Re ComfortDelGro Corporation Australia Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

ComfortDelGro Corporation Australia Pty Ltd, in the matter of ComfortDelGro Corporation Australia Pty Ltd [2020] FCA 378

File number: VID 153 of 2020
Judge: BEACH J
Date of judgment: 20 March 2020
Catchwords: CORPORATIONS – financial reporting – relief under ASIC Class Order – group of companies – deed of cross guarantee – 1998 Class Order – 2016 Class Order – necessity to file opt in notices – consequences of failure to file opt in notices – failure to comply with financial reporting and lodging requirements under ss 292(1), 301, 314 and 319 of Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) – relief from non-compliance under s 1322 – requirements of ss 1322(4) and (6) – inadvertence – no substantial injustice – orders made
Legislation:

ASIC Class Order: Wholly-owned Entities [CO 98/1418]

ASIC Corporations (Wholly-owned Companies) Instrument 2016/785

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) ss 292, 301, 314, 319 and 1322

Cases cited:

In the matter of DAC Finance (NSW/Qld) Pty Ltd [2020] NSWSC 182

Re Murray River Organics Ltd (2019) 138 ACSR 365

Re Wave Capital Ltd (2003) 47 ACSR 418

Weinstock v Beck (2013) 251 CLR 396

Date of hearing: 19 March 2020
Registry: Victoria
Division: General Division
National Practice Area: Commercial and Corporations
Sub-area: Corporations and Corporate Insolvency
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs:           54
Counsel for the Plaintiff: Ms S Gory
Solicitor for the Plaintiff: Gilbert + Tobin

ORDERS

VID 153 of 2020

IN THE MATTER OF COMFORTDELGRO CORPORATION AUSTRALIA PTY LTD (ACN 002 072 004)

COMFORTDELGRO CORPORATION AUSTRALIA PTY LTD (ACN 002 072 004)

Plaintiff

JUDGE:

BEACH J

DATE OF ORDER:

20 MARCH 2020

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.Pursuant to s 1322(4)(d) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) (the Act) the time specified by ASIC Class Order: Wholly-owned Entities [CO 98/1418] (Old Class Order) or ASIC Corporations (Wholly-owned Companies) Instrument 2016/785 (New Class Order) for the plaintiff and the entities listed in Annexure A (other than those that have been deregistered) to lodge the notice required by condition k of the Old Class Order or cl 6(1)(f) of the New Class Order (the opt in notice) be extended to 24 March 2020.

2.Under s 1322(4)(c) of the Act the plaintiff, the entities listed in Annexure A and each of their respective current directors and officers and former directors and officers are relieved from any civil liability in respect of any failure to:

(a)lodge an opt in notice within the time specified in the Old Class Order or the New Class Order;

(b)comply with:

(i)s 292(1) of the Act;

(ii)s 301(1) of the Act;

(iii)s 314(1) of the Act;

(iv)s 319(1) of the Act;

in respect of the financial years ending 31 December 2007 to 31 December 2018; and

(c)comply with the notice issued by the Australian Securities and Investments Commission under s 1274(11) of the Act dated 4 December 2019.

Note:   Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

ANNEXURE A

1.        Westbus Region 1 Pty Ltd (ACN 116…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Re ComfortDelGro Corporation Australia Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] FCA 378
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Federal Court of Australia, CDC Australia, a public transport company operating in several Australian states, sought relief from certain financial reporting and compliance obligations. The company had failed to comply with specific conditions of ASIC Class Orders that exempted it and its subsidiaries from certain financial reporting requirements, including the failure to file opt in notices. CDC Australia argued that its non-compliance was inadvertent and that there would be no substantial injustice if relief was granted. ASIC neither consented to nor objected to the relief sought by CDC Australia.

The legal issues before the court were whether CDC Australia's failure to comply with the conditions of the ASIC Class Orders was inadvertent and whether granting relief would result in no substantial injustice. The court considered the requirements of sections 1322(4) and 1322(6) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), which allow for relief from non-compliance if certain conditions are met. The court found that CDC Australia's failure to comply with the conditions of the ASIC Class Orders was inadvertent and that granting relief would not result in any substantial injustice. The court noted that CDC Australia had taken steps to comply with the Class Orders, including executing a deed of cross guarantee, and that ASIC had not provided any feedback on whether CDC Australia met the conditions of the Class Orders.

The court granted CDC Australia and its subsidiaries relief from any civil liability in respect of their failure to comply with certain financial reporting and compliance obligations. The court also extended the time for CDC Australia and its subsidiaries to file the opt in notices required by the ASIC Class Orders. The court found that CDC Australia's non-compliance was inadvertent and that granting relief would not result in any substantial injustice. The court noted that CDC Australia had taken steps to comply with the Class Orders and that ASIC had not provided any feedback on whether CDC Australia met the conditions of the Class Orders.

The court made orders pursuant to section 1322(4) of the Corporations Act, extending the time for CDC Australia and its subsidiaries to file the opt in notices required by the ASIC Class Orders, and relieving CDC Australia and its subsidiaries from any civil liability in respect of their failure to comply with certain financial reporting and compliance obligations. The orders also relieved CDC Australia and its subsidiaries from any civil liability in respect of their failure to lodge an opt in notice within the time specified in the ASIC Class Orders. The court's orders provide relief to CDC Australia and its subsidiaries from certain financial reporting and compliance obligations, and allow them to regularise their position with ASIC.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Pursuant to s 1322(4)(d) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) (the Act) the time specified by ASIC Class Order: Wholly-owned Entities [CO 98/1418] (Old Class Order) or ASIC Corporations (Wholly-owned Companies) Instrument 2016/785 (New Class Order) for the plaintiff and the entities listed in Annexure A (other than those that have been deregistered) to lodge the notice required by condition k of the Old Class Order or cl 6(1)(f) of the New Class Order (the opt in notice) be extended to 24 March 2020.

2. Under s 1322(4)(c) of the Act the plaintiff, the entities listed in Annexure A and each of their respective current directors and officers and former directors and officers are relieved from any civil liability in respect of any failure to:

(a) lodge an opt in notice within the time specified in the Old Class Order or the New Class Order;

(b) comply with:

(i) s 292(1) of the Act;

(ii) s 301(1) of the Act;

(iii) s 314(1) of the Act;

(iv) s 319(1) of the Act;

in respect of the financial years ending 31 December 2007 to 31 December 2018; and

(c) comply with the notice issued by the Australian Securities and Investments Commission under s 1274(11) of the Act dated 4 December 2019.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

ANNEXURE A

1. Westbus Region 1 Pty Ltd (ACN 116 171 450);

2. Hillsbus Co Pty Ltd (ACN 116 171 469);

3. Hunter Valley Buses Pty Ltd (ACN 116 171 432);

4. CDC NSW Pty Ltd (formerly Westbus Region 3 Pty Ltd) (ACN 054 096 892);

5. CDC Travel Pty Ltd (formerly known as Coach Services Pty Ltd and prior to that, Charterplus Pty Ltd) (ACN 118 478 318);

6. CDC Victoria Pty Ltd (formerly CDC Victoria 1 Pty Ltd) (ACN 006 822 420);

7. CDC Wyndham Pty Ltd (formerly CDC Werribee Pty Ltd and prior to that, Point Cook-Werribee Passenger Service Proprietary Limited) (ACN 004 400 766);

8. CDC Ballarat Pty Ltd (formerly H.A. Davis Motor Service Proprietary Limited) (ACN 004 640 895);

9. CDC Geelong Pty Ltd (formerly Pivot Bus Services Pty Ltd) (ACN 092 432 614);

10. CDC Altona Pty Ltd (formerly Altona Bus Lines Proprietary Limited) (ACN 004 637 512);

11. CDC Sunshine Pty Ltd (formerly CDC Victoria 4 Pty Ltd) (ACN 004 368 156);

12. CDC Oakleigh Pty Ltd (formerly W. Sinclair & Sons Proprietary Limited) (ACN 004 482 142);

13. CDC Victoria 2 Pty Ltd (deregistered 27 March 2012) (ACN 006 822 439);

14. CDC Victoria 3 Pty Ltd (deregistered 27 March 2012) (ACN 004 845 630);

15. West Transit Bus Lines Pty Ltd (deregistered 27 March 2012) (ACN 004 740 078);

16. North Sunshine Bus Service Pty Limited (deregistered 20 October 2019) (ACN 004 488 448);

17. Eastern Suburbs Omnibus Services Proprietary Limited (deregistered 27 March 2012) (ACN 004 231 396);

18. Western Coach Services Pty Ltd (deregistered 27 March 2012) (ACN 005 129 233); and

19. St Albans Bus Service Pty Ltd (deregistered 20 October 2019) (ACN 006 846 733).

Background

Background to the litigation

CDC Australia’s application and supporting material have been served on ASIC. ASIC has advised that it neither consents nor objects to the orders sought.BACKGROUND CDC Australia, formerly known as ComfortDelGro Cabcharge Pty Ltd, is an Australian public transport company that provides bus, taxi and patient transport services across Victoria, New South Wales, Western Australia, Northern Territory and Queensland. Its ultimate holding company (as to 51%) is ComfortDelGro Corporation Ltd, a publicly listed company on the Singapore Securities Exchange. As at 22 February 2006, CDC Australia was the holding company of the following subsidiaries (the original subsidiaries):(a)Westbus Region 1 Pty Ltd;(b)Hillsbus Co Pty Ltd;(c)Hunter Valley Buses Pty Ltd;(d)CDC NSW Pty Ltd (formerly Westbus Region 3 Pty Ltd); and(e)Coach Services Pty Ltd (subsequently also known as Charterplus Pty Ltd and now known as CDC Travel Pty Ltd). In around May 2007, CDC Australia’s then financial controller, Mr Stephen Thorne, requested advice from the company’s lawyers, Coleman Greig, about lodging consolidated accounts for the financial year ending 31 December 2007. Coleman Greig advised CDC Australia that in order to qualify for relief under the Old Class Order it had to provide ASIC with:(a)a deed of cross guarantee;(b)a statement by the directors of CDC Australia that, in their opinion, prior to the execution of such a deed there were reasonable grounds to believe that the company would be able to pay its debts as and when they fell due; and(c)evidence that CDC Australia was entitled to the relief sought. But the advice did not mention the need to file an opt in notice. Coleman Greig were instructed to prepare the relevant materials to enable CDC Australia and its subsidiaries to qualify for relief under the Old Class Order. On 6 June 2007, ASIC made orders under s 340(1) of the Act exempting CDC Australia and its original subsidiaries from the financial reporting requirements. The exemption was conditional on satisfaction with the conditions in the Old Class Order. On 14 June 2007, CDC Australia and the original subsidiaries executed a deed of cross guarantee. On 2 July 2007, Coleman Greig sent ASIC a copy of the deed of cross guarantee and other relevant materials. It requested confirmation that CDC Australia had met ASIC’s requirements and that CDC Australia and its original subsidiaries were entitled to the relevant relief. No reply from ASIC has been located. In 2009, CDC Australia acquired a further 13 wholly owned subsidiaries to expand the reach of its services in Victoria (the additional subsidiaries), being:(a)CDC Victoria Pty Ltd (formerly CDC Victoria 1 Pty Ltd);(b)CDC Wyndham Pty Ltd (formerly CDC Werribee Pty Ltd and prior to that, Point Cook-Werribee Passenger Service Proprietary Limited);(c)CDC Ballarat Pty Ltd (formerly H.A. Davis Motor Service Proprietary Limited);(d)CDC Geelong Pty Ltd (formerly Pivot Bus Services Pty Ltd)(e)CDC Altona Pty Ltd (formerly Altona Bus Lines Proprietary Limited);(f)CDC Sunshine Pty Ltd (formerly CDC Victoria 4 Pty Ltd);(g)CDC Oakleigh Pty Ltd (formerly W. Sinclair & Sons Proprietary Limited);(h)CDC Victoria 2 Pty Ltd (deregistered on 27 March 2012);(i)CDC Victoria 3 Pty Ltd (deregistered on 27 March 2012);(j)West Transit Bus Lines Pty Ltd (deregistered on 27 March 2012);(k)North Sunshine Bus Service Pty Limited (deregistered on 20 October 2019);(l)Eastern Suburbs Omnibus Services Proprietary Limited (deregistered on 27 March 2012);(m)Western Coach Services Pty Ltd (deregistered on 27 March 2012); and(n)St Albans Bus Service Pty Ltd (deregistered on 20 October 2019).

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established