Re Carpentaria Gold Pty Ltd & Elizabeth Walsh

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read

LAND COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:  Re Carpentaria Gold Pty Ltd & Elizabeth Walsh [2012] QLC 0060

PARTIES:In the matter of Mining Lease 1753 – Application by Carpentaria Gold Pty Ltd for determination of compensation payable to Elizabeth Walsh

FILE NO:MRA187-12

PROCEEDING:  Application for determination of compensation

DELIVERED ON:                  25 October 2012

DELIVERED AT:                   Brisbane

MEMBER:Mr BR O’Connor, Judicial Registrar

ORDERS:1. I determine compensation under s.281 in the sum of $500.

2. I award an additional amount of $50 in accordance with s.281(4)(e).

3.    I direct that the Applicant pay the total compensation in the sum of $550.00 to the current landowner within three months of notification of renewal of the mining lease by the Mining Registrar.

4.    In the absence of an application from either side within 14 days of this decision, no costs are to be awarded.

CATCHWORDS:                  MINING LEASE – DETERMINATION OF COMPENSATION

Mineral Resources Act 1989, s.279, 281

Smith v Cameron [1986-87] 11 QLCR

Shaw v Heritage Holdings Pty Ltd [1992-93] 14 QLCR

Mitchell v Oakhill and Mitchell (10 March 1998) unreported

APPEARANCES:                  Not applicable – Heard on the Papers

Background

  1. The Applicant, Carpentaria Gold Pty Ltd, seeks the renewal of Mining Lease 1753 in the Charters Towers District.  The Applicant seeks a term of 17 years.  The application was lodged at the office of the Mining Registrar Charters Towers on 13 July 2011.

  2. There is dispute between the parties as to whether the Mining Lease is partly located on Lot 3 on MHP 15821 owned by Elizabeth Walsh, the Respondent.  If it is not, no question of compensation arises.  Both parties have made extensive submissions on this question which is considered below.

Lease Boundary Dispute

  1. Various written submissions were supplied by the parties.  They are as follows:

    Applicant’s Written Material

    1.    Compensation Statement   -          29 May 2012

    2.    Affidavit of Lamb  -          29 May 2012

    3.    Reply to Respondent’s

    Compensation Statement  -          2 July 2012

    4.    Second Affidavit of Lamb   -          12 July 2012

    5.    Letter of rejection of offer  -          21 September 2012

Respondent’s Written Material

1.   Letter of Elizabeth Walsh   -          3 May 2012

2.   Letter of Elizabeth Walsh   -          24 May 2012

3.   Letter of Elizabeth Walsh   -          8 June 2012

4.   Letter of Elizabeth Walsh   -          12 June 2012

5.   Letter of Elizabeth Walsh   -          10 September 2012

6.   Letter of Elizabeth Walsh  -          5 October 2012

7.   Letter of Elizabeth Walsh  -          8 October 2012

  1. A telephone directions hearing was also held on 28 August 2012 at the Court’s request in an attempt to clarify certain material in the written submissions and possibly resolve the matter without Court determination. 

  2. A further offer by Mrs Walsh seeking the Applicant to purchase the whole of Lot 3 was rejected by the Applicant.

  3. Both parties have consented to the matter now being determined on the papers.

  4. This may not be the ideal process, given the apparent complexity of the boundary issue.  However, the relatively small amount in dispute, the location of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Re Carpentaria Gold Pty Ltd & Elizabeth Walsh and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] QLC 60
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Land Court of Queensland was presented with a case involving Carpentaria Gold Pty Ltd and Elizabeth Walsh concerning a mining lease renewal application. The primary dispute centered on whether Mining Lease 1753, which Carpentaria Gold sought to renew, overlapped with Lot 3 on MHP 15821, owned by Elizabeth Walsh. If there was an overlap, the court had to determine the compensation payable to Walsh. The legal issues revolved around the interpretation of the lease's boundaries as described in the Instrument of Lease and the subsequent survey reports. Carpentaria Gold argued that the lease overlapped with Walsh’s property by 59.21 square meters and sought compensation of $500. In contrast, Walsh contended that there was no overlap and that Carpentaria Gold should negotiate the purchase of her entire property.

The court carefully reviewed the written submissions and the telephone directions hearing transcript, which included expert input from a surveyor and the Acting Mining Registrar. The surveyor's report, based on an on-site inspection, indicated an overlap of 59 square meters, supported by the lease's description and the Acting Mining Registrar's sketch map. The court found that the lease did indeed overlap with Lot 3 by 59 square meters, primarily because the lease's bearings and distances took precedence over conflicting measurements from other sources. The court also noted that the small amount in dispute and the detailed submissions made it appropriate to proceed without a physical inspection of the site. Given the overlap, the court determined that Carpentaria Gold should compensate Walsh $550 within three months of the mining lease's renewal notification, including an additional $50 for the compulsory nature of the action. The court refrained from ordering Carpentaria Gold to purchase Lot 3 and did not address any potential trespass issues beyond the determined overlap.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.