CITATION: Simons v Permanent Trustee Co Ltd: Estate D. Hakim [2005] NSWSC 223
HEARING DATE(S): 15 and 16 March, 2005
JUDGMENT DATE :
18 March 2005JURISDICTION: Equity Division
JUDGMENT OF: Palmer J
DECISION: Further provision out of the estate ordered for the daughter; claims of grandchildren dismissed.
CATCHWORDS: FAMILY PROVISION ACT - EXTENSION OF TIME - Whether sufficient cause for delay shown. - ELIGIBLE PERSON - Whether grandchildren wholly or partially dependent upon testator - what is "dependence" - whether emotional, not financial, dependence is sufficient for purposes of s.6(1)(d). - ADEQUATE PROVISION - Large estate - claim by daughter - all other beneficiaries well provided for - whether adequate provision made for daughter - extent of daughter's needs.
LEGISLATION CITED: Family Provision Act 1982 (NSW) - s.6, s.7, s.16
Wills Probate and Administration 1898 (NSW) - s.93CASES CITED: - Anasson v Phillips (unrep) NSWSC 4 March 1988
- Fulop, Re (1987) 8 NSWLR 679
- Leahey & Trescowthick [1999] VSC 409
- MacEwan Shaw v Shaw [2003] VSC 318
- O'Dea v O'Dea [2005] NSWSC 46
- Pearson v Jones [2000] NSWSC 799
- Petrohilos v Hunter (1991) 25 NSWLR 343
- Sayer v Sayer [1999] NSWCA 340
- Tsivinsky v Tsivinsky (unrep) NSWCA, 5 December 1991
- Warren v McKnight (1996) 40 NSWLR 390PARTIES: Mariane Hakim Simons - First-named Plaintiff
David Joshua Edgeworth Simons - Second-named Plaintiff - Ceased to be a party: 13.12.04
James Lloyd Simons - Third-named Plaintiff
Mijanou Celina Ariane Zigane - Fourth-named Plaintiff
Giselle Marise Phillipa Simons - Fifth-named Plaintiff
Permanent Trustee Company Limited - First-named Defendant
Claude Hakim - Second-named Defendant
Muriel Betty Ginges - Third-named DefendantFILE NUMBER(S): SC 1644/03
COUNSEL: R.F. Margo SC, S.L. Bell - Plaintiffs
M. Cashion Sc, T.M. Thawley - DefendantsSOLICITORS: McCabe Terrill - Plaintiffs
Kemp Strang - Defendants
LOWER COURT JURISDICTION:
1 This is an application under s.7 of the Family Provision Act 1982 (NSW) for provision out of the estate of the late David Hakim. The Plaintiffs are a daughter of the deceased, Mariane Hakim Simons, and three of her children, James Lloyd Simons, Mijanou Zigane, and Giselle Marise Simons. For the sake of convenient reference and without intending any disrespect, I will refer to the Plaintiffs as Mariane, James, Mijanou and Giselle. 2 The deceased died on 6 April 2001 leaving a will dated 27 July 1998. Probate of the will was granted on 30 September 2002 to the Defendants, namely, Permanent Trustee Company Limited (“Permanent”), Claude Hakim and Muriel Ginges. Claude Hakim is the widow of the deceased and Muriel Ginges is his daughter. Again, without intending any disrespect, I will refer to the personal Defendants as Claude and Muriel.Introduction
3 The Plaintiffs’ application under the Act was commenced by the filing of a Summons on 27 February 2003. The prescribed period for the making of the application provided by s.16(1), namely, eighteen months from the death of the deceased, had expired on 6 October 2002.…
Extension of time
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Re Estate of Hakim; Simons v Permanent Trustee Co Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2005] NSWSC 223
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court was required to determine whether Simons demonstrated sufficient cause for the delay in making the application under the Family Provision Act. Furthermore, the court had to interpret the term "dependence" within the context of the Act, specifically whether emotional dependence, as opposed to financial dependence, could be sufficient to meet the criteria outlined in section 6(1)(d). The court also needed to assess whether the deceased had made adequate provision for Simons, considering the overall wealth of the estate and the provisions made for other beneficiaries.
The court held that Simons had not provided sufficient cause for the delay in bringing the application. In terms of dependency, the court concluded that "dependence" in the context of the Family Provision Act encompasses both financial and emotional aspects. However, the court found that Simons's claim for emotional dependence was not sufficient to meet the statutory criteria. Regarding adequate provision, the court determined that the deceased had made ample provision for Simons, considering the size of the estate and the provisions made for other beneficiaries.
No further orders were made by the court beyond the findings outlined above.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi