SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND
CITATION:
Re: Kirman & Harris [2020] QSC 99
PARTIES:
ROBERT MICHAEL KIRMAN AND WILLIAM JAMES HARRIS AS JOINT AND SEVERAL ADMINISTRATORS OF VAC GROUP OPERATIONS PTY LTD (ACN 130 054 296) (SUBJECT TO DEED OF COMPANY ARRANGEMENT)
(first plaintiff)
ROBERT MICHAEL KIRMAN AND WILLIAM JAMES HARRIS AS JOINT AND SEVERAL ADMINISTRATORS OF BEACOS PTY LTD (ACN 118 965 398) (SUBJECT TO DEED OF COMPANY ARRANGEMENT) IN ITS OWN CAPACITY AND IN ITS CAPACITY AS TRUSTEE FOR THE BEACOS TRUST (ABN 94 359 583 849)
(second plaintiff)
ROBERT MICHAEL KIRMAN AND WILLIAM JAMES HARRIS AS JOINT AND SEVERAL ADMINISTRATORS OF COSBEA PTY LTD (ACN 152 898 041) (SUBJECT TO DEED OF COMPANY ARRANGEMENT) IN ITS OWN CAPACITY AND IN ITS CAPACITY AS TRUSTEE FOR COSBEA UNIT TRUST (ABN 27 318 596 387)
(third plaintiff)ROBERT MICHAEL KIRMAN AND WILLIAM JAMES HARRIS AS JOINT AND SEVERAL ADMINISTRATORS OF EARTH RADAR GROUP PTY LTD (ACN 620 043 129) (SUBJECT TO DEED OF COMPANY ARRANGEMENT)
(fourth plaintiff)ROBERT MICHAEL KIRMAN AND WILLIAM JAMES HARRIS AS JOINT AND SEVERAL ADMINISTRATORS OF EARTH RADAR PTY LTD (ACN 163 919 088) (SUBJECT TO DEED OF COMPANY ARRANGEMENT)
(fifth plaintiff)ROBERT MICHAEL KIRMAN AND WILLIAM JAMES HARRIS AS JOINT AND SEVERAL ADMINISTRATORS OF REBIRTHED EARTH PTY LTD (ACN 144 749 235) (SUBJECT TO DEED OF COMPANY ARRANGEMENT)
(sixth plaintiff)ROBERT MICHAEL KIRMAN AND WILLIAM JAMES HARRIS AS JOINT AND SEVERAL ADMINISTRATORS OF SOIL TRANSFER PTY LTD (ACN 130 054 303) ADMINISTRATORS APPOINTED)
(seventh plaintiff)ROBERT MICHAEL KIRMAN AND WILLIAM JAMES HARRIS AS JOINT AND SEVERAL ADMINISTRATORS OF STAKING U ASIA PACIFIC CAMPUS PTY LTD (ACN 158 311 516) (SUBJECT TO DEED OF COMPANY ARRANGEMENT)
(eighth plaintiff)ROBERT MICHAEL KIRMAN AND WILLIAM JAMES HARRIS AS JOINT AND SEVERAL ADMINISTRATORS OF VAC GROUP EMPLOYEES PTY LTD (ACN 155 400 043) ADMINISTRATORS APPOINTED)
(ninth plaintiff)ROBERT MICHAEL KIRMAN AND WILLIAM JAMES HARRIS AS JOINT AND SEVERAL ADMINISTRATORS OF VAC GROUP HOLDINGS PTY LTD (ACN 130 053 388) (SUBJECT TO DEED OF COMPANY ARRANGEMENT)
(tenth plaintiff)ROBERT MICHAEL KIRMAN AND WILLIAM JAMES HARRIS AS JOINT AND SEVERAL ADMINISTRATORS OF VAC-U-DIG PTY LTD (ACN 105 678 493) (SUBJECT TO DEED OF COMPANY ARRANGEMENT)
(eleventh plaintiff)ROBERT MICHAEL KIRMAN AND WILLIAM JAMES HARRIS AS JOINT AND SEVERAL ADMINISTRATORS OF VAC-U-DIGGA PTY LTD (ACN 115 882 347) (SUBJECT TO DEED OF COMPANY ARRANGEMENT) IN ITS OWN CAPACITY AND IN ITS CAPACITY AS TRUSTEE FOR THE VAC-U-DIGGA TRUST (ABN 78 450 702 816)
(twelfth plaintiff)ROBERT MICHAEL KIRMAN AND WILLIAM JAMES HARRIS AS JOINT AND SEVERAL ADMINISTRATORS OF VAC-U-DIGGA R & D PTY LTD (ACN 120 462 053) (SUBJECT TO DEED OF COMPANY ARRANGEMENT)
(thirteenth plaintiff)ROBERT MICHAEL KIRMAN AND WILLIAM JAMES HARRIS AS JOINT AND SEVERAL ADMINISTRATORS OF VHS IP PTY LTD (ACN 618 795 583) (SUBJECT TO DEED OF COMPANY ARRANGEMENT)
(fourteenth plaintiff)
FILE NO/S:
BS No 13000 of 2019
DIVISION:
Trial Division
PROCEEDING:
Application on the papers without oral hearing
ORIGINATING COURT:
Supreme Court of Queensland
DELIVERED ON:
6…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Re Kirman and Harris and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2020] QSC 99
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues before the court were whether the remuneration sought by the applicants in their capacity as receivers should be approved, whether it was appropriate to relieve the applicants of the obligation to submit accounts, whether it was appropriate to discharge the receivers from their appointments, and whether it was appropriate to determine the application without an oral hearing. Furthermore, the applicants sought to amend a previous court order to change the wording of the costs provision.
The court found that it was appropriate to determine the application on the papers without an oral hearing, considering the nature of the application and the submissions provided. Regarding the remuneration, the court approved the remuneration sought by the applicants, noting that the work undertaken was reasonably necessary to the receiverships. The court also relieved the applicants of the obligation to submit accounts and discharged them from their appointments upon payment of the approved amounts. Finally, the court varied the previous order to amend the wording of the costs provision, finding it appropriate in the circumstances.
The final orders of the court approved the remuneration and disbursements, costs and expenses of the applicants, relieved them of the obligation to submit accounts, discharged them from their appointments upon payment of the approved amounts, and varied the previous order to amend the wording of the costs provision. The costs of the application were to be costs of the receiverships, equally, and if insufficient, to be the costs of the applicants in the administration of the trusts.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. This application be determined on the papers.
2. The remuneration of the second plaintiffs in their capacity as receivers and managers of the Beacos Trust be approved in the amount of $3459.00 (plus GST) made up as follows:
(a) $2194.00 (plus GST) in respect of work previously carried out;
(b) $1265.00 (plus GST) in respect of the work identified as prospective work.
3. The disbursement, costs and expenses incurred by the second plaintiffs in their capacity as receivers and managers of the Beacos Trust be approved in the amount of $39,860.43.
4. The remuneration of the twelfth plaintiffs in their capacity as receivers and managers of the Digga Trust be approved in the amount of $3267.50 (plus GST) made up as follows:
(a) $2002.50 (plus GST) in respect of work previously carried out; and
(b) $1265.00 (plus GST) in respect of costs and expenses.
5. The disbursement, costs and expenses incurred by the twelfth plaintiffs in their capacity as receivers and managers of the Digga Trust be approved in the amount of $11,535.65.
6. Paragraph 8 of the Orders dated 11 December 2019 be varied to delete the words “and if insufficient to be their costs in the winding up” and insert “and if insufficient to be their costs in the administration of the second and twelfth plaintiffs”.
7. The Receivers be relieved of the obligation to submit accounts.
8. Upon payment of the amounts in paragraphs 2 and 3, the second plaintiffs be discharged from their appointment as Receivers to the Beacos Trust.
9. Upon payment of the amounts in paragraphs 4 and 5, the twelfth plaintiffs be discharged from their appointment as Receivers to the Digga Trust.
10. The costs of this application be costs of the Receivership of the Beacos Trust and Digga Trust, equally, and if insufficient be their costs in the administration of the second and twelfth plaintiffs.
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In these circumstances, I consider it appropriate to deal with the application on the papers without the need for an oral hearing.Receivers’ remuneration The second issue to be determined is whether the remuneration sought by the second and twelfth plaintiffs in their capacity as Receivers should be approved. The relevant principles concerning a Receiver’s remuneration were identified in the submissions as being summarised in the case of Golden Star Resources Limited & Another v Keryn Beatrice Rosel [2010] QSC 28 at [25]. In that case, White J (as her Honour then was) adopted the propositions of principle summarised by Barrett J in Mohamed v Hurstville Tower Medical Clinic Pty Ltd (in Liquidation) [2006] NSWSC 4 at [8]:“1. The court constituted by a judge never considers a review of quantum, but only matters of principle.2. A receiver is entitled to have his costs, charges and expenses properly incurred in the discharge of his ordinary duties or in the performance of extraordinary services that have been sanctioned by the court. 3. The receiver must justify the reasonableness and prudence of the tasks undertaken for which remuneration is sought. The relevant onus is on the receiver. 4. A receiver’s remuneration is not in the same category of [sic] [as] costs. The receiver is making application for a fair recompense for what he or she has actually done. 5. The court’s objective is to award a sum or devise a formula which will reasonably compensate the receiver for the time and trouble expended in the execution of his duties and, to some extent the responsibility he has assumed. 6. The court will usually work off time sheets created in the receiver’s office provided they do significantly more than merely detail the total number of hours spent by the receiver and officers of particular grades on his or her staff. 7. The court is guided by a professional scale of charges, with emphasis on the broad average or general rate charged by persons of the relevant status and qualifications who carry out relevant work.” (Footnotes omitted) Paragraph 21 of the fourth Harris affidavit outlines the work undertaken by the Receivers since the commencement of the Receivership on 11 December 2019. This includes having negotiated and entered into the Westpac agreement (as defined), negotiated and entered into the Lease (as defined), notified insurers regarding ongoing insurance arrangements relating to the Receivership and attended to various statutory matters, lodgements and notifications relating to the appointment of Receivers. Exhibited to the fourth Harris affidavit as Exhibit WJH-35 is a remuneration request approval report. This report is in the format recommended by ARITA (which is the Australian Restructuring Insolvency and Turnaround Association).[3] The report contains a breakdown of the remuneration sought in relation to both the Beacos Trust and the Digga Trust. Further, it contains information setting out specified task areas, a general description, as well as a description of work covered in each of the areas.[4][3]Paragraph [23] of the fourth Harris affidavit.[4]Pages 434 - 436 of Exhibit WJH-35.