Re Estate of Badstuebner

Link copied
Case Copied 46 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Re Estate of Badstuebner [2020] QSC 144

PARTIES:

THOMAS PAUL BADSTUEBNER

(applicant)

v

KARL PERRY BADSTUEBNER

(first respondent)

JENNIFER OLIVE BADSTUEBNER

(second respondent)

FILE NO/S:

SC No 151 of 2020

DIVISION:

Trial

PROCEEDING:

Application

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court at Cairns

DELIVERED ON:

29 May 2020

DELIVERED AT:

Cairns

HEARING DATE:

24 April 2020

JUDGE:

Henry J

ORDERS:

1.   Application dismissed.

2.   I will hear the parties as to costs at 9.15 am 10 June 2020, if the Registrar has not in the meantime been notified in writing that costs are agreed.

CATCHWORDS:

SUCCESSION - PERSONAL REPRESENTATIVES – COMMISSION - DISCRETION OF COURT - GROUNDS FOR REFUSAL OR REDUCING AMOUNT – where the applicant was appointed as the sole executor of the estate of his deceased father – where the will divided the estate in equal shares between the applicant and his three siblings – where the estate was not complex or large – where the applicant entered into negotiations with the other beneficiaries to obtain the deceased’s home – where the applicant purported to condition his performance of his executor’s duties on the payment of an “executor’s fee” or executor’s commission – whether the applicant is entitled to receive a commission

Succession Act 1981 (Qld), s 68, s 52(1)(a), s 52(1)(d)

Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 (Qld), r 657C
Atkins v Godfrey [2006] WASC 83, applied
Dawson v Snedden [2019] NZHC 736, cited
Ex Parte Schneider; Re Estate of Blashild (2009) 3 ASTLR 61, cited
Ford v Princehorn; Estate of Ford [2012] NSWSC 1165, cited
Gonzales v Claridades (2003) 58 NSWLR 188, cited
Gonzales v Claridades (2003) 58 NSWLR 211, cited
Hawkins v Barkley-Brown [2010] NSWSC 48, applied
In the will of Henry Sherringham (1901) 1 SR (NSW) B&P 48, cited
In the Will of Wallace (1934) 51 WN (NSW) 84, cited
Kirkpatrick v Kavulak [2005] QSC 282, considered
Re Estate Gowing (2014) 11 ASTLR 128, cited
Re Estate of Celestino Ghidella [2005] QSC 106, considered
Re Lack [1983] 2 Qd R 613, considered
Re Phillips [2007] NSWSC 639, cited

G E Dal Pont and K F Mackie, Law of Succession (LexisNexis, 2nd ed, 2017)
De Groot’s Publishing, Wills, Executors and Probate Administration (Qld), vol I, (at May 2020)

COUNSEL:

J Trevino for the applicant

A Crossland for the respondents

SOLICITORS:

Miller Harris Lawyers for the applicant

Attwood Marshall Lawyers for the respondents

  1. The deceased, Paul Herman Badstuebner, died on 6 May 2018.  His will left his residual estate to his four children in equal shares and appointed one of his children, Thomas,[1] as executor.

    [1]I will for convenience, and intending no disrespect, herein refer to the deceased’s children by their first names.

  2. The will did not provide for Thomas to receive a fee to perform the role of executor. Thomas presided over a slow administration in which he repeatedly persued his own interests. Despite this shortcoming he now makes application for the court to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Re Estate of Badstuebner and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] QSC 144
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Re Estate of Badstuebner, the applicant, Thomas, was appointed as the sole executor of his deceased father’s estate. The dispute arose when Thomas sought to condition his performance of his executor duties on the payment of an executor’s fee or commission. Thomas' siblings, Karl and Jennifer, resisted the application, arguing that Thomas was not entitled to receive a commission. The estate, which was not complex, comprised the deceased’s home, cash in various accounts, two motor vehicles, and sundry household chattels. Thomas pursued a distribution of the estate which would have seen him receive ownership of the deceased’s home, the motor vehicles, and household chattels, but this attempt ultimately failed. Thomas rented out the Kirby Close property and eventually engaged a real estate agent to sell the house, which sold in September 2019. The interim distributions made to all beneficiaries totalled $917,000, yet no distributions were made after the house sale settled on 5 September 2019. As at the hearing of this application in late April 2020, over seven months after the Kirby Close property was sold, the amount of $447,500 still remained in the estate’s accounts.

The legal issues the court was required to decide included whether Thomas was entitled to receive a commission, and if so, what amount. The court considered the value and composition of the estate, the conduct of the parties, and the efficiency of the administration of the estate in deciding the application for commission. The court found that Thomas had breached his executor duties, and his conduct was a relevant consideration in the decision-making process. The court determined that the occurrence and consequence of any breach of the executor’s duties would be relevant, and that an executor’s breach of duty may result in the court refusing to authorise payment of a commission. The court also found that the effect of the breach upon the estate would be relevant and that the degree of seriousness of a breach of duty would remain a relevant consideration.

The court dismissed the application for commission and ordered that Thomas was not entitled to receive a commission. The court will hear the parties as to costs at 9.15 am on 10 June 2020, if the Registrar has not in the meantime been notified in writing that costs are agreed.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Application dismissed.

2. I will hear the parties as to costs at 9.15 am 10 June 2020, if the Registrar has not in the meantime been notified in writing that costs are agreed.

Background

Background to the litigation

The application is resisted by Thomas’ siblings Karl and Jennifer. The other sibling, Brett, did not participate in the proceeding.Background The estate was uncomplicated. It comprised: (a)the deceased’s home, a residential property at Kirby Close, Atherton, valued in the estate inventory at $358,077.56 “after expenses”; (b)$993,198.03 cash in various accounts; (c)two motor vehicles valued in the estate inventory at $9000 and $8000 respectively; and, (d)sundry household chattels. Thomas was granted probate on 25 June 2018. From then until at least November of 2018, Thomas pursued a distribution of the estate which, via a deed he propounded, would have seen him receive ownership of the deceased’s Kirby Close property, the motor vehicles and the household chattels.[2] Thomas’ prolonged attempt to negotiate that outcome failed. In the meantime, Thomas rented out rather than sold the Kirby Close property. While he secured his siblings agreement to such a course it was a clearly a course pursued by Thomas to accommodate his desire to receive that property as part of the distribution he spent much of 2018 in pursuit of. A substantial part of the commission he now seeks relates to the hours he expended in direct and indirect consequence of that essentially self-interested pursuit.[2]Affidavit of Thomas Paul Badstuebner, dated 20 March 2020, Court doc 2, Ex TPB9 p 46. The Kirby Close house was rented out from August 2018 to February 2019. Thomas eventually engaged a real estate agent to sell the house in February 2019. It sold in September 2019. Thomas made no partial distribution of the estate’s significant cash holdings during 2018, despite their quantum far exceeding the estate’s likely debts. Interim distributions totalling $229,250 each (a total of $917,000) were eventually made to all beneficiaries on 7 January 2019 and 5 June 2019, yet none were made after the house sale settled on 5 September 2019. As at the hearing of this application in late April 2020, over seven months after the Kirby Close property was sold, the amount of $447,500 still remained in the estate’s accounts. That amount far exceeds the commission here sought of $41,858.89 and any lingering financial obligations of the estate. No explanation was given by Thomas for why such a large amount has remained undistributed for so long. The respondent submits the delay was to induce Thomas’ siblings to agree that he be paid a commission. This is said to be part of a pattern of conduct throughout Thomas’ executorship, by which he has abused his control of the timing of the administration of the estate to try and induce his siblings to agree to his wishes. Material supporting the application Rule 657C Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 (Qld) (“UCPR”) relevantly provides:“657C Application for commission(1) A trustee of an estate may apply to the court for commission.(2) The application must be supported by an affidavit of the trustee setting out— (a) the basis of the application; and (b) the commission sought; and (c) the trustee’s justification for the commission; and (d) an inventory of the estate; and (e) material to identify the appropriate respondents to the application. …”

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Considerations guiding the court’s decision on an application for commission are set out at r 657E UCPR as follows:“657E Decision on application for commission (1) In deciding an application for commission by a trustee of an estate, the court may take into account—(a) the value and composition of the estate; and (b) the provisions of the will or trust instrument for the estate; and (c) the conduct of all persons (including the parties) connected with the administration of the estate; and (d) the nature, extent and value of work done by persons other than the trustee, including non-professional work delegated to a lawyer; and (e) the result of any assessment of the estate account, including the scope and merit of any objections raised in a notice of objection before the estate account has passed; and (f) the efficiency of the administration of the estate; and (g) any other matter the court considers relevant.(2) The court may make any order for commission the court considers appropriate.” Of the considerations specifically listed in r 657E(1) the value and composition of the estate, the conduct of the players and the efficiency of the administration are the most obviously relevant in the present case. In the circumstances of this case the occurrence and consequence of any breach of the executor’s duties appears to be a relevant consideration both as “conduct”, caught by r 657E(1)(c), and as a “relevant” matter, caught by r 657E(1)(g). It is well settled that an executor’s breach of duty may result in the court refusing to authorise payment of a commission. For example, in an oft-cited observation, Walker J relevantly observed in In the will of Henry Sherringham:[15]“[B]efore remuneration is allowed them, trustees must show that their conduct of the affairs of the trust is free from any suspicion and that there has been no neglect on their part which has in any way prejudiced the estate.”[15](1901) 1 SR (NSW) B&P 48, 49. The effect of the breach upon the estate will be relevant. Observations by Street J in In the Will of Wallace[16] suggest that rather than concerning itself with the degree of blame for the neglect of duty the court should look to the effect of that neglect upon the estate. [16](1934) 51 WN (NSW) 84, 86. Nonetheless, the degree of seriousness of a breach of duty also remains a relevant consideration. In Atkins v Godfrey[17] Le Miere J concluded on a review of authority and articles:“It seems to be established and accepted that where executors have been guilty of positive fraud or dishonesty in their office the courts will refuse them commission. As to acts or neglects falling short of fraud or dishonesty, whether the executor’s commission should be refused or reduced will depend upon the severity of the breach, assessed according to its consequences and the culpability of the executor.” His Honour concluded the executor in that matter had failed to exercise proper scrutiny over legal fees and failed to ensure the estate was administered with due expedition. He materially reduced the commission he would otherwise have allowed.[17][2006] WASC 83, [29].

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.