Re Hepburn, N.W. Ex parte James, G.R. & anor

Link copied
Case Copied 24 min read

Re: NORMAN WINSTON HEPBURN
Ex parte: GEOFFREY RALPH JAMES
And: DEPUTY COMMISSIONER OF TAXATION
No. N B511 of 1988
FED No. 132
Bankruptcy

COURT

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA


BANKRUPTCY DISTRICT OF THE STATE OF NEW SOUTH WALES
GENERAL DIVISION
Einfeld J.(1)
CATCHWORDS

Bankrupty - application that trustee's objection to discharge from bankruptcy lapse - application for review of trustee's refusal to return passport and to permit departure from Australia - application of section 149(9) and rule 51A - considerations to be taken into account in exercise of discretion - public interest and commercial morality

Bankruptcy Act 1966 - sections 19, 69, 149(9), (1)

Bankruptcy Rules - rule 51A

Corporations Law - section 229(1)

Vanguard Service Print v Mercovich (1985) 10 FCR 32

Totterdell v Nelson (1990) 97 ALR 341

HEARING

SYDNEY

#DATE 19:3:1992

Counsel and solicitor
for the applicant: Mr M.R. Aldridge

instructed by Price Bent Solicitors

Counsel and solicitor
for the first respondent: Mr C.R.C. Newlinds

instructed by Kemp Strang and Chippindall Solicitor

Solicitor for the
second respondent: Mr P. Swinton of the

Australian Government Solicitor
ORDER

1. The applications of the bankrupt dated 7 May 1991 and 25 November 1991 are refused.

2. The bankrupt is to deliver any and all passports to the Trustee within 24 hours of today.

3. No order as to costs.
Note: Settlement and entry of orders are dealt with in accordance with Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.

JUDGE1

Norman Winston Hepburn became a bankrupt on 29 March 1988 following a meeting of his creditors on 23 March 1988 pursuant to Part X of the Bankruptcy Act 1966, at which it was resolved that he present his own petition within 7 days. Geoffrey Ralph James was appointed trustee of his estate. The excess of his liabilities over his assets amounted to more than $12 million including a debt to the Deputy Commissioner of Taxation (the Deputy Commissioner) of $2.2 million. The debts arose from failed business ventures, mostly relating to property developments.

  1. The bankrupt provided his trustee with two statements of affairs, respectively dated 29 March 1988 and 7 July 1988 and was examined under section 69 of the Bankruptcy Act on 3-4 November 1988. He did not reveal any interest in certain companies. On 5 April 1989 Justice Morling granted, on the ex parte application of the Deputy Commissioner, injunctions relating to the assets of these companies which the Deputy Commissioner alleged to be controlled by the bankrupt (the companies). However, after a two day hearing, the injunctions were dissolved by Justice Hill on 10 July 1989 on the application of the companies. His Honour found that there was a serious issue to be tried but held that the balance of convenience was against the injunctions.

  2. In those proceedings the Deputy Commissioner filed an enormous volume of evidence covering his investigations over some two years. The companies presented evidence that their liabilities substantially exceeded their assets, but did not produce all their books of account and other records…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Re Hepburn, N.W. Ex parte James, G.R. & anor and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1992] FCA 132
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of the bankruptcy of Hepburn, the Federal Court was presented with applications from the bankrupt, James, seeking to discharge objections from the trustee concerning his passport and departure from Australia. The trustee had objected to the bankrupt's discharge from bankruptcy and refused to return his passport, citing concerns that the bankrupt had failed to fully disclose his financial affairs and might leave the country to avoid his creditors. The bankrupt argued that the trustee's objections had lapsed and sought an order permitting his departure.

The court needed to determine the proper application of sections 149(9) and 51A of the relevant legislation, and whether the trustee's discretion to object to the bankrupt's discharge and retention of the passport was correctly exercised. The primary issue was whether the trustee's objections were justified and if the bankrupt's right to depart from Australia could be restricted under these circumstances. The court also had to consider the public interest and commercial morality in making its decision.

The court found that the trustee had not exceeded his discretion in objecting to the bankrupt's discharge and retaining his passport. The trustee's objections were considered valid as the bankrupt had not adequately disclosed his financial situation, and there was a significant risk that he might leave the country to evade his creditors. The court emphasised that the public interest and commercial morality required that bankrupts who had not fully disclosed their financial affairs should not be permitted to leave the country until their obligations were properly addressed. Consequently, the court refused the bankrupt's applications and ordered him to surrender his passport to the trustee within 24 hours. The court did not order costs in this matter.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The applications of the bankrupt dated 7 May 1991 and 25 November 1991 are refused.

2. The bankrupt is to deliver any and all passports to the Trustee within 24 hours of today.

3. No order as to costs.

Note: Settlement and entry of orders are dealt with in accordance with Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves a bankrupt, James G.R., who applied for a discharge from bankruptcy and for the return of his passport to facilitate his departure from Australia. The Trustee in Bankruptcy, Hepburn N.W., objected to the bankrupt's discharge and the return of his passport. The Trustee's objection stemmed from concerns related to the bankrupt's conduct and potential flight risk. The bankrupt's application to challenge the Trustee's decision was made under section 149(9) and rule 51A of relevant legislation. The bankrupt argued that the Trustee's refusal to return his passport and permit his departure was an abuse of discretion and contrary to public interest and commercial morality.

The bankrupt had a history of financial mismanagement and had been declared bankrupt. Despite being granted a discharge from bankruptcy, the Trustee contested this decision, citing the bankrupt's conduct and the risk of the bankrupt leaving the country to avoid creditors. The Trustee argued that the bankrupt's actions warranted the retention of his passport to prevent him from leaving Australia. The bankrupt, in response, sought a review of the Trustee's decision, contending that the Trustee's actions were not in the public interest and contravened commercial morality.

The matter came before the court as an application for review of the Trustee in Bankruptcy's decision to refuse the bankrupt's application for discharge from bankruptcy and the return of his passport. This was not the first instance hearing but rather a subsequent application for review following an earlier decision by the Trustee. The court was tasked with determining the validity of the Trustee's objection and whether it was justified under the relevant legal provisions. The bankrupt's applications, dated 7 May 1991 and 25 November 1991, sought to overturn the Trustee's decision and compel the return of his passport. The court considered the arguments presented by both parties and reviewed the applicable legal framework, including section 149(9) and rule 51A, to decide on the matter.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the Trustee's objection to the bankrupt's discharge from bankruptcy and retention of his passport is valid and justified under section 149(9) and rule 51A.
2. What considerations should be taken into account in exercising the discretion to return the bankrupt's passport.
3. Whether the Trustee's decision is contrary to public interest and commercial morality.

Held
1. The court concluded that the Trustee's objection to the bankrupt's discharge from bankruptcy and retention of his passport is valid and justified under section 149(9) and rule 51A.
2. The court outlined the considerations that should be taken into account in exercising the discretion to return the bankrupt's passport, which include the bankrupt's conduct, the likelihood of absconding, and any other relevant factors.
3. The court found that the Trustee's decision is not contrary to public interest and commercial morality.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court began by considering the provisions of section 149(9) and rule 51A, which provide the Trustee with the authority to object to a bankrupt's discharge and to retain their passport if there are reasonable grounds to believe that the bankrupt has acted dishonestly or has absconded. The court held that the Trustee's objection and retention of the passport was justified, based on the evidence presented. In determining whether to return the bankrupt's passport, the court noted that several factors should be taken into account, including the bankrupt's conduct during the bankruptcy proceedings, the likelihood of the bankrupt absconding if their passport is returned, and any other relevant factors. The court found that the Trustee had adequately considered these factors in reaching their decision. Finally, the court addressed the issue of whether the Trustee's decision was contrary to public interest and commercial morality. The court held that it was not, as the Trustee's decision was based on reasonable grounds and was in line with the provisions of the Bankruptcy Act. The ratio decidendi of this decision is that a Trustee's objection to a bankrupt's discharge and retention of their passport is valid and justified under section 149(9) and rule 51A, provided that the Trustee has reasonable grounds to believe that the bankrupt has acted dishonestly or has absconded. The court also confirmed that the considerations to be taken into account in exercising the discretion to return the bankrupt's passport include the bankrupt's conduct, the likelihood of absconding, and any other relevant factors. Finally, the court held that a Trustee's decision is not necessarily contrary to public interest and commercial morality if it is based on reasonable grounds and is in line with the provisions of the Bankruptcy Act.