Re Florance, James Louis Ex parte Turimetta Properties Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 27 min read

-_

lXIL\TLY

RE:

JAMES

L O U I S

F L O l l t V i C E

EX

PARTE:

NO:

P 303 of 1979

CORAN:

LOCKHART J .

DATE O F ORDER

Page 2 , 11 ne

1

follo” should

CATCHWORDS

Uaskmptcy - creditor's petition - petitioning creditor held to be a secured creditor - whether petitlon may be

amended to permit secured credltors to state willingness

to surrender security o r estimate value of security o r

such statements must be made in petition when presented -

exercise of discretion in favour of amendment

FiZ:

JAMES LOUIS FLORANCE

EX

PARTE:

TURIMETTA PROPERTIES

FTY. LIMITED NO. P 309 OF 1979

LOCKHART J.

SYDNEY

11 FEBRUARY 1980

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

)

GENERAL DIVISION

BANKRUPTCY DISTRICT

OF THE STATE

No. P 309 of 1979

OF NEW SOUTH WALES AND THE

AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY

RE:

JAMES

LOUIS

FLORANCE

Debtor

Ex PARTE:

TURIMETTA

PROPERTIES

PTY. LIMITED

Creditor

ORDER

JLTDGE MAKING

ORDER:

LOCKHART

J.

SYDNEY

WHERE MADE:

ORDER:

DATE

OF

11 FEBRUARY 1980

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.

Leave be granted to the petitioning creditor

to amend

paragraph 3 . of the petition by deleting paragraph

3. in

its present form and substituting the

following:-

"3. The company holds security over part

of the property of the debtor for payment

of the amounts specified In the last

preceding paragraph, being the debtor's

interest in all those pieces

o r parcels

of land sltuate at Mona Vale In the Shire

of Warringah, Parish

of Narrabeen and

County of Cumberland. being the whole

of

the land comprised in Certiflcate

of Title

Volume 7199 Folic 118; Volume 9244 Follo

186 (excluding the land referred to in

dealing number P 60375) and Volume

12710

F o l l o 224 and 225, but the company is willing to surrender the security for the benefit of the creditors generally in the

event of a sequestration order being

made

against the estate of the debtor.''

. . ./2

.

I

-2-

2.

The

pe t i t i on ing c r ed i to r

be d i rec ted

to

rever i fy

and

r e - se rve t he pe t i t i on a s

amended

i n accordance

wlth

t h e

Bankruptcy Rules and the practice

of

t h i s

C m r t ;

3.

The

fu r the r hea r ing o f t he pe t i t i on

be

adjourned

t o

I

a

d a t e t o

be f ixed.

4 . Costs be reserved.

-1-

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA )

1

DIVISION

GENERAL

)

)

BANKRUPTCY DISTRICT OF THE STATE

) NO. P309 of 1979

)

OF NEW

SOUTH

WALES

AND

THE

)

1

AUSTRALIAN

CAPITAL

TERRITORY

)

RE:

JAMES LOUIS FLORANCE

Debtor

EX PARTE: TURIMETTA PROPERTIES PTY.

LIMITED

Creditor

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

LOCKHART J .

On 17 September 1979 I gave judgment on the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Re Florance, James Louis Ex parte Turimetta Properties Pty L... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1980] FCA 13
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Re Florance, James Louis Ex parte Turimetta Properties Pty Ltd, the petitioner, Turimetta Properties Pty Ltd, sought to amend its creditor's petition for bankruptcy against the debtor, James Louis Florance. The primary legal issue was whether the court could permit the amendment of the petition to allow the secured creditor to state its willingness to surrender security and estimate the value of security, or if these statements must be made in the petition when presented. Lockhart J. held that the court had the power to allow the amendment, as it did not bring about a radical change in the law and was not a condition precedent to the right to present a petition. Lockhart J. also found that, as a matter of discretion, the leave to amend the petition ought to be granted. The court ordered that the petitioning creditor be granted leave to amend paragraph 3 of the petition, and the further hearing of the petition be adjourned to a date to be fixed. Costs were reserved.

Background

Background to the litigation

Turimetta Properties Pty Ltd, a creditor, filed a bankruptcy petition against James Louis Florance. The creditor held security over certain of the debtor's properties. The petition did not initially state the creditor's willingness to surrender its security or provide particulars of the security as required by the Bankruptcy Act 1966. The debtor opposed the petition, arguing that the creditor was a secured creditor and that the petition should not be amended to include the required statements. The creditor sought leave to amend the petition to comply with the statutory requirements.

This case involved a hearing on an application for leave to amend a bankruptcy petition. Previously, on 17 September 1979, the court had given judgment on the grounds of opposition to the petition and adjourned the further hearing of the petition. The matter was listed for further hearing on 14 December 1979 to consider the creditor's application to amend the petition.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Does the court have the power to permit a petitioning creditor to amend a bankruptcy petition to include statements required by the Bankruptcy Act 1966?
2. Should the court, in its discretion, grant leave to the petitioning creditor to amend the petition?

Held
1. The court has the power to permit a petitioning creditor to amend a bankruptcy petition to include statements required by the Bankruptcy Act 1966.
2. The court, in its discretion, grants leave to the petitioning creditor to amend the petition to include necessary statements regarding its status as a secured creditor, but denies the amendment to include an additional act of bankruptcy not committed within the required time frame.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court held that it has the authority to allow a petitioning creditor to amend a bankruptcy petition to comply with the requirements of the Bankruptcy Act 1966, even if those requirements were not initially met at the time of petition presentation. This conclusion was based on the court's analysis of relevant statutory provisions and case law, which demonstrated a consistent practice of permitting such amendments. The court rejected the argument that the statutory language precluded the power to amend, finding that the intent of the legislation was to ensure compliance rather than impose a condition precedent to filing a petition. Regarding the exercise of discretion, the court found that the petitioning creditor's late recognition of its status as a secured creditor, and the absence of prejudice to the debtor, justified granting leave to amend. However, the court declined to permit an amendment that would include an act of bankruptcy occurring outside the statutory six-month window, adhering to the strict requirements of the Act. The court also ordered that the amended petition be reverified and reserved in accordance with court practice.