but the court exercised its discretion and dismissed the application for discharge. The court left open the possibility of a future application if the debtor's circumstances changed in a way that warranted an early discharge.