Dust Diseases Tribunal
of New South Wales
CITATION: (re Dawson) Novek v Amaca Pty Limited (2) [2008] NSWDDT 15 PARTIES: Carina Maria Novek as legal personal representative of the Estate of the Late Margaret Denise Dawson
Amaca Pty LimitedMATTER NUMBER(S): 7152 of 2007 JUDGMENT OF: Kearns J CATCHWORDS: DUST DISEASES TRIBUNAL :- costs
indemnity costs
Calderbank offer
reserved costs
conduct of the partiesDATES OF HEARING: 20 May 2008
DATE OF JUDGMENT:
26 May 2008LEGAL REPRESENTATIVES: Ms A Katzmann SC, instructed by Turner Freeman, appeared for the plaintiff.
Mr D Russell SC, instructed by DLA Phillips Fox, appeared for the defendant.
JUDGMENT:
1. On 25 May 2008, there were two applications argued before me, though no notices of motion had been filed.
Plaintiff’s application for indemnity costs
2. The first was the plaintiff’s application for indemnity costs. On 22 January 2008, the plaintiff made a Calderbank offer to settle for $500,000 plus costs. The letter was a standard Calderbank letter and no point is taken as to any inadequacy in its form. The application was resisted essentially on three bases:
(1) the stage of the proceedings when the offer was made;
(2) the short time that the offer was left open for acceptance;
(3) the defendant’s prospects of success and the genuineness and force of its arguments.
3. I do not think any of those three bases, either alone or together, warrant denying the plaintiff the relief she seeks. By 22 January 2008, the matter had been listed for hearing on 7 and 8 February 2008. On 22 January 2008, the hearing was brought forward to 24 January 2008. It was brought forward, I assume, because of a deterioration in Mrs Dawson’s health.
4. By 22 January 2008, the whole of the plaintiff’s affidavit evidence had been served. True it is that, when the offer was made, the defendant had not had an opportunity to cross-examine the deponents and the offer was to expire before that could occur. There is nothing novel in that. Offers of compromise and Calderbank offers are frequently, indeed mostly, made and lapse before evidence is taken and I do not see that as a basis for refusing the plaintiff’s application.
5. The offer allowed the defendant two days or less in which to accept it. It was made on 22 January. It was to lapse on 24 January at 10.00am. I do not think this is an unreasonable time in the circumstances for the defendant to consider the offer. It made no protest about the inadequacy of the time. If it did not know the value of the case then, it never would. The defendant must have been fully prepared for hearing before the offer was made. It went to mediation, apparently in good faith and fully on top of the case, in November 2007. By 22 January, it had received the totality of the plaintiff’s affidavit evidence. It should have needed less than one day to make up its mind whether or…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read (re Dawson) Novek v Amaca Pty Limited (2) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2008] NSWDDT 15
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court needed to decide if the plaintiff’s conduct in making the Calderbank offer, which was not accepted, justified an order for indemnity costs. The legal principles at play included the conduct of both parties and whether the offer was reasonable. The court considered the effect of the offer on the defendant's conduct and the overall progress of the litigation.
The Tribunal found that the plaintiff's conduct was not unreasonable and that the Calderbank offer was indeed reasonable. The court concluded that the defendant’s failure to achieve a better outcome justified an order for indemnity costs. The court balanced the conduct of both parties and the potential deterrent effect of such an order on future litigation. The outcome was in favour of the plaintiff, who was granted indemnity costs for the proceedings.
Orders
Orders of the court
Full text does not contain this section.
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Full text does not contain this section.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Full text does not contain this section.