Re Maikantis and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection

Link copied
Case Copied 52 min read

MAIKANTIS and MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND BORDER PROTECTION (Migration) [2018] AATA 40 (19 January 2018)

Division:General Division

File Number:           2017/6561

Re:VASILIOS MAIKANTIS

APPLICANT

AndMINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND BORDER PROTECTION

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Deputy President S A Forgie
Mr A Maryniak QC, Member

Date:19 January 2018  

Place:Melbourne

The Tribunal decides to:

1.set aside the decision of the delegate of the respondent dated 24 October 2017; and

2.remit the matter to the respondent with a direction that the applicant’s application for a Bridging E (Class WE) visa not be refused under s 501 of the Migration Act1958. 

.............[sgd]........................................................

Deputy President S A Forgie

Catchwords

MIGRATION – refusal of visa on character grounds – identification of question to be answered on review – decision set aside and remitted.

Legislation

Migration Act 1958 ss 5, 29, 30, 31, 36, 45, 45AA, 46, 47, 65, 84, 86, 499, 501

Direction No.65

Cases

Alexandra Private GeriatricHospital Pty Ltd v Blewett(1984) 2 FCR 368; 56 ALR 265

Contreras v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2015] FCAFC 47

Harman v HomeDepartment State Secretary [1983] 1 AC 280; [1982] 1 All ER 532; [1982] 2 WLR 338

Hearne v Street [2008] HCA 36; (2008) 235 CLR 125; 248 ALR 609; 82 ALJR 1259

Minister for Aboriginal Affairs v Peko-Wallsend Ltd [1986] HCA 40; (1986) 162 CLR 24; 66 ALR 299

Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs v SRT [1999] FCA 1197; (1999) 91 FCR 234; 56 ALD 349

Re Smith and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2013] AATA 687

Williams v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2013] FCA 702; (2013) 136 ALD 299

Secondary Materials

REASONS FOR DECISION

Deputy President S A Forgie

  1. On 24 October 2017, a delegate of the Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (Minister) refused Mr Vasilios Maikantis’s application for a Bridging E (Class WE) visa (sc 050 BE visa) (Bridging Visa) under s 501(1) of the Migration Act 1958 (Migration Act). The delegate did so on the basis that Mr Maikantis had not passed the character test under ss 501(6) and 501(7)(c). The Department of Immigration and Border Protection (Department) advised Mr Maikantis of the decision on 27 October 2017. There was no dispute between the parties that Mr Maikantis had not passed it because he had a substantial criminal record within the meaning of ss 501(1)(a) and 501(7)(c) and (d) of the Migration Act in that he has been sentenced to a term of imprisonment of 12 months or more and has been so sentenced on more than one occasion.

  1. Mr Maikantis has applied for review of the Minister’s decision.  He was born in Greece in 1947 and is a Greek citizen.  He first came to Australia in 1965 with his parents and two siblings when he was 17 years of age and obtained permanent residence but did not apply for Australian citizenship.  On 24 January 2001, Mr Maikantis went to Thailand…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Re Maikantis and Minister for Immigration and Border Protect... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] AATA 40
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an appeal by Mr Maikantis against the Minister for Immigration and Border Protection's refusal to grant him a visa on character grounds. The refusal was based on Mr Maikantis having a substantial criminal record, as defined by section 501(7)(c) of the *Migration Act 1958* (Cth), due to being sentenced to multiple terms of imprisonment totalling more than 12 months. The court was required to determine the lawfulness of the Minister's decision to refuse the visa.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether the Minister's decision to refuse the visa under section 501 of the *Migration Act* was valid. This involved considering the discretionary nature of the power to refuse a visa, the boundaries within which such discretion must be exercised, and the impact of the Minister's Direction No. 65, issued under section 499 of the Act, on the decision-making process. The court also had to assess whether the Minister had properly considered all relevant factors in reaching the decision.

The court found that while Mr Maikantis did have a substantial criminal record, the Minister's discretion under section 501(1) was not unfettered. The decision-making power must be exercised within the boundaries of the Act and any applicable directions. The court noted that Direction No. 65 provides specific guidance on how the Minister should approach character test refusals. The court concluded that the decision under review had failed to adequately identify the specific question to be answered on review, leading to the decision being set aside and remitted for reconsideration.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Direction No. 65 expands upon each of these criteria and we will return to it later in these reasons. BACKGROUND In this section of our reasons, we will set out the facts that are either not in dispute or that we have found after hearing Mr Maikantis’s oral evidence and that of his wife, Mrs Philothea Maikantis, his daughter, Mrs Spiridoula Ahimastos, his son Mr Nickolaos Maikantis, his mother, Mrs Spiridoula Maikantis and that of consultant psychologist, Mr Tim Watson-Munro, as well as having regard to the written evidence. We will set out the facts by reference to the years in which they occurred. Mr Maikantis was born in Greece and attended school until he was 11 years of age. He was functionally literate in Greek and remains so. After leaving school, Mr Maikantis worked on a farm for two years and then worked at a clothing factory in Greece. When he came to Australia, he worked for 18 months on the assembly line at General Motors Holden. He then became a machinist at a clothing factory for a year before obtaining work at the Apex Metal Factory. Mr Maikantis remained at the Apex Metal Factory for two years but secured work in other factories when it closed down. He continued to work in factories until 1978 and then opened a fish and chip shop with his wife, brother, parents and children. The family operated that business for two years. He then bought three trucks and delivered potatoes to fish and chip shops for approximately four years but had to stop that undertaking when pre-cut chips were introduced. Mr Maikantis then owned and operated a coffee shop for some 14 years. At or about the time that he was working at the Apex Metal Factory, Mr Maikantis married. The wedding took place in 1968 and he and his wife will have been married for 50 years this year. When they married, they and Mr Maikantis’s parents lived together and continued to do so when their daughter and son were born. Mr Maikantis has been convicted of a number of offences. We will set them out and intersperse them with events that were happening in Mr Makaintas’s life: Mr Maikantis pleaded guilty to the charges that led to his convictions in the County Court of Victoria (County Court) on 7 November 2016. In passing sentence, Judge Allen set out the events that had led to Mr Maikantis’s being charged together with Mr Chung and Mr Tran:“5. In relation to the charges concerning the cultivation of cannabis, for which each of you have pleaded guilty to, it can be said, by way of introduction, that between July 2014 and January 2015 the three of you, together with others, were engaged in what can be described as a business of cultivating and trafficking cannabis on a very large scale. There is no actual evidence before me of trafficking, per se; although you, Mr Tran, have pleaded guilty to a charge of trafficking, as I understand it, on the basis that the cultivation in which you were involved was for the purpose of trafficking. This cannabis was cultivated as part of a joint criminal enterprise, in which each of you had separate and distinct roles. The joint criminal enterprise included the following activities:i.the procuring of rental properties for the purpose of cultivating cannabis.ii.arranging for the inspection of these properties to determine their suitability for that purpose;iii.the payment of rent and bonds;iv.the setting up of the properties with hydroponic equipment;v.illegal electrical bypasses;vi.planting cannabis plants in those properties;vii.the arranging of crop sitters, as well as, the arranging for managers;viii.dealing with crop sitters;ix.the arranging for the removal of the cannabis plants, that is, for their harvesting in preparation for sale; andx.the arrangement for the properties to be rehabilitated and cleaned prior to being returned to their lawful owners at the end of the lease terms.I emphasise that not each of you three men were involved in all of those activities. …6. In relation to your particular roles … Mr Chung and Mr Maikantis, you became involved at a later stage, sometime in August 2014. The three of you were involved in procuring the rental properties …7. Mr Maikantis, your main role was in procuring the rental properties. … There were various managers and crop sitters engaged by you, Mr Tran, as I’ve said, and with whom you, Mr Maikantis, had some involvement. …. As far as the rental properties were concerned, each of you had pleaded guilty on the basis that you were, each of you separately, directly involved in the 12 properties. It should be noted that those are not the same 12 properties in each case. There is a certain amount of overlap. No one has actually calculated how many properties, all together, are involved between the three of you.8. Police eventually searched each of the rental properties in question. The police found, either, hydroponic cannabis cultivations underway; or, evidence that the property in question had previously been used for such purposes. Each of the properties exhibited limited signs of habitation and, in each of them, all or at least most of the rooms in the buildings had been set up for highly sophisticated hydroponic cultivation. Each property in question included storage facilities for hydroponic equipment and supplies, and the like. This was clearly a carefully planned and manage, sophisticated hydroponic cultivation business. Investigations eventually revealed that each of the properties had been leased for this purpose, for periods ranging between six and 12 months. Nearly all of the properties were residential properties throughout the suburbs of Melbourne. … Mr Maikantis, in relation to the 12 properties in which you were involved, the police seized 901 cannabis plants weighing a total of just under 294 kilograms.9. ‘The summary of prosecution opening’, which was tendered and marked Exhibit A, sets out in comprehensive detail the particular role each of you played and the details of evidence gleaned by investigation; particularly, the analysis of the relevant telephone intercept material. … Exhibits C, D and E, respectively, were synopses in relation to the involvement or particular role that each of you carried out in the business. …10-11. …12. In relation to your role, Mr Maikantis, Exhibit D confirms that the Crown case against you is that your main role was as the procurer of the rental properties, which Mr Tran sought for the purpose of growing cannabis. You were named on the rental agreements for each of these properties. The telephone intercept material reveals that you were involved in collecting the rent for some of those properties and in the clean-up of the properties before they were returned to the landlords. The Crown conceded, as they were bound to do, that your involvement means that you are significantly less culpable than Mr Tran.13. In relation to Charge 2 on your indictment, Mr Maikantis, this involved an agreement you made to sell 20 pounds of dried cannabis to Mr Fortakis for $2,450 per pound. The telephone intercept evidence revealed that Xuan Phuc Ha was to supply you with dried cannabis for $2,400 a pound. You were to make a very minor profit from this proposed arrangement; further evidence of your desperation to obtain money to gamble. As it turned out there is no evidence that your arrangement was ever concluded, or that the sale ever took place. You pleaded guilty to trafficking on the basis that you agreed to sell those drugs to Mr Fortakis.14. …15. As far as the arrests and chronology of the proceedings are concerned, as I understand it, Mr Maikantis, you were the first of the three offenders to be arrested. On 8 January 2015, the police executed a search warrant at your home in Wheelers Hill. It must have been a most distressing experience for your wife and your mother. They also searched your car and various items were seized. They searched other premises that were significant in your life; the Sports Bar in Clayton, where you spent your day’s playing cards and gambling; and, the offices of City Wide Real Estate, through which the premises had been rented and the gambling records of Crown Casino were obtained. These records revealed that, in the year 2014 alone, apart from any money that you wasted at the Sports Bar in Clayton, you lost $210,331 at the casino. You were interviewed by the police later that day, on 8 January 2015, after you had been arrested. To your credit, you made significant admissions throughout the course of the interview and expressed remorse. You were totally cooperative with the police. Amongst other things, you admitted renting all of the houses. You admitted that they had been rented, or re-rented, in connection with Mr Tran and Mr Chung. You claim that you were initially unaware that they were going to be used for cultivating cannabis, but admitted that you became aware of that and continued to remain involved. You admitted organising and paying for the clean-up of properties and paying the rent for the houses. You said to the police that your motive for being involved in this way was, quote, ‘… to make a bit of money.’ You told them that you received somewhere between $800 and $2,000 a month for what you did. You admitted that you had, quote, ‘… done the wrong thing’, and explained that you were, quote, ‘desperate for money because I’m a gambler.’ …16-26. …27. In relation to your [Mr Maikantis’s] prior convictions, I accept Mr Saunders’ submission that they must be seen in the context of dishonesty and gaming. It is noted that you have no prior convictions in relation to drug offending and that your prospects of rehabilitation, in relation to any offending, are of course dependent upon you finally, at this late stage of your life, curing your gambling addiction.28. Mr Saunders conceded that your offending was serious, in light of the fact that it took place over approximately six months and involved a large quantity of cannabis. He conceded that sentencing principals [sic] of general deterrence, just punishment, and denunciation were important factors which resulted in an inevitable sentence of imprisonment.29. Mr Saunders referred to the psychological report of Mr Newton … I have considered that report carefully and I accept, on the whole, Mr Newton’s findings and observations. Mr Newton found, upon testing you carefully, as he always does, that you are experiencing what he describes as ‘noteworthy anxiety’, and that you also reported ‘noteworthy depressive symptoms’. Mr Newton reported that that these symptoms were significantly worse by September 2016, than when he had previously seen you in May 2015. As I understand it, it would seem that your symptoms of anxiety and depression are situational. I must say, for a man of your background, your health problems, and your family circumstances, to find yourself where you are, it is no surprise at all that you are extremely anxious and depressed; so would I be. I do not mean to play down the severity of those symptoms by saying that. I acknowledge that they are serious. Not surprisingly, Mr Newton also found that you have a, ‘history of uncontrolled gambling behaviour, dating from the early 1970s’. Mr Newton referred to your medical problems, your physical problems, your physical illnesses, which I will refer to in a moment, and your psychological difficulties and said:‘Mr Maikantis’ chronic medical problems and psychological difficulties which he suffers are of such severity that they have already resulted in significant difficulties coping with the custodial environment. … The rigors of a custodial penalty would continue to weigh upon Mr Maikantis in a particularly onerous fashion, and would continue to cause him considerable distress over and above the usual hardship that would be experienced by an individual in custody.’I accept and take into account Mr Newton’s findings.30. Mr Saunders relied upon the medical report of your general practitioner, Dr Kounnas. Dr Kounnas says that your medical problems which include type 2 diabetes, otherwise known as myelitis, which has been difficult to control. Dr Kounnas had referred you to an endocrinologist for specialist treatment. Dr Kounnas says that your other major problem is that of rheumatoid arthritis; arthritis which is zero positive, and which requires various forms of medication to control. This medication has an adverse effect on the control of your diabetes. Finally, your general practitioner describes you as suffering from recurrent infections in your legs and right leg ulcer. By way of summary, your general practitioner, who knows not you only but your wife and your mother, and has treated you for 35 years, stated the following:‘The stress of being in a prison setting would exacerbate both his type 2 diabetes, as well as his rheumatoid arthritis. It would also make his complication of diabetes, such as neuropathy, and the neuropathy more unstable because of the stress factors involved in him being in a hospital system.’I believe what is meant by ‘hospital system’ is ‘prison system’. I also received the medical evidence of your 93-year of mother’s serious health difficulties.31. Mr Saunders informed me of your personal history, of which I will summarise. You are now 69 years of age; you will turn 70 in April. You were born in rural Greece. You grew up on a small farm in circumstances of poverty. You had limited education, leaving school at grade 5 because you needed to help your parents on the family farm. Mr Newton has described your level of literacy as rudimentary literacy in Greek, and basic rehabilitation skills, you obtained employment originally in an automobile factory where you remained for some years. Afterwards, you undertook various forms of factory work. Until most recently, you were engaged as a delivery driver. You retired about six years ago and have since then been on the pension. You were married in 1968. This period of incarceration represents the first time you and your wife have been separated. You have two adult children. As I understand it, your elderly 93-year old mother had been living with you and your wife, and you significantly involved in her care and management.32. Mr Maikantis, your counsel asked me to take into account the following matters by way of mitigation. First, your plea of guilty, I accept that it has substantial weight in the circumstances of this case. It has avoided a lengthy and expensive trial. I regard it as being an early plea. I accept that it is evidence of general remorse on your part, an acceptance of responsibility, as well as, your willingness to facilitate the course of justice. I take into account what the authorities say about the sentencing of elderly prisoners, particularly where they suffer ill health. I accept, as was indicated in the case of Gordon, that, in particular, those circumstances justify a more substantial gap between the non-parole period and the head sentence that I might have otherwise imposed in the objective circumstances of this case. [1][1] R v Gordon [2012] QCA 334 at [40]33. I accept, consistent with the principles at paragraph 20 in Markovic, that whilst the circumstances of your family are not exceptional, imprisonment will weigh more hardly upon you; that is, it will be an additional burden for you to sit in gaol, knowing that your wife and mother struggle in your absence, without you being there to assist them in the way that you normally do. [2][2] Markovic v R [2010] VSCA 105; 30 VR 589; 200 A Crim R 51034. I accept that you have excellent prospects of rehabilitation, in relation to being involved in further drug offending. Having served what will be a lengthy prison sentence for someone your age, I am satisfied, in relation to the principle of specific deterrence, that you will be deterred from engaging in this sort of conduct again. I can only hope, however, that your prospects of avoiding crime altogether will be minimised by you putting an end to your gambling addiction.”[38][38] G documents; Attachment B

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Subject to certain qualifications related to the suspension of the processing of visa applications under s 84 and visa limits under s 86, the Minister is to grant a valid application for a visa if satisfied that the health and other criteria specified for the visa have been satisfied, charges have been paid and the grant of the visa is not prevented by Commonwealth laws or the provisions of the Migration Act including s 501.[9] [9] Migration Act; s 65Refusal under section 501 of the Migration Act Section 501(1) provides that:“The Minister may refuse to grant a visa to a person if the person does not satisfy the Minister that the person passes the character test.Note:Character test is defined by subsection (6).”The Minister may refuse to grant a visa if he reasonably suspects that the person does not pass the character test and he is satisfied that the refusal is in the national interest.[10] [10] Migration Act; s 501(3) The character test is set out in s 501(6). Only s 501(6)(a) is relevant:“For the purposes of this section, a person does not pass the character test if:(a)the person has a substantial criminal record (as defined by subsection (7));…” Section 501(7) sets out various situations in which a person is determined to have a substantial criminal record. They include the situation in which a person has been sentenced to a term of imprisonment of 12 months or more.[11] Mr Maikantis has been sentenced to three terms of imprisonment totalling more than 12 months and it makes no difference that one of them was suspended or that he has been released early on parole.[11] Migration Act; s 501(7)(c) Section 501(1) is drafted in discretionary terms in that the Minister “may” refuse to grant a visa to a person who does not satisfy the Minister that the person passes the character test. It is not an unfettered discretion but a discretion that must be exercised within boundaries found in the Migration Act. Those boundaries may be express or they may be implicit when regard is had to the subject matter of the enactment under which the decision is made as well as from its object and underlying policy.[12][12] Alexandra Private GeriatricHospital Pty Ltd v Blewett (1984) 2 FCR 368; 56 ALR 265 at 375; 272 per Woodward J and see also Minister for Aboriginal Affairs v Peko-Wallsend Ltd [1986] HCA 40; (1986) 162 CLR 24; 66 ALR 299; Gibbs CJ, Mason, Brennan, Deane and Dawson JJ at 39-40; 308-309 per Mason J with whom Gibbs CJ and Dawson J agreed In the case of a discretionary decision of the sort provided for in s 501, s 499 of the Migration Act provides that the Minister may give written directions to a person or body having functions or powers under that Act provided the directions are about the performance of those functions or the exercise of those powers.[13] Those directions must not be inconsistent with the Act or the Regulations made under it.[14] The person or body to whom the directions are given must comply with them.[15] The Minister has made a direction under s 499 for the purposes of decisions made under, among others, s 501(1). It is known as “Direction No. 65”. [13] Migration Act; s 499(1)[14] Migration Act; s 499(2)[15] Migration Act; s 499(2A)