SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND
CITATION:
Re LM Investment Management Ltd (in liq) [2022] QSC 132
PARTIES:
RAYMOND EDWARD BRUCE
(first applicant)
AND
VICKI PATRICIA BRUCE
(second applicant)
v
LM INVESTMENT MANAGEMENT LIMITED (IN LIQUIDATION) ACN 077 208 461 IN ITS CAPACITY AS RESPONSIBLE ENTITY OF THE LM FIRST MORTGAGE INCOME FUND
(first respondent)
AND
THE MEMBERS OF THE LM FIRST MORTGAGE INCOME FUND ARSN 089 343 288
(second respondent)
AND
ROGER SHOTTON
(third respondent)
AND
AUSTRALIAN SECURITIES & INVESTMENTS COMMISSION
(intervener)FILE NO:
BS 3383 of 2013
DIVISION:
Trial Division
PROCEEDING:
Interlocutory Application
ORIGINATING COURT:
Supreme Court at Brisbane
DELIVERED ON:
24 June 2022
DELIVERED AT:
Supreme Court at Brisbane
HEARING DATE:
10 June 2022
JUDGE:
Kelly J
ORDER:
1. David Whyte, as the person appointed under section 601NF(1) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) to ensure that the LM First Mortgage Income Fund (‘FMIF’) is wound up in accordance with its constitution and any orders of the Court, and as the receiver of the property of the FMIF, is justified in settling Supreme Court proceeding 2166 of 2015 on the terms set out in the Terms of Settlement (‘the Terms of Settlement’) exhibited to Mr Whyte’s affidavit filed in Court on 10 June 2022, and in causing LM Investment Management Limited (in liquidation) (‘LMIM’) as the responsible entity of the FMIF (receiver appointed) to enter into and perform the Terms of Settlement.
Mr Whyte’s costs of and incidental to this application be costs in the winding up of the FMIF, to be paid out of the assets of the FMIF. 2.
The following documents be placed in a sealed envelope to be held on the Court’s file and not opened without an order of the Court, with the envelope to be so endorsed, and not be placed on the Court’s electronic file:3.
the Affidavit of David Whyte filed 10 June 2022;a.
the Affidavit of Tegan Jade Harris filed 10 June 2022; andb.
the written submissions filed on behalf of Mr Whyte dated 9 June 2022. c.
CATCHWORDS:
CORPORATIONS – RECEIVERS, CONTROLLERS AND MANAGERS – POWERS – TO APPLY TO COURT FOR DIRECTIONS – where the applicant was appointed by orders of this Court of 21 August 2013 to take responsibility for winding up a registered managed investment scheme and act as the receiver of the property of that scheme – where the scheme sought investment via the purchase of units in a fund from the public to make loans to property developers secured by registered mortgages over real property – where the fund was adversely affected by the Global Financial Crisis, and the loans went into default – where the responsible entity of the scheme was placed into liquidation on 1 August 2013 – where the fund and the responsible entity were required to engage, and did engage a registered auditor perform compliance plan audits and financial statement audits – where the responsible entity engaged in related party transactions which breached its duties under the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth)…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Re LM Investment Management Ltd (in liq) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2022] QSC 132
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court considered the inherent jurisdiction to provide directions and whether Whyte was justified in settling the proceedings. The court found that the application for directions was essentially private advice about the exercise of powers conferred upon Whyte by the Court, and therefore it was appropriate to hear the application ex parte and in a closed court. The court also found that Whyte was justified in settling the proceedings on the terms agreed on 31 May 2022, as the advice was being sought to ensure proper exercise of the powers and authority conferred upon him. The court found it important to protect the confidentiality of the settlement terms, as they were confidential and negotiated in the context of mediation.
The court ordered that Whyte was justified in settling the Supreme Court proceedings on the terms set out in the Terms of Settlement, and that his costs of and incidental to this application be costs in the winding up of the fund, to be paid out of the assets of the fund. The court also ordered that the affidavits and written submissions be placed in a sealed envelope to be held on the Court's file and not opened without an order of the Court.
This case demonstrates the importance of confidentiality in settlement negotiations, and the role of the court in providing directions and advice to receivers and liquidators in the context of winding up proceedings. The court found that it was appropriate to hear the application ex parte and in a closed court, and that Whyte was justified in settling the proceedings on the agreed terms.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. David Whyte, as the person appointed under section 601NF(1) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) to ensure that the LM First Mortgage Income Fund (‘FMIF’) is wound up in accordance with its constitution and any orders of the Court, and as the receiver of the property of the FMIF, is justified in settling Supreme Court proceeding 2166 of 2015 on the terms set out in the Terms of Settlement (‘the Terms of Settlement’) exhibited to Mr Whyte’s affidavit filed in Court on 10 June 2022, and in causing LM Investment Management Limited (in liquidation) (‘LMIM’) as the responsible entity of the FMIF (receiver appointed) to enter into and perform the Terms of Settlement.
Mr Whyte’s costs of and incidental to this application be costs in the winding up of the FMIF, to be paid out of the assets of the FMIF. 2.
The following documents be placed in a sealed envelope to be held on the Court’s file and not opened without an order of the Court, with the envelope to be so endorsed, and not be placed on the Court’s electronic file:3.
the Affidavit of David Whyte filed 10 June 2022;a.
the Affidavit of Tegan Jade Harris filed 10 June 2022; andb.
the written submissions filed on behalf of Mr Whyte dated 9 June 2022. c.
Background
Background to the litigation
This case involves an interlocutory application made by David Whyte, the receiver of the LM First Mortgage Income Fund, seeking directions in the inherent jurisdiction of the Court regarding the settlement of proceedings against an auditor. The application was made in the context of winding up proceedings of the LM First Mortgage Income Fund, which was adversely affected by the Global Financial Crisis and subsequently placed into liquidation. The proceedings against the auditor were initiated on 2 March 2015, and the application for directions regarding the settlement was made on 10 June 2022. The application is an ex parte application, meaning it was made without notice to the other parties, and seeks to have the court proceedings and evidence sealed and closed to protect the confidentiality of the settlement terms.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the application ought be heard ex parte and in closed court.
2. Whether the applicant is justified in settling those proceedings on the terms agreed on 31 May 2022.
Held
1. The court decided that the application should be heard ex parte and in a closed court.
2. The court held that the applicant is justified in settling the proceedings on the terms agreed on 31 May 2022.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
I considered that it was appropriate to hear the application ex parte, to close the court and seal the affidavits because:(a)The role of the Court when giving “judicial advice” is properly characterised as the Court exercising its supervisory responsibility for the conduct of the winding up, rather than as resolving a dispute between parties or giving advice to an external party.[2] (b)Judicial advice is hence properly described as “private advice”.[3](c)In Yuill v Spedley Securities (in liq),[4] the Court (Gleeson CJ, Mahoney and Priestley JJA) relevantly said of applications for judicial advice as to whether to commence proceedings that “Applications of that kind are … ordinarily heard in camera”.(d)In the present case, by this Court’s orders dated 21 August 2013, the applicant was conferred with, inter alia, power and authority to commence, maintain and, if appropriate, settle, proceedings on behalf of the Fund brought in the name of LMIM as were necessary for the winding up of the Fund. The subject matter of the interlocutory application was private advice about the exercise of the power and authority conferred upon the applicant by this Court. The applicant sought that private advice in circumstances where, in order to obtain the advice, he needed to place before the Court confidential material including the Terms of Settlement themselves, legal advice and reference to without prejudice communications.(e)The other parties to the Terms of Settlement have an obvious interest in protecting the confidential nature of the Terms of Settlement. I consider that it is important to protect that interest at this stage, when the Supreme Court proceedings are still on foot and judicial advice is being sought. I do not consider it appropriate to expose the Terms of Settlement to actual scrutiny or the prospect of scrutiny by any person who is not a party to that document at this critical stage.(f)The affidavits include the Terms of Settlement which are confidential and negotiated in the context of a mediation.(g)The affidavits also include confidential material which is protected by without prejudice privilege and, in respect of which, the applicant has a limited permission to place the material before the Court alone for the sole purpose of obtaining advice.(h)There is also no reason for the Court to withhold judicial advice merely because the terms of settlement are confidential. Advice can be given in these circumstances by the Court.[5] [2]Gardner v London Chatham and Dover Railway Co (No 1) (1867) LR 2 Ch App 201, 211; Rosanove v O’Rourke [1988] 1 Qd R 171, 173 (Connolly, Carter and de Jersey JJ); Re GB Nathan & Co Pty Ltd (in liq) (1991) 24 NSWLR 674, 677.[3]Macedonian Orthodox Community Church St Petka Inc v His Eminence Petar The Diocesan Bishop of The Macedonian Orthodox Diocese of Australia and New Zealand (2008) 237 CLR 66, 91-2 [64]-[65].[4]Unreported, NSWCA, 8 May 1992.[5]Hodges v Waters (No 7) (2015) 232 FCR 97 [65]-[68] (Perram J).Consideration of the Interlocutory Application