Re Edelsten, G.W.; Ex parte Donnelly, M.C. v Edelsten, G.W.

Link copied
Case Copied 5 min read

4-0s sz

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA JUSMENT NO. ..l.uu...,.J
EXERCISING FEDERAL JURISDICTION No NB 497 of 1988
IN BANKRUPTCY

BANKRUPTCY DISTRICT OF THE STATE OF NEW SOUTH WALES AND THE AUSTRALIAN

CAPITAL TERRITORY

RE :  GEOFFREY WALTER EDELSTEN

Bankrupt

EX PARTE:  MAX CHRISTOPHER DONNELLY

AS TRUSTEE FOR THE ESTATE OF

GEOFFREY WALTER EDELSTEN

Applicant

AND:  GEOFFREY WALTER EDELSTEN AND OTHERS

Respondents

COURT:  NORTHROP J
PLACE :  MELBOURNE
m: 
2 JUNE 1992  12 JUN 1992

AUSTRALIA

EX TEMPORE REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

PRINCIPAL REalSTRI

, :. ,

An unusual and fairly difficult question has arisen in

the following circumstances. Counsel for the applicant called as a witness Ruth Rowena Davoren who had sworn an affidavit at the request of the solicitors for the applicant on 8 July

1991. She was then cross-examined by Dr Edelsten, the first

respondent, and Mr Collins, counsel for the fourteenth counsel appearing for an opposing party would not be allowed to do in the cross-examination. It consisted essentially, of stating what had occurred or what the position was and then
respondent. It is fair to say that the cross-examination of

asking of the witness:  Do you agree? Is that not so? or
words to that effect.  One finished with the impression that,

what his version was of all these events which he sought,
then, to establish by the oath of the witness, Ruth Davoren.

in reality, Dr Edelsten was, in substance, giving evidence of witness seemed to have very little clear recollection of what had occurred and when asked questions as to what did occur, what was said or what had happened, her recollection was very,

very bad.  But in answer to questions put to her as to
statements or events, she had no hesitation in saying yes or
no as the case may be.

In re-examination, counsel for the applicant put to the

witness an affidavit sworn by her on 13 September 1991
apparently relied upon by an opposing party in this
application. Objection was taken to the witness being asked
questions about that affidavit and there then ensued argument
as to the relevance of this. It became apparent that counsel
for the applicant was seeking to establish a basis for
declaring the witness hostile so as to be allowed to conduct

the re-examination in the manner of a cross-examination to the
extent to which counsel considered it necessary for the
purpose of doing justice.

In deciding the question of whether counsel should be

allowed to put the second affidavit to the witness, it is
necessary, to some extent, to consider the principles to be
applied in deciding whether a witness should be declared
hostile or not. Normally, this question arises in
examination-in-chief where the witness gives oral evidence.
The common case is that that evidence is inconsistent with

previous statements either written or oral. In those

circumstances the person who called that witness desires to

cross-examine the witness. The principles to be applied in

cases of this kind are discussed at some length…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Re Edelsten, G.W.; Ex parte Donnelly, M.C. v Edelsten, G.W. and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1992] FCA 405
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Re Edelsten; Ex parte Donnelly arose in the Federal Court of Australia, specifically in the Bankruptcy Division. The dispute involved an application by Max Christopher Donnelly, acting as the trustee for the estate of Geoffrey Walter Edelsten, who was a bankrupt. The primary issue before the court was whether the witness, Ruth Rowena Davoren, should be declared hostile, thereby allowing the applicant's counsel to cross-examine her in re-examination as if she were being cross-examined during examination-in-chief. This unusual situation arose due to the manner in which Dr. Edelsten, the first respondent, cross-examined the witness, which closely resembled the examination of a hostile witness, and the witness's poor recollection of events, leading to questions about her credibility.

The court had to determine whether the principles governing the declaration of a witness as hostile could apply in the context of re-examination, particularly when the witness had previously sworn an affidavit. The central legal issue was whether the court could allow the witness to be cross-examined in re-examination and, if so, under what circumstances. The court considered authorities such as Cross on Evidence and the High Court decision in McLelland v Bower, which provided guidance on when a witness could be deemed hostile. The court also took into account the witness's demeanour and the relevance of a second affidavit sworn by the witness.

The court, after considering the evidence and arguments presented, ruled that it was appropriate to allow the applicant's counsel to cross-examine the witness in re-examination using the second affidavit. This decision was made in the interest of justice, taking into account the witness's previous affidavit, the method of cross-examination employed by Dr. Edelsten, and the witness's demeanour. The court's ruling permitted the cross-examination to proceed in a manner akin to cross-examination in examination-in-chief. The final orders were made to permit the cross-examination as outlined in the judgment.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established